Episode 59 - Collect First, Justify Later

Show Notes - https://forum.closednetwork.io/t/episode-59-collect-first-justify-later/199 Website / Donations / Support - https://closednetwork.io/support/ BTC Lightning Donations - closednetwork@getalby.com / simon@primal.net **Thank You Patreons & Direct Supporters! -** https://www.patreon.com/closednetwork https://xmrchat.com/closednetwork Direct Support - https://closednetwork.io Subscribe Without Patreon - https://closednetwork.io/#/portal/signup 1. Michael Bates - Privacy Bad Ass 2. David - Privacy Bad Ass 3. TK - Privacy Bad Ass 4. Trying - Privacy Bad Ass 5. VO - Privacy Bad Ass 6. MrMilkMustache - Privacy Supporter 7. Hutch - Privacy Advocate 8. Inferno\_Potato Privacy Supporter 9. Dolores Y - Privacy Supporter Direct Support - Craig D Thank You Producers! You Produce This Show! TOP LIGHTNING BOOSTERS !!!! THANK YOU !!! 1. @bon thousands and thousands and thousands of SATs sats!! 2. @fireflygow - 5,000 sats!! 3. frigolay - 34,540 SATs.. HOLY SHITE 4. **wardemoff - 5,000 SATs** 5. **Silas Thornbrook** **XMR CHAT BOOSTS** **- HookersOnPhonics - $20** ### Thank You To Our Moderators: **Unintelligentseven** - Follow on NOSTR primal.net/p/npub15rp9gyw346fmcxgdlgp2y9a2xua9ujdk9nzumflshkwjsc7wepwqnh354d **MaddestMax** - Follow on NOSTR primal.net/p/npub133yzwsqfgvsuxd4clvkgupshzhjn52v837dlud6gjk4tu2c7grqq3sxavt ### Join Our Community Closed Network Forum - https://forum.closednetwork.io Join Our Matrix Channels! Main - https://matrix.to/#/#closedntwrk:matrix.org Off Topic - https://matrix.to/#/#closednetworkofftopic:matrix.org SimpleX Group Chat - https://smp9.simplex.im/g#SRBJK7JhuMWa1jgxfmnOfHz7Bl5KjnKUFL5zy-Jn-j0 Join Our Mastodon server! https://closednetwork.social ### **Follow Simon** On The Socials Mastodon - https://closednetwork.social/@simon NOSTR - Public Address - npub186l3994gark0fhknh9zp27q38wv3uy042appcpx93cack5q2n03qte2lu2 - primal.net/simon Twitter / X - @ClosedNtwrk Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/closednetworkpodcast/ YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@closednetwork Email - [simon@closednetwork.io](mailto:simon@closednetwork.io) Special Thanks to - **EloquentWinter for creating -** A Linux guide on MAC address randomization https://forum.closednetwork.io/t/a-linux-guide-on-mac-address-randomization/189 # TOPICS ## IN THIS EPISODE **01** **The Man Who Built FISA — And Watched It Break** The FBI lawyer who designed the bureau's FISA safeguards says that after he left in 2006 they were dismantled — and the system ballooned into Section 702. **02** **EU Chat Control: The Majority Said No. The Scan Survived.** A parliamentary majority voted against message scanning on 9 July — and it survived anyway on a second-reading technicality, now running to 2028. **03** **SCOTUS, Flock & the Cameras That Don't Care.** The Supreme Court ruled that reconstructing your movements is a 'search' — but 113,000+ license-plate cameras keep rolling, and the fix isn't in a courtroom. **04** **Your Face Is a Password You Can't Change.** Madison Square Garden's facial-recognition system leaked — watchlists included — after a single phishing call. Why every face database is a breach-in-waiting. **05** **Tools to Own the Stack.** Three open-source projects worth your time — one per fight: DeFlock, SimpleX Chat, and GrapheneOS. *Timestamps are estimates based on segment order — update after the final edit.* **00:00**Cold Open & Episode Rundown **02:00**The Man Who Built FISA **08:30**EU Chat Control Update **14:30**SCOTUS, Flock & the Cameras **20:00**Your Face Is a Password You Can't Change **25:00**Tools to Own the Stack **28:00**Outro ## SEGMENT TAKEAWAYS **The Man Who Built FISA** 1. FISA (1978) was sold as a reform, but it legitimized surveillance the government had previously run with no statute at all. 2. The FISA court rarely says no because the real filtering was designed to happen upstream, inside the FBI. 3. Bowman built that pipeline — embedded lawyers, months of review, personal sign-off. After he left in 2006, it went passive. 