Jerusalem Talmud
BookWikipedia
222
MENTIONS
73
EPISODES
50
PODCASTS
Search complete. 222 mentions across 73 episodes found for "Jerusalem Talmud".
Sep 14, 2026
Gavin McDowellGUEST
That might not be what it means for some people, but like that bothered me a lot when I was writing the book because Pirkei De-Rabbi Eliezer never does that.
Gavin McDowellGUEST
It never, it's like we have, we hear about the synoptic problem in rabbinic studies where you talk about parallel passages and the two Talmuds, parallel passages between Genesis Rabbah and the Palestinian Talmud, places where it's just like it's nearly identical or you could tell it's basically the same thing.
Gavin McDowellGUEST
None of that in Pirkei De-Rabbi Eliezer.
Gavin McDowellGUEST
That created a huge headache for me because like this text, it must have known Genesis Rabbah, but there's no, there's lots of stuff related to Genesis Rabbah, including the story of Rabbi Eliezer himself, which is like the introductory chapters of the book, how Eliezer ben Hyrcanus became a great scholar of Torah.
Ari FedergrunHOST
Because he had this protection, potentially.
Ari FedergrunHOST
That's what the Talmud Yerushalmi says.
Ari FedergrunHOST
They had this protection.
Ari FedergrunHOST
Then afterwards, he died.
Michael RosensweigHOST
Likely, that's what the Keskuni was, uh, referring to.
Michael RosensweigHOST
And we'll see in a moment, that is the way the Yerushalmi understands the Halakha, the Mishnah.
Michael RosensweigHOST
The Yerushalmi doesn't have any gezeirat Raba.
Michael RosensweigHOST
Am HaRaba, Gemara says, "Im d'oraisa b'mikdash shechi takina, ve'od ala'av melacha hi d'istrich kar le mute." Right? It's, uh, chok ma'avein a melacha.
Michael RosensweigHOST
So the Gemara concludes, Rabbanan hu d'gazir k'deRaba, hakoch ya'amu t'kiat shofar.
Michael RosensweigHOST
Zeh ursham yivlanah biyadah v'yeilech et tzvaki l'omad.
Michael RosensweigHOST
Ya'aver darut al mos moshe s'rabin, v'chaynu taima d'lulav, v'chaynu taima d'megillah.
Michael RosensweigHOST
So the pashtos when you walk away from this Gemara, you say, "Wow, there was this amazing havamina that this is din d'oraisa." But l'mascana, it's just a gezeirat Raba, right? However, number one, the Yerushalmi doesn't hold that way.
Daniel KorobkinHOST
But in the course of dealing with that shailah, Rav HaLevi methodically presented the different situations for when a kehillah's minhag could and could not be changed.
Daniel KorobkinHOST
He cites the Talmud Yerushalmi, that so strong is a community minhag that sometimes it even trumps halakha.
Daniel KorobkinHOST
Minhag mevatel halakha.
Daniel KorobkinHOST
However, the application of this is generally restricted to cases of finance, such as upholding local business transaction practices.
Ari BergmannGUEST
And it tells the story of two people who are in yeshiva.
Ari BergmannGUEST
One of them was Rabbi Yochanan, a great rabbi that actually is attributed that he did the Palestinian Talmud, and then you have somebody called Ilfa.
Ari BergmannGUEST
Ilfa was somebody who decided, both, both at that time decided to go work, and they go to work, and the angel says, "We're going to kill them." They left life, eternal life, spiritual life, to deal with the mundane.
Ari BergmannGUEST
So Rabbi Yochanan heard it, and Ilfa didn't hear the angels.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Safek leket, safek leket v'chulu.
Shalom RosnerHOST
And he quotes the, the Gemara quotes the Yerushalmi, "Ani verash hatsdiku, hatsdiku b'matnosav." It's a special limud.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Special limud based on the one where, one where Shloka just quoted also now, uh, Lechumra.
Shalom RosnerHOST
The Rama adds though, "Avo mi shehichtish davar belashon shemusu pachim bo." If you have something that's Safek Sakah, fine.
