The isser might apply to maternal brothers, but the mitzvah is only by paternal.
And that's why the Mishnah said that whether the brothers are born after their mother, before the mother converts, so they're both non-Jewish, they both convert with the mother, or even if one of the brothers is born after the mother converts, or one of them is born after, but was impregnated before the geras took place, he's not related to his father, So then there's no mitzvah of Yibam either.
So the Gemara just clarifies when it says, even before that, I'm sorry, before that Rabbi Pinchas were up to.
Does that include Avadim, that they would be included in Karbanos? Therefore, it includes Avadim even for Yisurei Arayos, that are violated b'shogeg.
So the question is, how do you understand this v'yamart alei hem? But either way, Onomar l'chalavim is amris.
The reason that we said the first shot is that what's v'yamart alei hem by Arios can't be referring to Chalavim.
Is it including Avadim in the world of Arios? Or is it including the other Yisurim relating to Jews, which might apply to Avodim too, but not in the world of Arios.
How do you darshen that? And the Gemara answers, and that's the question of whether he will be chayef chatos for Imo.
And the Gemara just adds, Just like by a regular giores, there's no difference for Hilchas, Yibam, and Chalitza, whether the mother converted to after she had the two babies, two brothers, and therefore they're totally for sure not related, or even if she converted between, meaning after she was impregnated, and then she converted, and then she had one baby, so one baby was born Jewish, and the other one was born fully Jewish, even impregnated Jewish, so too, the same thing, both those cases, they're not related paternally, and therefore there's no mitzvah, so the same thing with shifra, if she was mishachrar, she was mishachraris, after impregnation, And before birth of one of them, so afshivcha, nasa batzad, shenashach rachah, kitzad, shalom nashach rachah, it would apply there too.
The isser might apply to maternal brothers, but the mitzvah is only by paternal.
And that's why the Mishnah said that whether the brothers are born after their mother, before the mother converts, so they're both non-Jewish, they both convert with the mother, or even if one of the brothers is born after the mother converts, or one of them is born after, but was impregnated before the geras took place, he's not related to his father, So then there's no mitzvah of Yibam either.
So the Gemara just clarifies when it says, even before that, I'm sorry, before that Rabbi Pinchas were up to.
Does that include Avadim, that they would be included in Karbanos? Therefore, it includes Avadim even for Yisurei Arayos, that are violated b'shogeg.
So the question is, how do you understand this v'yamart alei hem? But either way, Onomar l'chalavim is amris.
The reason that we said the first shot is that what's v'yamart alei hem by Arios can't be referring to Chalavim.
Is it including Avadim in the world of Arios? Or is it including the other Yisurim relating to Jews, which might apply to Avodim too, but not in the world of Arios.
How do you darshen that? And the Gemara answers, and that's the question of whether he will be chayef chatos for Imo.
And the Gemara just adds, Just like by a regular giores, there's no difference for Hilchas, Yibam, and Chalitza, whether the mother converted to after she had the two babies, two brothers, and therefore they're totally for sure not related, or even if she converted between, meaning after she was impregnated, and then she converted, and then she had one baby, so one baby was born Jewish, and the other one was born fully Jewish, even impregnated Jewish, so too, the same thing, both those cases, they're not related paternally, and therefore there's no mitzvah, so the same thing with shifra, if she was mishachrar, she was mishachraris, after impregnation, And before birth of one of them, so afshivcha, nasa batzad, shenashach rachah, kitzad, shalom nashach rachah, it would apply there too.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.