Listener sentiment
Listeners remain sharply split on The Rest Is Politics. A devoted core praises Alastair Campbell and Rory Stewart as intelligent, well-informed guides who make British and global affairs accessible — and who model how to disagree without rancour — while an equally vocal bloc of critics says the show has drifted into one-sided, left-leaning commentary, with Campbell campaigning rather than analysing and Stewart too often agreeing. Bias complaints arrive from both directions: right-leaning listeners object to the tone on Reform, Trump and Labour, some on the left fault Stewart for dismissing wealth taxation and defending elite interests, and coverage of Israel, Gaza and antisemitism draws simultaneous fire from opposing camps. Alongside the politics, recurring practical grievances centre on the paywall — several listeners argue a series on environmental and food-security issues is too important to restrict to subscribers, and one paying member reports still hearing ads — as well as heavy ad loads, miniseries and guest co-hosts crowding out the core two-host debate, and habitual verbal tics. Guest hosts divide opinion: historian Dominic Sandbrook's substitute stint was widely praised for its historical depth and willingness to push back on Campbell, while Mehdi Hasan's appearances proved divisive. This polarised pattern, consistent since spring, has held into late summer with no clear movement in either direction.
Apple3.2 · 849
Summary generated Sep 1, 2026