9 MINS LATER
Shalom RosnerHOST
L'fisha siyu es Yisrael b'yitziyasam mimitzrayim she'ein l'cha kolecha ve'echad she'ein loshivim chamorim lefanav t'unin kesef v'zahav v'avam tovos u'margaliyas.
Shalom RosnerHOST
The, the donkeys, the chamorim helped the Jews when they left, so that's why we have a mitzvah with them.
Shalom RosnerHOST
The Yerushalmi has a different pshat.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Not on Bechoros, there is no Yerushalmi on Bechoros, but Yerushalmi on Shkalim.
David KadoshHOST
It requires precisely the zirizut, the alacrity that we spoke about on day number 8.
David KadoshHOST
The Talmud in Uxin concludes with a statement that the sages chose quite deliberately as the final word of the entire Talmud Yerushalmi.
David KadoshHOST
Hashem found no vessel capable of holding blessing for the Jewish people other than peace.
David KadoshHOST
every blessing, health, prosperity, wisdom, children, rain, harvest, requires a vessel to hold it.
speaker_1HOST
But you may recall, we've said the story over, that in the 19th century, some individual decided that they were going to pull one of the greatest frauds in Jewish history.
speaker_1HOST
And so they came out with the Yerushalmi on Kaddishim.
speaker_1HOST
They released the Yerushalmi, which we know, and the Rambam mentioned it here before, that there were actually five orders of the Yerushalmi that were written, not just four as we have them.
speaker_1HOST
And so the fifth one, which is Kadashim, is missing.
speaker_1HOST
So someone released it, like they found it and they published it.
speaker_1HOST
They had different proofs.
speaker_1HOST
that it was fraudulent, and that it was just some very clever person who, for some really mysterious reason, decided to try to create their own thing like that.
speaker_1HOST
So, Rav Yosef Rosen, the Raguchover, his explanation for how he knew that this was a fraudulent work was because he said, every Mesechta in Gemara, in Bavli, in Yerushalmi, every Mesechta has a rabbi, at least one rabbi, that's unique to that Masechta.
Michael RosensweigHOST
And we'll see in a moment.
Michael RosensweigHOST
That is the way the Yerushalmi understands L'Halacha, the Mishnah.
Michael RosensweigHOST
Yerushalmi doesn't have any Gzeira Darab.
Michael RosensweigHOST
Amar Rava, G'mar says, Yimid Ar-Aisa, B'mikta Sheikha Takina, Ba'od Halav Malacha, Hidnit Strich Karlamuteh.
Michael RosensweigHOST
So the Gemara concludes, So the Pashtos, when you walk away from this Gemara, you say,
speaker_2UNKNOWN
wow, there was this amazing
Michael RosensweigHOST
Habamina, that this is a Din Doraesah, But L'maskana, it's just a Xerov rabbo.
Michael RosensweigHOST
Right? However, number one, the Yerushalmi doesn't hold that way.
Baruch SimonHOST
Within the Bible.
Baruch SimonHOST
Rosh Hashanah always likes to quote to Yerushalmi that they had a kasha, but then Yerushalmi answers the kasha.
Baruch SimonHOST
But if you want to see the Mishalmi, that's here on the last page.
Baruch SimonHOST
But maybe, could there be a Svara, he wants to suggest, the Leivaron, that maybe, maybe Mach L'shita is that you don't blow shofar on Rosh Hashanah because of the passing of Zikr and Shua, and Yom Shua, but those Zikr were only by Rosh Hashanah.
14 MINS LATER
Baruch SimonHOST
like to, you could.
speaker_0PANELIST
Okay.
speaker_0PANELIST
So if you want to say Yerushalmi as opposed to Bavli, fine.
speaker_0PANELIST
Okay? But if you want to say in the Bavli that the Shita of Rav Levi Bar Lachma continues, you can't say that because at the end of the Gemara, It's clearly rejected.
63 more episodes mention Jerusalem Talmud.
Create an account to see the whole feed, search across every transcript, and follow the entities you care about.