Should This Gaza Documentary from Israeli Filmmakers Be Cheered?

So the first question is from ABC, who says this.

I was surprised to see harsh criticism aimed at the NASA documentary.

And for those of you who don't know, NASA is a documentary – made by two Israeli filmmakers, Yubel Abraham, who won the Oscar with a Palestinian two years ago for a documentary they did on life in the West Bank and the apartheid regime in Israel and the drastic differences in each of their lives due to nothing but the fact that one is Israeli and one is Arab.

And then a filmmaker named Rachel Soar.

And I think it just got released or it's about to be released.

And the unique part of this film is that it interviews two dozen idf soldiers their anonymity is protected they are their face isn't shown their names aren't given their voice is altered but they are idf soldiers uh who who were in gaza I think all of them were, most of them were.

Maybe there were a couple who just worked on the idea from Israel on the war.

And they basically all confessed to the most shocking crimes.

Like, yeah, we did this.

And they came forward because it's on their conscience.

And there's a lot of...

PTSD, I think I might have it.

I don't know why I couldn't spit that out.

PTSD and suicide, high rates of suicide among Israeli soldiers who went to Gaza.

Because even though they did things monstrous and even just joining the IDF, in my view, is monstrous.

they're still you know most people are not psychopaths and so if you go and see just pure sadism and dehumanization and mass slaughter and mass murder and especially of kids a lot of people are going to be affected by it and there have been a lot so they have two dozen or so IDF soldiers who are just everything that organizations have been saying, everything that Palestinians have been saying, they're basically confessing to.

So let me read the question because it has created a lot, even though the film is getting rave reviews, And it's kind of considered a watershed moment in that these are Israelis confessing.

It's actually quite controversial, including among a lot of Israel critics and people who are activists with the pro-Palestinian cause.

And that's what this question is about.

So it says, I was surprised to see harsh criticism aimed at the Nasa documentary and its directors from a few prominent people who do great work for Palestinian causes.

Some of the criticism used the same woke language from recent movements, like, quote, not centering or believing Palestinian voices.

I would have thought that any effort to get more people to turn against Israel would be welcome, but apparently not.

Any thoughts? So I'm just going to show you a couple of critiques of the film from Palestinian activists or people active in the Palestinian cause, people who I respect and know.

so that we can then discuss it.

So let's put the first one on the screen.