New Criticism
Literary developmentWikipedia
43
MENTIONS
8
EPISODES
6
PODCASTS
Search complete. 43 mentions across 8 episodes found for "New Criticism".
Nov 13, 2026
The Genealogy of Genealogy: Nietzsche, Foucault, and the Coils of Critical History with Jason Ānanda Josephson Storm (U Chicago Press, 2026)
J
18:05Jason Ānanda Josephson StormGUEST
And so they ended up importing a range of thinkers from the Francophone Academy to do different kinds of work.
J
18:13Jason Ānanda Josephson StormGUEST
First, Derrida is imported by a bunch of folks at Yale as a way to kind of rebuttrous what was then, what had been a fading model of criticism called New Criticism, which then Derrida was brought in and New Criticism was, in certain respects, modified or rehabilitated into a kind of American form of deconstruction.
J
18:34Jason Ānanda Josephson StormGUEST
In contrast to that, folks, and specifically one of the key figures here is Edward Said, brought in Foucault and the notion of genealogy as a way to restore the study of history to a kind of literary field.
J
18:48Jason Ānanda Josephson StormGUEST
And so Edward Said did this in New Beginnings.
The Genealogy of Genealogy: Nietzsche, Foucault, and the Coils of Critical History with Jason Ānanda Josephson Storm (U Chicago Press, 2026)
J
15:42Jason Ānanda Josephson StormGUEST
And so they ended up importing a range of thinkers from the Francophone Academy to do different kinds of work.
J
15:51Jason Ānanda Josephson StormGUEST
First, Derrida is imported by a bunch of folks at Yale as a way to kind of rebuttrous what was then, what had been a fading model of criticism called New Criticism, which then Derrida was brought in and New Criticism was, in certain respects, modified or rehabilitated into a kind of American form of deconstruction.
J
16:11Jason Ānanda Josephson StormGUEST
In contrast to that, folks, and specifically one of the key figures here is Edward Said, brought in Foucault and the notion of genealogy as a way to restore the study of history to a kind of literary field.
J
16:25Jason Ānanda Josephson StormGUEST
And so Edward Said did this in New Beginnings.
The Genealogy of Genealogy: Nietzsche, Foucault, and the Coils of Critical History with Jason Ānanda Josephson Storm (U Chicago Press, 2026)
J
16:50Jason Ānanda Josephson StormGUEST
And so they ended up importing a range of thinkers from the Francophone Academy to do different kinds of work.
J
16:58Jason Ānanda Josephson StormGUEST
First, Derrida is imported by a bunch of folks at Yale as a way to kind of rebuttrous what was then, what had been a fading model of criticism called New Criticism, which then Derrida was brought in and New Criticism was, in certain respects, modified or rehabilitated into a kind of American form of deconstruction.
J
17:19Jason Ānanda Josephson StormGUEST
In contrast to that, folks, and specifically one of the key figures here is Edward Said, brought in Foucault and the notion of genealogy as a way to restore the study of history to a kind of literary field.
J
17:33Jason Ānanda Josephson StormGUEST
And so Edward Said did this in New Beginnings.
E Michael Jones: Degenerate Moderns
E
46:53E. Michael JonesGUEST
At this point, the Jews took over literary criticism.
E
46:56E. Michael JonesGUEST
So when I was a teenager in high school and as an undergraduate, there was called the New Criticism, and it was a kind of formalism, which basically you didn't talk at all about the biography of the poet.
E
47:11E. Michael JonesGUEST
All you talked about was the form of the poem.
E
47:17E. Michael JonesGUEST
And for some, some poems are really intricate.
E
47:37E. Michael JonesGUEST
You usually always come up with the same thing.
E
47:39E. Michael JonesGUEST
And there was a sense of dissatisfaction with the artificial limits.
E
47:45E. Michael JonesGUEST
Now, I'm saying new criticism was Protestant.
E
47:51E. Michael JonesGUEST
It was basically sola scriptura.
Does a Poem Need Something to Say? with Matthew Buckley Smith (Part 1) | Ep. 158
M
32:44Matthew Buckley SmithGUEST
Yeah, it's hard to say.
M
32:46Matthew Buckley SmithGUEST
I think John Ransom in New Criticism has an observation, because he spends a whole chapter trying to humiliate Ivor Winters.
