Listener sentiment
Recent listeners are broadly enthusiastic about Josh Zeman's deep-dive into the Long Island Serial Killer case, praising his decade-plus of involvement, the thoroughness of the reporting, and the gripping narration that goes well beyond what mainstream true-crime television covered. Many reviewers highlight the podcast as the most comprehensive and up-to-date resource on the case, appreciating Zeman's evident commitment to the victims and the story. A sizeable minority, however, are sharply critical, and their complaints cluster around three recurring issues: an excessive ad load that some say consumes a quarter or more of each episode, an overdramatic production style with constant suspense music that distracts from the story, and a perceived self-promotional streak in which the host repeatedly references his own prior documentary work. Early frustration over a paywall model that limited free access to the first few episodes also generated several one-star reviews, though some listeners pointed out that episodes were eventually released for free on a weekly basis. The net sentiment is largely positive, but the ad volume and host self-referencing are consistent enough gripes that they represent a genuine drag on audience satisfaction rather than isolated kvetching.
Apple3.8 · 44
Summary generated Sep 15, 2026
