On Common Ground: An American Inheritance
Aug 17, 2026 · 42 min · 10 segments
Episode two, "The Land," is the origin story: how the United States came to hold 640 million acres in trust for the public, how concentrated wealth plundered and privatized much of it in the 1800s…
Bill HeddenHost
John LeshyHost
At one point, the United States owned nearly the entire continent, everything acquired through war, purchase, treaty, and the displacement of indigenous peoples.

And for most of the 19th century, the policy was simple: give it away Give it to settlers to farm.

Before the land could be given away, it had to be taken, and before it could be taken, it had to be imagined as empty.

The farmland, the rail corridors, the mining country, the acres that paid for the schools, almost all of it had belonged to Native nations who were pushed off, bought out, or killed.

The ground around Arches and Canyonlands was Ute and Paiute and Puebloan homeland.

And there's another lie buried in the story, the claim that the federal government somehow stole the states' land.

Walt Dabney spent his career in the National Park Service, including a superintendent at Arches and Canyonlands, right near where I lived.
When the Mormons came in to the Utah Valley, the Salt Lake Valley up there, it was 1847.
That was Mexico, and it wasn't for another 48 years, in 1896, that Utah became a state.
And I heard when I first started doing this, well, we were promised at statehood that we'd get our lands back.
Well, first of all, they were territorial lands that the state was carved out of, and they agreed that nothing else that was not designated as something other federal land w- was available to them unless Congress acted otherwise.

It belonged to the federal government before the states even existed, and the laws by which Congress established new states said so explicitly.

At one point, the United States owned nearly the entire continent, everything acquired through war, purchase, treaty, and the displacement of indigenous peoples.

And for most of the 19th century, the policy was simple: give it away Give it to settlers to farm.

Before the land could be given away, it had to be taken, and before it could be taken, it had to be imagined as empty.

The farmland, the rail corridors, the mining country, the acres that paid for the schools, almost all of it had belonged to Native nations who were pushed off, bought out, or killed.

The ground around Arches and Canyonlands was Ute and Paiute and Puebloan homeland.

And there's another lie buried in the story, the claim that the federal government somehow stole the states' land.

Walt Dabney spent his career in the National Park Service, including a superintendent at Arches and Canyonlands, right near where I lived.
When the Mormons came in to the Utah Valley, the Salt Lake Valley up there, it was 1847.
That was Mexico, and it wasn't for another 48 years, in 1896, that Utah became a state.
And I heard when I first started doing this, well, we were promised at statehood that we'd get our lands back.
Well, first of all, they were territorial lands that the state was carved out of, and they agreed that nothing else that was not designated as something other federal land w- was available to them unless Congress acted otherwise.

It belonged to the federal government before the states even existed, and the laws by which Congress established new states said so explicitly.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.