Temurah
BookWikipedia
168
MENTIONS
41
EPISODES
27
PODCASTS
Search complete. 168 mentions across 41 episodes found for "Temurah".
Oct 11, 2026
Shaya KatzHOST
So that's number two, which is the difference, or the commonality between Bechor, Bechor, Maaser Behemah.
Shaya KatzHOST
And then Temuras.
Shaya KatzHOST
Somebody does Temura with a Bechor and Maaser Behemah.
Shaya KatzHOST
The Temura works.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Not all rishonim agree to this.
Shalom RosnerHOST
If you look in the Tosafot, Tosafot in Temura says Beferish.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Tosafot in Temura on the bottom of Yud tes avei beis, and the Rama also says this.
Shalom RosnerHOST
The Rama, the, the Tosafot says, [Hebrew].
Shalom RosnerHOST
Wow.
Shalom RosnerHOST
But by meiser and bechor, right, bechor, it has a mum.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Meiser, even if it has a mum, it still has the halacha.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Temurah.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
And a, a third commonality between Maaser Behema and Bechorah, Temuras.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
That if you, uh, uh, try to effectuate Temurah with a Bechorah, Maaser Behema on a, on-- meaning you try to extend its Kedushah onto another Behema, even though the Kedushas Temurah is gonna be Chal, the Temurah animal is not gonna be brought on the Mizbeach.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
Whereas other Kochim, the Temurah is also brought on the Mizbeach just like the original animal, meaning the, the Kedushah doesn't leave the original animal, but the Kedushah is Chal on the new animal, so much so that it's even brought on the Mizbeach.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
Uh, Temuras Kochim is Korban the Mizbeach.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
The Gemara Darshans from Rak Kochtecha l'Rabos says that Temuros, that they're Hu Korban Mizbeach.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
Temuras Bechorah Maaser is not brought on the Mizbeach.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
The Gemara Darshans in Temurah, because, "Lo tipodeh kodashaim," we Darshan, "Kodashaim," "Heim kraven ve'ein Temurasan krava." That it's Dovcha Heim that are Korban on the Mizbeach.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
So these are Dinim DeOraita that you don't have by Maaser Behema and by Bechorah.
Moshe ElefantHOST
And Bechor has, even has a Mum, the Torah says, Lo Yevakem B'tov L'ra, and therefore they have a Kedushat Haguf even though they are Ba'al Mum.
Moshe ElefantHOST
Temurah.
Moshe ElefantHOST
The Halakha is by Bechor or Maaser, the Halakha is that if you make a Temurah, even though the Halakha is that the Temurah is somewhat effective, but the Temurah Korban will not be put on the Mizbeach.
Moshe ElefantHOST
Here, by all other Korbanot, the Temurah animal is also brought as a Korban.
Moshe ElefantHOST
Achilah.
Moshe ElefantHOST
A Bechor and Maaser Behemah that become a Ba'al Mum- Are eaten.
speaker_0HOST
Then you don't.
speaker_0HOST
Rashi says, And therefore by Meisr and by Bechor, you cannot be makar of a Temurah.
speaker_0HOST
It works, but you cannot be makar of a Temurah of a Meisr or Bechor.
speaker_0HOST
That's the third point.
speaker_0HOST
And the fourth point is achila.
Darren PlatzkyHOST
[speaking foreign language] any Kodshim that had a Mum before you Makdish it, right, the Kedusha doesn't Kal.
Darren PlatzkyHOST
[speaking foreign language] Number three, [speaking foreign language] if you apply Temurah to a Korban Bechor or to, or to a, a Maaser animal, you don't bring that as a Korban.
Darren PlatzkyHOST
[speaking foreign language] you can't do anything, you can't redeem, you can't exchange nothing.
Darren PlatzkyHOST
[speaking foreign language] so also there's no Din of Temurah with regards to, uh, to, to, to those animals.
Darren PlatzkyHOST
Even though there's Din, it's a Knas.
Darren PlatzkyHOST
I mean, it does... now they're actually become Korbanot.
speaker_0HOST
And that might tie in in a deeper place, that kind of sugi.
speaker_0HOST
What we do is Chal, that's a big sugi in Temurah.
speaker_0HOST
Whether what you do, like an issue that you do is a chal or not chal.
speaker_0HOST
I don't know how it all works together.
Phil KareshHOST
And the gemara makes a comparison.
Phil KareshHOST
From our world of Tzulimukdash and Temurah to the world of Bechor and Meister.
Phil KareshHOST
Look at this.
Phil KareshHOST
Why can't it be eaten by the owners? Okay, it's a momkavua, but you'll be po'ed to it and give it to the owners.
Phil KareshHOST
Where does the Gemara even have a havamina that such a thing should be possible? Says the Gemara, When it comes to the temurah of bechor maiser, we do have this halachot, it's not.
Phil KareshHOST
We have a mishnah, one that we will see in the next mosech of temurah.
Phil KareshHOST
If you have an animal that is bechor maiser, And you do the Isser of Temurah, and you transfer it from Betsy, the animal, to whatever the other animal is.
Phil KareshHOST
So the halacha is, The halachic status of all of the progeny of that Temurah are going to be the same.
Moshe FrankelHOST
Now, what's the shitah of Rabbi Yosi? The shitah is if someone said...
Moshe FrankelHOST
It, it's the shitah is in Temurah.
Moshe FrankelHOST
If someone said that, "Ha'areza Temurah's oila Temurah shlam," he has a oila, he has a shlam, and he says about an animal, "This animal should be instead of the, the oila and shlam." If he would've said oila, it would've been an oila.
Moshe FrankelHOST
If he would've said shlam, it would've been a shlam.
Moshe FrankelHOST
Instead, he said, "Ha'areza Temurah's oila Temurah shlam." Now, it can't be both.
Moshe FrankelHOST
So Rabbi Yosi says that we take into account both parts of the statement, and you let the animal that you made it-- You said Temurah's oil, Temurah shlam him, you let it graze until it gets a mom, and then you sell it, and you bring, give its money, and use its money, half for an oila and half for a shlam.
Moshe FrankelHOST
So therefore, it's g-- That's the shitah that says, "Begmar dvar vadam nitzvas." We don't only look at the beginning of the words, we also look at the end of the, the end of the words.
Moshe FrankelHOST
And therefore, "Vaha'i nadar upis choimoi," he made a neder with a- Torah Anytime ... pischo, with a Pesach, with a way out.
speaker_0HOST
In other words, it has enough innate meaning.
speaker_0HOST
Kedusha in what it is, since it was Bakhtish first only then developed among them, that it would be able to make a Temurah.
speaker_0HOST
The Temurah that was made after the animals redeemed would die.
speaker_0HOST
Why does it die? Well, simply, you have no other choice.
speaker_0HOST
possibility because hey what else are you supposed to do colon liquor if you say one just offers a carbon question mark comma can't do that because where did it get its kedusha well from the other thing that was declared that made this one cut well the other thing is it pushed off kedusha Now, okay, fine, so if you want to say, well, I just want to redeem it.
31 more episodes mention Temurah.
Create an account to see the whole feed, search across every transcript, and follow the entities you care about.