Nov 14, 2026 · 2 hr 1 min · 14 segments
Ethan and Pat explore and DEFEND the view known as skeptical theism. Support the show >> patreon.com/summacontraeverybody 00:00 Introduction and…
Ethan MuseHost
Pat FlynnHost
Yeah, well, and so just beginning with the objections to theism that skeptical theism is sort of a strategy or a framework for helping us address.

So the objections to theism, I like to think of them as basically all forms of this one general problem, which is the problem of privation.

which is basically going around and looking at all the respects in which the world is suboptimal, and especially respects in which it seems gratuitously suboptimal, right? So it just seems like it could have been improved.

There's some flaw with it, something bad or some absence of good that just could have been easily remediated.

And so then it sort of raises the question, like if God is good, right, and God is smart, you know, why didn't he make something better, right? Why didn't he remediate all these defects? Why did he leave all this, you know, valuable stuff that he easily could have made on the table, right? Why did he go with this? And so there's these forms of the problem of privation, just looking at all these respects in which the world is suboptimal and especially respects in which it appears to be gratuitously suboptimal, right? There's no obvious reason for the suboptimality as opposed to just having improved it.

And then it proceeds from that to the conclusion that this is strong evidence against the existence of God, right? And there's lots of particular objections that take this form, right? And so one of them, which you mentioned at the outset, is the problem of evil, right? So going and looking at things that are not just respects in which there's more good could have been achieved than was in fact achieved, but things that are positively bad, right? They're undesirable, right? The world would be better in their absence.

And you look at that and we obviously look at the world around us and we see that there's lots of glaring conspicuous examples of evil.

Yeah, well, and so just beginning with the objections to theism that skeptical theism is sort of a strategy or a framework for helping us address.

So the objections to theism, I like to think of them as basically all forms of this one general problem, which is the problem of privation.

which is basically going around and looking at all the respects in which the world is suboptimal, and especially respects in which it seems gratuitously suboptimal, right? So it just seems like it could have been improved.

There's some flaw with it, something bad or some absence of good that just could have been easily remediated.

And so then it sort of raises the question, like if God is good, right, and God is smart, you know, why didn't he make something better, right? Why didn't he remediate all these defects? Why did he leave all this, you know, valuable stuff that he easily could have made on the table, right? Why did he go with this? And so there's these forms of the problem of privation, just looking at all these respects in which the world is suboptimal and especially respects in which it appears to be gratuitously suboptimal, right? There's no obvious reason for the suboptimality as opposed to just having improved it.

And then it proceeds from that to the conclusion that this is strong evidence against the existence of God, right? And there's lots of particular objections that take this form, right? And so one of them, which you mentioned at the outset, is the problem of evil, right? So going and looking at things that are not just respects in which there's more good could have been achieved than was in fact achieved, but things that are positively bad, right? They're undesirable, right? The world would be better in their absence.

And you look at that and we obviously look at the world around us and we see that there's lots of glaring conspicuous examples of evil.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.