Shaping Science with Nick Dirks
Nov 16, 2026 · 58 min · 12 segments
David Krakauer is an evolutionary theorist and President of the Santa Fe Institute, the pioneering research center devoted to the science of complex systems, where he also…
David KrakauerGuest
Nick DirksHost
So this was an interesting moment in the sort of history of universities and the like.

By the 80s, some of those experiments were turning out not to really work very well.

We were talking before about University of California in Santa Cruz that began with a kind of plan not to have any departments at all.

I think by the mid-80s, it had begun to creep back to a departmental disciplinary structure.

So in a way, the Santa Fe Institute is a very radical dramatic effort to break that apart and really create something that couldn't be then recongealed in an older kind of disciplinary structure.

Even as the Institute for Advanced Study that has a lot of flexibility in terms of the way both fellows and faculty can work, does.

Could you say a little bit more about this historical moment of its creation and who the main players were that were brought together and what the kind of charter for its intellectual mandate was and how that was developed.

So as I said, part of it is dispositional, right? It's a certain kind of person who understands the sources of inspiration in their own lives and doesn't repress that.

And you have these extraordinary array of people, many of whom had won Nobel prizes.

I mean, like Murray, like Phil Anderson in condensed metaphysics, like Ken Arrow in economics, and then George, of course, and David Pines, another condensed metaphysicist, and on it goes.

And so part of it was, in some sense, people massively encumbered by prizes, who were so weighed down by the success that they were looking for a little bit of freedom later in their lives, I think.

Why are we so confident that the disciplinary structures that we've created were right? It's just an empirical observation.

How can it be? Presumably, if you were an engineer and every time you touched a machine, it broke, you would question your principles.

That is, just be an empiricist about the structure of epistemology, about the structure of knowledge.

How well are we doing? In some areas we're doing very well, in other areas we're doing badly.

So this was an interesting moment in the sort of history of universities and the like.

By the 80s, some of those experiments were turning out not to really work very well.

We were talking before about University of California in Santa Cruz that began with a kind of plan not to have any departments at all.

I think by the mid-80s, it had begun to creep back to a departmental disciplinary structure.

So in a way, the Santa Fe Institute is a very radical dramatic effort to break that apart and really create something that couldn't be then recongealed in an older kind of disciplinary structure.

Even as the Institute for Advanced Study that has a lot of flexibility in terms of the way both fellows and faculty can work, does.

Could you say a little bit more about this historical moment of its creation and who the main players were that were brought together and what the kind of charter for its intellectual mandate was and how that was developed.

So as I said, part of it is dispositional, right? It's a certain kind of person who understands the sources of inspiration in their own lives and doesn't repress that.

And you have these extraordinary array of people, many of whom had won Nobel prizes.

I mean, like Murray, like Phil Anderson in condensed metaphysics, like Ken Arrow in economics, and then George, of course, and David Pines, another condensed metaphysicist, and on it goes.

And so part of it was, in some sense, people massively encumbered by prizes, who were so weighed down by the success that they were looking for a little bit of freedom later in their lives, I think.

Why are we so confident that the disciplinary structures that we've created were right? It's just an empirical observation.

How can it be? Presumably, if you were an engineer and every time you touched a machine, it broke, you would question your principles.

That is, just be an empiricist about the structure of epistemology, about the structure of knowledge.

How well are we doing? In some areas we're doing very well, in other areas we're doing badly.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.