- Speakers
- Shalom RosnerHost
But the question is, can he be a shliach for someone else? That was the question that we ended off with.
Can the Katan, again, this is how the Pneumosha and other Mepharshim read the Gemara.
We're going to go with the Pshat that this whole Gemara that we're involved in is talking about a Katan.
So can a Katan be mocked as an animal on behalf of somebody else? So Gemara asks, well, he's involved, he can become Tame, so he is in the world of of that area of halacha, so he should be able to be makdish, or do we say, no, he's excluded from shlichus, in general, and that general kolotor, kolotor principle, let's read it again, a few lines off of the bar, since he becomes tamim with them, since he's involved in the area of halacha, and it's shayach to him, he should be able to be a shlich, or, or because he's always excluded from shlichus, and he can't, So, he said, Reb Yudin.
Again, we're going with the Pnei Moshe's answer that the Gemara says, what are you talking about? Of course he cannot.
So, you see, he is involved in Shumas and Maisa Midar Raisa, and yet, We're going to change the gersa.
That's the source of the katan being excluded from shlichus is by a precious truma.
But the question is, can he be a shliach for someone else? That was the question that we ended off with.
Can the Katan, again, this is how the Pneumosha and other Mepharshim read the Gemara.
We're going to go with the Pshat that this whole Gemara that we're involved in is talking about a Katan.
So can a Katan be mocked as an animal on behalf of somebody else? So Gemara asks, well, he's involved, he can become Tame, so he is in the world of of that area of halacha, so he should be able to be makdish, or do we say, no, he's excluded from shlichus, in general, and that general kolotor, kolotor principle, let's read it again, a few lines off of the bar, since he becomes tamim with them, since he's involved in the area of halacha, and it's shayach to him, he should be able to be a shlich, or, or because he's always excluded from shlichus, and he can't, So, he said, Reb Yudin.
Again, we're going with the Pnei Moshe's answer that the Gemara says, what are you talking about? Of course he cannot.
So, you see, he is involved in Shumas and Maisa Midar Raisa, and yet, We're going to change the gersa.
That's the source of the katan being excluded from shlichus is by a precious truma.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.