4. The Carter Page applications (17+ errors; a doctored email; a guilty plea) showed the cost. 5. 2008's Amendments Act created Section 702 — blanket categories, no named targets, a queryable database of Americans' data. 6. Thesis: the danger isn't who builds a surveillance system — it's everyone who inherits it. **EU Chat Control** 1. Two proposals, one name: 1.0 (temporary, voluntary) vs. 2.0 / CSAR (permanent, mandatory). 2. 26 Mar 2026: Parliament rejected the temporary rules 307–306; the derogation expired 3 April. 3. 9 Jul 2026: more MEPs voted to kill the revived scheme than keep it (reported 314–276), but rejecting the Council needed 361 votes. It survived — extended to 3 April 2028, with an E2E carve-out. 4. The permanent CSAR could be adopted as soon as October 2026. 5. Client-side scanning is the core danger; 500+ scientists call it infeasible; Signal would exit the EU. Watch Germany. **SCOTUS, Flock & the Cameras** 1. Chatrie v. United States (29 Jun 2026, 6–3): a geofence is a 'search'; police generally need a warrant. Built on Carpenter (2018). 2. The Court didn't ban geofence warrants and never mentioned ALPRs — a principle above a system it doesn't touch. 3. Scale: 113,000+ cameras; ~20B detections/month across ~5,000 departments vs. ~240M drivers. 4. A 2 Jul 2026 ACLU report documented Flock misleading councils (the Oshkosh 'heat map' reversal). 5. At least 82 jurisdictions have canceled ALPR contracts. The durable fix is local — stop collection. **Your Face Is a Password You Can't Change** 1. MSG breached by ShinyHunters via a phishing call; ~45GB / ~26M claimed records, including facial-recognition records and threat profiles. 2. MSG used facial recognition for years — including to bar opposing lawyers. Second breach in under a year; class actions filed. 3. A pattern, not an accident: Clearview's client list leaked in 2020; Mercor exposed biometrics + ID docs in April 2026. 4. Biometrics are irreversible — you can't reissue your face. The safeguard is not building the database. ## TOOLS MENTIONED *Open source · not sponsored · no affiliate relationships.* **DeFlock · pairs with the Flock segment** Crowdsourced ALPR camera map on OpenStreetMap; has mapped ~half of Flock's ~100,000-camera network so you can see and route around them. deflock.org **SimpleX Chat · pairs with Chat Control** Messenger with no user identifiers at all — the metadata-resistance layer E2E encryption alone doesn't give you. Audited by Trail of Bits. simplex.chat **GrapheneOS · pairs with every segment** Hardened, de-Googled Android on Pixel — the endpoint is where client-side scanning and biometric capture actually land. grapheneos.org ## SOURCES & REFERENCES **Segment 1 — FISA** 1. Naomi Brockwell × Spike Bowman (YouTube) **Segment 2 — EU Chat Control** 1. Closed Network — Chat Control live tracker 2. EU Perspectives — Q&A 3. Euronews — temporary scanning extension 4. Patrick Breyer — Chat Control tracker **Segment 3 — SCOTUS / Flock** 1. Truthout — SCOTUS ruling & Flock (Mike Ludwig) 2. Supreme Court — Chatrie v. United States (PDF) 3. SCOTUSblog — geofence ruling 4. ACLU — Flock Safety credibility report **Segment 4 — Facial Recognition / Breaches** 1. TechCrunch — worst breaches of 2026 so far 2. The Next Web — MSG 45GB leak 3. Law360 — MSG sued over breach 4. Biometric Update — Mercor biometric breach 5. Privacy Guides — breach roundup Jul 3–9 **Segment 5 — Tools** 1. DeFlock (project site) 2. 404 Media — DeFlock maps ALPRs worldwide 3. Adafruit — DeFlock overview 4. SimpleX Chat (GitHub) 5. GrapheneOS (site)