Rishonim
1.4k
MENTIONS
552
EPISODES
163
PODCASTS
Search complete. 1364 mentions across 552 episodes found for "Rishonim".
Sep 12, 2026
Shalom RosnerHOST
Achazel patter.
Shalom RosnerHOST
There is a machloket Rishonim, Rashi and Tosafot not so much here, but in Bava Kama, Daf Samech Vav.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Does this mean that I s-- designated the reishas hageyz and then I colored it, am patter? Or is it that I colored the entire wool, all the wool that I have? Tosafot says, "If you designate the reishas hageyz and then you, uh, color it, so give from the rest of your wool." Why, why are you patter? Why does that, why did that lose the chiyuv? Because it does- it doesn't have any...
Shalom RosnerHOST
Tosafot says.
Shalom RosnerHOST
And the Rashba also, just Rashba Lisa B'Tzarich Yin.
Shalom RosnerHOST
The Rashba here quotes this Kashah that Tosafot says later on, why didn't the Gemara use this, um, for Rav Chisda? Ve'nirah, uh, he said, "Ve'ikra meimar," and he quotes, he quotes the, uh, possibility that Tosafot's quoted, and then he quotes, "Ama ein ocheia da mishtarshei mi gaumi pa- mi praoba chovo." Okay, discusses this, but this is the, um, [lip smacks] relationship between Rav Chisda and, and the Mishnah.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Also, discussion a little bit in the Rishonim that it's not exactly the same as, let's say, gezela.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Right? We know from Bava Kama there's also kinds of shini kone.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
We think of Shinoi Kona, over here it's Midin of Matnas Kohuna, that you're not going to give the Matana because it went through with Shinoi.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
So there are a lot of details about this Halacha that the Rishonim discuss.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
We're not going to be able to get to everything, I'll just give you the Rashi Prakin.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
The Rishonim discuss and debate where does this Petor come from, that when you're Tzovea, all of a sudden your potter from Resh Tzageh is.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
They also debate whether you have to have Kavanah to steal it by coloring it, or your potter, even without Kavanah to steal it, just by being Tzovea, by accident, you'd also be Kona.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
Is it Dafka because it's a Maisag Zela and you're having Kavanah to be Gozel? The third thing they argue about is how much of the wool needs to be colored in order for you to be pater.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
Meaning, okay, now you get to keep the shiur.
Aryeh LebowitzHOST
So what, you gain because of your avera? So now you're not going to have to pay anything? And if you don't have to pay the money, so should you at least pay the money to be Yotzei Dei Shemayim? Now all of those four makhloksim, those four issues, although they sound like four separate issues, are very much related to each other in how you understand fundamentally what the din is about.
Moshe ElefantHOST
when you did, when this person died it, he changed it.
Moshe ElefantHOST
And therefore, the Rishonim point out that although, as we just said, and we know, as we said, the Gemara Maseach Bar Mitzvah says that when you make a shinui, it becomes yours, the Allah is, it only becomes yours when you make a shinui, when the shinui that you made is a, when the shinui that you made is with the intention of stealing it.
Moshe ElefantHOST
So if somebody, according to those who are showing them, did a shinui in the Rosh Hashanah, he colored it, but he did not have any intention to steal it, so then the fact that there was a shinui would be immaterial.
Moshe ElefantHOST
However, those that disagree, they say that the Mishnah is teaching us that the obligation of Rosh Hashanah is only is when it's in its original state.
8 MINS LATER
Moshe ElefantHOST
That you're not allowed to cut or work with kut shebedek habayis.
Moshe ElefantHOST
answers the Gemara, that haol halacha is mid-Durabonan.
Moshe ElefantHOST
Why did the Rabbanah institute such a rule? Explain the Rishonim.
Moshe ElefantHOST
Because as we just learned, you're not allowed to work with Katshe HaGov.
Shalom RosnerHOST
So the rashi says, When you're osing a mitzvah, you get more schar.
Shalom RosnerHOST
But if you look in the ran, and the other is shown in there, the ran says the beginning of the deals with all of the questions that all the Rishonim say.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Let's say according to the according to the Rambam, here.
Shalom RosnerHOST
Well, we'll backtrack for a second.
Shalom RosnerHOST
According to the Rambam, there's a mitzvah of kiddushin.
Shalom RosnerHOST
So you can say mitzvah means kiddushin.
