The Analysis: A Movie and TV Podcast
Aug 9, 2026 · 37 min · 10 segments
Barry Irving returns to The Analysis to break down Spider-Man: Brand New Day and ask the big question: did Marvel actually deliver the definitive Tom Holland Spider-Man movie—or did the MCU get in its…
Barry IrvingGuest
Um, so, I mean, saying it, saying, oh, I thought it was mid is selling both the movie and my reaction to the movie a little
bit.

But if I'm being perfectly honest, I walked out of the theater pretty underwhelmed.

So by the time I had seen the movie, it had already been breaking records and people were already giving it the all time raves, rants and raves.

And I think, just mentioned, you know, the eras, and it's been an interesting journey for this Tom Holland era.

We end, we have this great, you know, I mean, Marvel's getting criticized for being a nostalgia bait, but we had this really, I feel like, worthwhile trip through memory lane.

And I think this is, particular iteration had its own sort of gift and curse power and responsibility situation where it's had this gift of being connected to the greater Marvel Cinematic Universe but I also feel like perhaps and at least in this film it wound up being a bit of a hindrance because I think The last film we started with this clean slate and this final image of Spider-Man web slinging.

And it was like a true clean slate or it felt like it was going to be a clean slate.

accurate depiction of Spider-Man for about 30 to 40 minutes, and then we just get a lot of MCU stuff.

We get characters from the old trilogy get shoved back into the storyline, and this Jean Grey situation that we'll probably talk about in a little bit, but I just feel like There was a real chance to give a full, fresh take on Spider-Man that I really thought got weighed down in the second and third acts of this movie.

Um, so, I mean, saying it, saying, oh, I thought it was mid is selling both the movie and my reaction to the movie a little
bit.

But if I'm being perfectly honest, I walked out of the theater pretty underwhelmed.

So by the time I had seen the movie, it had already been breaking records and people were already giving it the all time raves, rants and raves.

And I think, just mentioned, you know, the eras, and it's been an interesting journey for this Tom Holland era.

We end, we have this great, you know, I mean, Marvel's getting criticized for being a nostalgia bait, but we had this really, I feel like, worthwhile trip through memory lane.

And I think this is, particular iteration had its own sort of gift and curse power and responsibility situation where it's had this gift of being connected to the greater Marvel Cinematic Universe but I also feel like perhaps and at least in this film it wound up being a bit of a hindrance because I think The last film we started with this clean slate and this final image of Spider-Man web slinging.

And it was like a true clean slate or it felt like it was going to be a clean slate.

accurate depiction of Spider-Man for about 30 to 40 minutes, and then we just get a lot of MCU stuff.

We get characters from the old trilogy get shoved back into the storyline, and this Jean Grey situation that we'll probably talk about in a little bit, but I just feel like There was a real chance to give a full, fresh take on Spider-Man that I really thought got weighed down in the second and third acts of this movie.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.