Aug 9, 2022 · 56 min · 12 segments
Will MacAskill is one of the founders of the Effective Altruist movement and the author of the upcoming book, What We Owe The Future. We talk about improving the future, risk of extinction &…
So my first question is, what is the high-level explanation for the success of the Effective Altruist Movement? Is it itself an example of the contingencies you talk about in the book?
Maybe not on the order of like, this would never have happened, but at least on the order of decades.
Evidence for the reason why effective altruism is somewhat contingent is just that similar ideas have been promoted at many times during history and not taken on.
The Moists defended a kind of impartial view of morality and took very strategic actions to try and help all people, in particular providing defensive assistance to cities under siege.
Effective altruism is broader than utilitarianism, but has some similarities.
the idea that we should be giving most of our income to help the very poor, and hadn't had a lot of traction until even like early 2010, after GiveWell launched, after GivingWhatWeCan launched.
What explains the rise of it? I mean, I think it was a good idea waiting to happen at some point.
I think the internet helped to gather together a lot of like-minded people that weren't possible otherwise.
And I think there were some particularly lucky events, like Ellie meeting Holden, me meeting Toby, that helped catalyze it at the particular time it did.
Now, if it's true, as you say in the book, that moral values are very contingent, then shouldn't that make us suspect that modern Western values probably aren't that good? They're probably mediocre or worse because ex ante, you would expect to end up with the median of all the values you could have had at this point.
And obviously, we'd be biased in favor of whatever values we were brought up in.
And I think it should make us take seriously the fact that we're very far away from the moral truth right now.
We should not think we're at the end of moral progress and we should not think, oh, we should lock in the kind of Western values we have now.
Instead, we should think we want to ensure that we spend a lot of time trying to figure out what's actually morally right so that the future is guided by the right values rather than merely whichever happened to win out.
So that makes a lot of sense, but I guess I'm asking a slightly separate question, which is not only are there possible values that could be better than ours, but should we expect our values...
I mean, we have this sense that we've made moral progress, so things are better than they were before, or better than most possible other worlds
So my first question is, what is the high-level explanation for the success of the Effective Altruist Movement? Is it itself an example of the contingencies you talk about in the book?
Maybe not on the order of like, this would never have happened, but at least on the order of decades.
Evidence for the reason why effective altruism is somewhat contingent is just that similar ideas have been promoted at many times during history and not taken on.
The Moists defended a kind of impartial view of morality and took very strategic actions to try and help all people, in particular providing defensive assistance to cities under siege.
Effective altruism is broader than utilitarianism, but has some similarities.
the idea that we should be giving most of our income to help the very poor, and hadn't had a lot of traction until even like early 2010, after GiveWell launched, after GivingWhatWeCan launched.
What explains the rise of it? I mean, I think it was a good idea waiting to happen at some point.
I think the internet helped to gather together a lot of like-minded people that weren't possible otherwise.
And I think there were some particularly lucky events, like Ellie meeting Holden, me meeting Toby, that helped catalyze it at the particular time it did.
Now, if it's true, as you say in the book, that moral values are very contingent, then shouldn't that make us suspect that modern Western values probably aren't that good? They're probably mediocre or worse because ex ante, you would expect to end up with the median of all the values you could have had at this point.
And obviously, we'd be biased in favor of whatever values we were brought up in.
And I think it should make us take seriously the fact that we're very far away from the moral truth right now.
We should not think we're at the end of moral progress and we should not think, oh, we should lock in the kind of Western values we have now.
Instead, we should think we want to ensure that we spend a lot of time trying to figure out what's actually morally right so that the future is guided by the right values rather than merely whichever happened to win out.
So that makes a lot of sense, but I guess I'm asking a slightly separate question, which is not only are there possible values that could be better than ours, but should we expect our values...
I mean, we have this sense that we've made moral progress, so things are better than they were before, or better than most possible other worlds
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.