The University of Chicago Press Podcast
Nov 13, 2026 · 1 hr 3 min · 29 segments
A daring reassessment of the critical method that reshaped the humanities and an invitation to imagine new ways of doing history. The genealogical method—a mode of historical analysis that shows that…
Jason Ānanda Josephson StormGuestMorteza HajizadehHostSo is it fair to say that, you know, based on the introduction of the overview you just gave us and the fact that it's sort of an auto-destruction, is it fair to say it's sort of a deconstruction of the idea of genealogy, both Nietzsche and Foucault?
Yeah, it's a genealogy, but in that respect, a critical history of critical history.
So to take a step back and give you the context for the book, for your listeners who haven't listened to our previous interview on the myth of disenchantment or other things, this is part of a three-part trilogy, although you can read them in whatever order and pick them up, on the past and future of the human sciences.
In the myth of disenchantment, I was describing the birth of the humanities and social sciences around the problem of modernity.
In the metamodernism book, I talk about the future of the human sciences and have a program for what I hope we should do next.
In the middle, this book was an attempt to grapple with the present of the human sciences And in particular, the attitude to history, which we might associate with postmodernism, which is no longer the celebration of rupture that is in the critique of the myth of modernity that I challenged in the book earlier, but a new notion of kind of critical history.
And the watchword for critical history in many fields is genealogy.
And so turning it on itself, I provide a critical history of critical history, including both Nietzsche and Foucault, who are usually in that lineage, but also talking about how it functions.
But even more so in the first chapter, I'm challenging the way that genealogy functions as a scholarly genre in the contemporary Anglophone Academy.
There are like hundreds of books, like you can probably see on my bookshelf behind me, like at least there's Talal Asad's Genealogies of Religion.
There are books, tons of books with the title genealogy in them.
And most of them are not when scholars are doing it, tracking pedigrees or family lineages, they're doing critical history.
And one of the things that was curious, you know, again, as I said from the beginning is what is this critical? Why is this such a common genre? And indeed, as I discovered in the book, it's not marginal.
In other words, there are literally thousands of works that refer to themselves within his genealogies.
And insofar as that term means something, it often involves a footnote to one of Foucault's most famous essays, not always, but often, an essay by Foucault called Nietzsche Genealogy History.
And when they're not Foucault-ing that, they're referencing Nietzsche or Foucault in one way or another.
And most of them define themselves as critical histories or think of what they're doing as a kind of critical history.
So yeah, so as a whole, it's a critical history of critical history, turning its own techniques on itself to figure out where they break and where they don't.
So is it fair to say that, you know, based on the introduction of the overview you just gave us and the fact that it's sort of an auto-destruction, is it fair to say it's sort of a deconstruction of the idea of genealogy, both Nietzsche and Foucault?
Yeah, it's a genealogy, but in that respect, a critical history of critical history.
So to take a step back and give you the context for the book, for your listeners who haven't listened to our previous interview on the myth of disenchantment or other things, this is part of a three-part trilogy, although you can read them in whatever order and pick them up, on the past and future of the human sciences.
In the myth of disenchantment, I was describing the birth of the humanities and social sciences around the problem of modernity.
In the metamodernism book, I talk about the future of the human sciences and have a program for what I hope we should do next.
In the middle, this book was an attempt to grapple with the present of the human sciences And in particular, the attitude to history, which we might associate with postmodernism, which is no longer the celebration of rupture that is in the critique of the myth of modernity that I challenged in the book earlier, but a new notion of kind of critical history.
And the watchword for critical history in many fields is genealogy.
And so turning it on itself, I provide a critical history of critical history, including both Nietzsche and Foucault, who are usually in that lineage, but also talking about how it functions.
But even more so in the first chapter, I'm challenging the way that genealogy functions as a scholarly genre in the contemporary Anglophone Academy.
There are like hundreds of books, like you can probably see on my bookshelf behind me, like at least there's Talal Asad's Genealogies of Religion.
There are books, tons of books with the title genealogy in them.
And most of them are not when scholars are doing it, tracking pedigrees or family lineages, they're doing critical history.
And one of the things that was curious, you know, again, as I said from the beginning is what is this critical? Why is this such a common genre? And indeed, as I discovered in the book, it's not marginal.
In other words, there are literally thousands of works that refer to themselves within his genealogies.
And insofar as that term means something, it often involves a footnote to one of Foucault's most famous essays, not always, but often, an essay by Foucault called Nietzsche Genealogy History.
And when they're not Foucault-ing that, they're referencing Nietzsche or Foucault in one way or another.
And most of them define themselves as critical histories or think of what they're doing as a kind of critical history.
So yeah, so as a whole, it's a critical history of critical history, turning its own techniques on itself to figure out where they break and where they don't.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.