Jun 3, 2025 · 46 min · 18 segments
Who's Editing is back, and it's real, this time! So Siskoid and the Monitor Tapes' Doug Adamson tackle Who's Who Update '87 #1 and reinvent the DC Universe using only this comic's entries! New era…
Doug AdamsonGuestSiskoidHostSo here are the revised rules for each episode of Who's Editing from now on.
Our line of books must include a monthly series for every hero, character, or team featured, as well as any location.
If and only if they didn't already get an entry in the main volume and therefore coverage on this show.
But one of these revised entries can be added to our roster.
And indeed, in this case, because there are so few new entries, we can add two.
We can also give a villain or other entry their own series as before if we absolutely feel the need to.
But we can only name a single villain from the issue to receive that honor.
So imagine we're coming back from some crisis or other.
We can reboot characters.
We can use any Continuities version.
We can do very classic versions.
It's up to us.
Titles don't have to match the entries.
Note that myself and Doug are each pitching our own ideas, so we'll end up with two possible lines of books.
Listeners, you decide which books you'd actually want to read, and we'll actually play that game too, and we'll give each other just enough cryptocurrency.
That's what I was going to say.
We'll move on to the future of cryptocurrency.
To buy one title from the other editor's line, so we have to take notes, etc.
But tell me, before we get into the entries, did you have a strategy going in?

Rough idea in terms of I'm trying to tie some books into the same way that DC used to do.

have houses, and there's Justice League house, and there's like four or five books under that editor.

So I'm trying to group them together so there's a through line on some, and, you know, a bit Roy Thomas-y in other respects.
I've done that before, so it definitely can pay off.
So here are the revised rules for each episode of Who's Editing from now on.
Our line of books must include a monthly series for every hero, character, or team featured, as well as any location.
If and only if they didn't already get an entry in the main volume and therefore coverage on this show.
But one of these revised entries can be added to our roster.
And indeed, in this case, because there are so few new entries, we can add two.
We can also give a villain or other entry their own series as before if we absolutely feel the need to.
But we can only name a single villain from the issue to receive that honor.
So imagine we're coming back from some crisis or other.
We can reboot characters.
We can use any Continuities version.
We can do very classic versions.
It's up to us.
Titles don't have to match the entries.
Note that myself and Doug are each pitching our own ideas, so we'll end up with two possible lines of books.
Listeners, you decide which books you'd actually want to read, and we'll actually play that game too, and we'll give each other just enough cryptocurrency.
That's what I was going to say.
We'll move on to the future of cryptocurrency.
To buy one title from the other editor's line, so we have to take notes, etc.
But tell me, before we get into the entries, did you have a strategy going in?

Rough idea in terms of I'm trying to tie some books into the same way that DC used to do.

have houses, and there's Justice League house, and there's like four or five books under that editor.

So I'm trying to group them together so there's a through line on some, and, you know, a bit Roy Thomas-y in other respects.
I've done that before, so it definitely can pay off.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.