Shalom RosnerHOST
But if you say, like some other Rishonim, the Rosh and others, there's no mitzvah of getting married.
Shalom RosnerHOST
There's only mitzvah of puruvu.
Rabbi StarkHOST
150 years ago, nobody learned chucim.
Rabbi StarkHOST
Try to find Rishonim on chucim.
Rabbi StarkHOST
What's going on? You see the movement, you see the sprouting.
Rabbi StarkHOST
There's so much going on here, right? And you being here, even if you're not learning chucim, maybe you wanna have a chucim, uh, mishnas just to get [laughs] get involved.
Yaakov HarariHOST
What is it? You're just reading 10 Pesukim about Shofus.
Yaakov HarariHOST
So the Rishonim handled that Shiloh.
Yaakov HarariHOST
And they talk about how we have to be Metsape for the Shofar of Rosh Hashanah.
Yaakov HarariHOST
Which means the Din.
Shloimie FriedmanHOST
We find that Adam who touches a meiz becomes tamei, becomes a avatuma.
Shloimie FriedmanHOST
And kelim that touch a meiz become an avi avos hatuma, like the Rabbeinu Tam davka by metal [speaking foreign language] and like the other shitas or Rishonim, it's by all kelim.
Shloimie FriedmanHOST
So [speaking foreign language] we find that Adam is more chomer than kelim, and sometimes kelim is more chomer than Adam.
Shloimie FriedmanHOST
Shekelim, this is the case that kelim is more chomer than other Adam is shekelim shlosha.
Shloimie FriedmanHOST
Mishnah Dalet, Adam v'kelim metamei-- Mishnah He, Adam ub'gadim tamei im be'zov, both Adam and b'gadim could become tamei from a zav.
Shloimie FriedmanHOST
However, [speaking foreign language] each one you have a chumrah over the other one.
Shloimie FriedmanHOST
Adam, the chumrah over b'gadim is [speaking foreign language] the Adam who touches a zav, and this Rishonim all speak out is while he's still touching the zav, is metameh b'gadim.
Shloimie FriedmanHOST
He's going to be metameh b'gadim.
Gideon RothsteinHOST
I've done the shchita perfectly right, and I've shechted two-thirds of the simanim, And then something goes wrong.
Gideon RothsteinHOST
So that's a debate among the Rishonim.
Gideon RothsteinHOST
There are those who held that I can ignore it, because after all, the shkita is already valid.
Gideon RothsteinHOST
Maybe I just say, once there's a valid shkita, the animal has been slaughtered in a valid way.
Mati NovickHOST
הלך אביו וכן מכולי כתובה שתתהול האישה כתובתה מן הפחות שבמנפיות כיצד נעשה אישה במקום וגרשה מקום אחר אם היו מאות מקום הנישויים טובות ממאות מקום הגירושין נותן לה ממאות מקום הגירושין ואם היו מאות מקום הגירושין טובות ממאות מקום הנישויים נותן לה ממאות מקום הנישויים The final leniency of the payment of the ketubah is mentioned in the Gemara as an explicit consequence of the fact that ketubah is derabanan.
Mati NovickHOST
And therefore, while the Rambam accepts it as part of his general shita that ketubah is derabanan, those Rishonim who believe that ketubah is doraita reject it.
Mati NovickHOST
This relates to a case where a man marries a woman in one place and divorces her elsewhere.
Mati NovickHOST
The ketubah includes a certain sum, expressed in ma'ot, but the unit of currency called a ma'ah changes in value from place to place, depending on the exact proportion of silver relative to other metals.
Mati NovickHOST
But Ruvain does not fulfill perivirvia if both of his grandchildren come from only one of his children, even if the two grandchildren are boy and a girl.
Mati NovickHOST
Other Rishonim, like Tosod and Latour, believe that as long as the two grandchildren come from Ruvain's son and daughter, one grandchild from each, there is no requirement for the grandchildren themselves to be one boy and one girl.
Mati NovickHOST
the Shulchan Aruch accepts the more stringent view of the Rambam.
Mati NovickHOST
If a non-Jewish man has children, a son and a daughter, and both he and they subsequently convert, then he fulfills Piri Avirivya in this manner.
542 more episodes mention Rishonim.
Create an account to see the whole feed, search across every transcript, and follow the entities you care about.