"Hi, sisters.
I love your show and all of you.
Thank you so much.
My question is, why aren't detainees being protected under the Eighth Amendment, designed to prohibit cruel and unusual punishment? Thank you very much."
And, you know, it seems so obvious, the Eighth Amendment, of course, protects us against cruel and unusual punishment.
The Supreme Court has actually interpreted the Eighth Amendment to apply only to situations of punishment.
But when it comes to detainees, the thought is they're not actually being punished.
They are being handled in an administrative proceeding, and so they are only held so they can't run away, and then they are deported from the country, uh, perhaps to one of these third countries.
So it doesn't apply to pretrial detention or immigration detention or even deportation.
So great question, but according to the Supreme Court, doesn't apply to this situation.
"Hi, sisters.
I love your show and all of you.
Thank you so much.
My question is, why aren't detainees being protected under the Eighth Amendment, designed to prohibit cruel and unusual punishment? Thank you very much."
And, you know, it seems so obvious, the Eighth Amendment, of course, protects us against cruel and unusual punishment.
The Supreme Court has actually interpreted the Eighth Amendment to apply only to situations of punishment.
But when it comes to detainees, the thought is they're not actually being punished.
They are being handled in an administrative proceeding, and so they are only held so they can't run away, and then they are deported from the country, uh, perhaps to one of these third countries.
So it doesn't apply to pretrial detention or immigration detention or even deportation.
So great question, but according to the Supreme Court, doesn't apply to this situation.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.