Reincarnation - Past Lives Revisited
Oct 25, 2026 · 58 min · 13 segments
Today we return to Masada one final time, not to discuss David's memories but instead to explore the findings of two archaeological digs that took place in the 60s, that have changed people's thoughts…
Marilyn ElliottHost
That is no easy task as there's only one source of information that was written at the time and it in itself is open to confrontation and questioning.

Two archaeological digs that were carried out in the 60s on Masada have provided evidence that is also causing people to question that written account and also bring into question the possibility of a mass suicide that became an important part of Jewish law.

However, there have been assumptions made and questions left unanswered about the dig that make me feel that there is need for further consideration and scrutiny about Masada and the archaeological findings.

Masada marked a huge loss for the Jewish people, as it was the last stand of the Jews in their first fight against the Romans, and the first fight impacted Judaism greatly and started it on a path that led to a change in the way that Judaism was worshipped, a transition that was only really cemented in at the end of the final of the three battles between the two groups.

The archaeological findings that seem to have set the cat among the pigeons were two major digs that were led by Professor Igael Yardin between 1963 and 1965.


during the first war between the romans and the jews a man called flavius josephus had written about the siege describing the actions taken by the zealots and the romans culminating in a dramatic and tragic suicide after the romans breached the walls According to Josephus, the leader of the Sicarii, Aliaza ben Yair, gave two impassioned speeches, exhorting the Jews to sacrifice themselves by committing suicide, thereby finding death on their own terms and thwarting the Romans of their victory.

It was a brave and poignant ending to the first of the three wars that took place between the Romans and the Jews.

That account has become a sacred moment in the history of the Jewish people, a treasured testament to the courage and sacrifice of Jews giving up their lives as a final gesture of defiance against a brutal oppressor, dying with dignity and honour for their faith.

However, the digs created a major headache for Yadin, when no sign of this suicide was found at the dig site, and evidence seemed to point to Flavius' account differing from what actually happened.

Some things were there in evidence, but the more they uncovered, some serious holes seemed to appear in Flavius' account.

Should he release the findings and destroy this precious moment in history for the entire Jewish faith? Or should he take the evidence that did match Flavius' account and use that as proof of the mass suicide, even though he himself no longer believed that it had taken place? Unfortunately, Yardine chose the latter and declared the suicide was proven, even when there was no evidence of it.

Of course, this deception finally did surface, bringing not only the inconsistencies of Flavius' account to light, but also tainting Yardine's own body of work and leaving a shadow on his reputation.

But did Yardine make the right assumption when he assumed there was no suicide? No matter what way you look at this, you end up finding more questions.

So let's dive into all this and see if we can work out what is the truth and what is fiction, so we can determine how accurately David's memories align with what we know now.

So to provide the bits of backstory that help to bring context to the Battle of Masada, we need to understand the events that were happening at the time and how they impacted on the history of the region.

Both sides acted brutally and engaged in what would be considered war crimes in today's battlefields.

As it is currently, the Middle East at the time was a seething cauldron of many different groups, all vying for power and control, and it was a time before human rights were even considered.

In 63 BC, the Roman Emperor Pompey conquered Jerusalem, bringing it under Roman rule, but kept the local city governing authorities in place to keep everything running smoothly during the occupation.


At the time of the conquest, although the Romans intended to leave sacred sites untouched, the level of violence and bloodshed at the Temple Mount perpetrated against the Jews shocked even the Roman supporters.

The Romans were ruthlessly efficient in their dealings with conquered enemies, which becomes an important point to remember when we come to Masada.


That is no easy task as there's only one source of information that was written at the time and it in itself is open to confrontation and questioning.

Two archaeological digs that were carried out in the 60s on Masada have provided evidence that is also causing people to question that written account and also bring into question the possibility of a mass suicide that became an important part of Jewish law.

However, there have been assumptions made and questions left unanswered about the dig that make me feel that there is need for further consideration and scrutiny about Masada and the archaeological findings.

Masada marked a huge loss for the Jewish people, as it was the last stand of the Jews in their first fight against the Romans, and the first fight impacted Judaism greatly and started it on a path that led to a change in the way that Judaism was worshipped, a transition that was only really cemented in at the end of the final of the three battles between the two groups.

The archaeological findings that seem to have set the cat among the pigeons were two major digs that were led by Professor Igael Yardin between 1963 and 1965.


during the first war between the romans and the jews a man called flavius josephus had written about the siege describing the actions taken by the zealots and the romans culminating in a dramatic and tragic suicide after the romans breached the walls According to Josephus, the leader of the Sicarii, Aliaza ben Yair, gave two impassioned speeches, exhorting the Jews to sacrifice themselves by committing suicide, thereby finding death on their own terms and thwarting the Romans of their victory.

It was a brave and poignant ending to the first of the three wars that took place between the Romans and the Jews.

That account has become a sacred moment in the history of the Jewish people, a treasured testament to the courage and sacrifice of Jews giving up their lives as a final gesture of defiance against a brutal oppressor, dying with dignity and honour for their faith.

However, the digs created a major headache for Yadin, when no sign of this suicide was found at the dig site, and evidence seemed to point to Flavius' account differing from what actually happened.

Some things were there in evidence, but the more they uncovered, some serious holes seemed to appear in Flavius' account.

Should he release the findings and destroy this precious moment in history for the entire Jewish faith? Or should he take the evidence that did match Flavius' account and use that as proof of the mass suicide, even though he himself no longer believed that it had taken place? Unfortunately, Yardine chose the latter and declared the suicide was proven, even when there was no evidence of it.

Of course, this deception finally did surface, bringing not only the inconsistencies of Flavius' account to light, but also tainting Yardine's own body of work and leaving a shadow on his reputation.

But did Yardine make the right assumption when he assumed there was no suicide? No matter what way you look at this, you end up finding more questions.

So let's dive into all this and see if we can work out what is the truth and what is fiction, so we can determine how accurately David's memories align with what we know now.

So to provide the bits of backstory that help to bring context to the Battle of Masada, we need to understand the events that were happening at the time and how they impacted on the history of the region.

Both sides acted brutally and engaged in what would be considered war crimes in today's battlefields.

As it is currently, the Middle East at the time was a seething cauldron of many different groups, all vying for power and control, and it was a time before human rights were even considered.

In 63 BC, the Roman Emperor Pompey conquered Jerusalem, bringing it under Roman rule, but kept the local city governing authorities in place to keep everything running smoothly during the occupation.


At the time of the conquest, although the Romans intended to leave sacred sites untouched, the level of violence and bloodshed at the Temple Mount perpetrated against the Jews shocked even the Roman supporters.

The Romans were ruthlessly efficient in their dealings with conquered enemies, which becomes an important point to remember when we come to Masada.

The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.