We have a Halacha in Shechinach about not saying shalom, not greeting someone in the morning, which could be pretty difficult and awkward and not polite sometimes.
And clearly brought down, it makes no difference if you use the word shalom or you say tzafraid maratav, which means good morning.
If you're meeting your friend in shul, and then it's perfectly fine to tell him good morning after you've said already Birchas Hashachar.
So some people have the meaning that they say Birchas Hashachar, the brachos, the morning brachos in shul.
It is the Chabad meaning as it is for multiple reasons that we say the Birchas Hashachar right away in the morning at home.
So once we said already Birchas Hashachar, it's not a big deal if you're seeing him in shul and saying good morning, that's perfectly fine.
Even before saying brachos, if you make a variation in the way you wish him and you don't use the normal expression of wishing him, then it's perfectly fine as long as you don't say the word shalom.
The reason why it's okay when you tell him tzafraid maratav, good morning, well, that's, that's not the normal way of talking.
The issue, of course, is, which Poskim already have addressed, that nowadays good morning is a very normal way how to wish people when you see them in the morning.
And if the whole idea is because you want to make a shinui, a variation, so what have we accomplished? So some people, actually you'll notice there are some people that have this thing in the morning when they see people, they don't tell them good morning or guten morgen, and they actually use the Aramaic tzafraid maratav.
For some reason they think if you say it in Aramaic it's better, which makes sense because they're making some type of variation.
But there could be another justification for saying good morning because the Rabbeinu Manoach explains that when you say the words tzafraid maratav, which means good morning, it's very different than shalom.
The very fact that you're not asking him how he's doing, you're wishing him, is a form of variations.
Certainly if a person said already brachos, once brachos has been said, it's already the severity is not, the severity is less severe I was about to say.
We have a Halacha in Shechinach about not saying shalom, not greeting someone in the morning, which could be pretty difficult and awkward and not polite sometimes.
And clearly brought down, it makes no difference if you use the word shalom or you say tzafraid maratav, which means good morning.
If you're meeting your friend in shul, and then it's perfectly fine to tell him good morning after you've said already Birchas Hashachar.
So some people have the meaning that they say Birchas Hashachar, the brachos, the morning brachos in shul.
It is the Chabad meaning as it is for multiple reasons that we say the Birchas Hashachar right away in the morning at home.
So once we said already Birchas Hashachar, it's not a big deal if you're seeing him in shul and saying good morning, that's perfectly fine.
Even before saying brachos, if you make a variation in the way you wish him and you don't use the normal expression of wishing him, then it's perfectly fine as long as you don't say the word shalom.
The reason why it's okay when you tell him tzafraid maratav, good morning, well, that's, that's not the normal way of talking.
The issue, of course, is, which Poskim already have addressed, that nowadays good morning is a very normal way how to wish people when you see them in the morning.
And if the whole idea is because you want to make a shinui, a variation, so what have we accomplished? So some people, actually you'll notice there are some people that have this thing in the morning when they see people, they don't tell them good morning or guten morgen, and they actually use the Aramaic tzafraid maratav.
For some reason they think if you say it in Aramaic it's better, which makes sense because they're making some type of variation.
But there could be another justification for saying good morning because the Rabbeinu Manoach explains that when you say the words tzafraid maratav, which means good morning, it's very different than shalom.
The very fact that you're not asking him how he's doing, you're wishing him, is a form of variations.
Certainly if a person said already brachos, once brachos has been said, it's already the severity is not, the severity is less severe I was about to say.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.