M
32:56Matthew Buckley SmithGUEST
He says it's basically impossible to speculate convincingly about how a poem was written, even if you are the poet.
M
33:05Matthew Buckley SmithGUEST
Poe, in The Philosophy of Composition, describes in great detail writing The Raven, and I half believe him.
21. African-American Criticism
P
55:12Paul FryHOST
Now finally I want to take up the most controversial example in his essay, one which is a source of outrage for most readers, at the bottom of page 1893 in the left-hand column.
P
55:28Paul FryHOST
He's been talking about the new He's been talking about the new agrarian moment, out of which there emerged a number of figures associated with the new criticism, including Robert Penn Warren, who very early on repudiated the new agrarians and became a politically progressive figure in his own writing.
P
55:51Paul FryHOST
Many of you have probably read All the King's Men, certainly in his poetry as well, but who was an avatar, a central figure in the development of the thinking of the New Criticism, which we have briefly studied.
P
56:07Paul FryHOST
Now Warren wrote a poem called Pondy Woods.
P
56:10Paul FryHOST
which is quoted completely out of context by Sterling Brown and unfairly out of context in the passage, which I'm not going to read because I don't think I have the right to speak the N-word, and so I'll just have you look at it, and I'll come back to that in a minute.
P
57:52Paul FryHOST
It seems completely unfair, and it is, I think, unfair as Sterling Brown took it up and as Gates then perpetuates the idea in his own reference.
P
58:05Paul FryHOST
The one thing I would add, however, is that it's a new critical idea that we invoke to say that it's unfair.
P
58:13Paul FryHOST
It's the new criticism in which Robert Penn Warren was a participant that tells us we shouldn't confuse speakers in poems with authors.
6. The New Criticism and Other Western Formalisms
P
6:56Paul FryHOST
That criterion, as I say, not just for the sorts of semi-facetious readings we can do with Wimsatt's eleventh footnote but also for readings that may at least have some marginal plausibility, this sense of unity is what governs interpretive decisions of this kind.
P
7:18Paul FryHOST
All right, now a word or two about the antecedents of the New Criticism.
P
7:24Paul FryHOST
In the first place, the thirties and forties in the academic world bear witness to the rise of a canon of taste largely introduced by the great modernist writers, particularly by T.S. Eliot.
P
7:41Paul FryHOST
You may notice that Brooks, for example, has a kind of done obsession.
P
7:45Paul FryHOST
He gets that from Eliot's essay The Metaphysical Poets, which is a review essay of a volume of Donne's poems edited by somebody named Grierson, which made Donne overnight, for a great many readers, the central poet in the English tradition.
P
8:03Paul FryHOST
Brooks is still, as I say, very much under the influence of this.
P
8:06Paul FryHOST
Well, Eliot in The Metaphysical Poets says some rather interesting things that had far-reaching consequences for the New Criticism.
P
8:14Paul FryHOST
He says, poetry in our own time, such is the complexity of the world we live in, must be difficult.
5. The Idea of the Autonomous Artwork
P
4:18Paul FryHOST
When I arrived at Yale, Wimsatt was still teaching.
P
4:21Paul FryHOST
Cleanth Brooks was still teaching, and so I feel a kind of personal continuity with these figures and understand, as we all will more fully later on, the way in which the style and emphasis on style of close reading that evolved within the New Criticism meaningfully and importantly left its mark on much subsequent criticism and theory that hasn't in fact always acknowledged the New Criticism, perhaps to the extent that it might have.
P
4:59Paul FryHOST
What I'll say, because much of this should be reserved for next time when I talk about Cleanth Brooks and return to the whole subject of the New Criticism and the way in which it's viewed historically, so much of it can be reserved for next time.
P
5:13Paul FryHOST
But what I do want to say now is this.
P
5:16Paul FryHOST
If it weren't for the New Critics, None of you probably would have been able to sit patiently through any of your middle or high school English classes when Clint Brooks and Robert Penn Warren published a book called Understanding Poetry, first published in 1939 and then subsequently reissued again and again and again as it swept the country.
P
6:59Paul FryHOST
It took time.
P
7:00Paul FryHOST
If you had more than fifty minutes, you could actually make ample use of it.
P
7:05Paul FryHOST
T.S. Eliot, who was in many ways associated with the New Criticism, one of its intellectual forebears, nevertheless took a somewhat dim view of it and called it lemon-squeezer criticism.