Jul 3, 2026 · 47 min · 22 segments
After making ‘ET’ and ‘Close Encounters of the Third Kind’ in the ‘70s and ‘80s, Steven Spielberg returns to the theme of extraterrestrials in his new film, ‘Disclosure Day.’ He spoke with Terry Gross…
David BianculliJust in time for a contentious 250th anniversary of the United States of America, historian David S. Reynolds' latest book, Two Ships, helps us realize that any country that couldn't agree on its own origin story is destined for divisive times.
Two Ships is about the complicated, conjoined legacy of the landings of the Mayflower, which carried the Pilgrims to Plymouth in 1620, and the White Lion, which arrived in Jamestown a year earlier, bringing the first enslaved Africans to Virginia.
As Reynolds demonstrates, it's not so much the facts of these two voyages as it is the meanings ascribed to them that made them such a powerful metaphor for two conflicting visions of American identity.
As the United States developed, the Mayflower was credited with carrying the seeds of a radical democracy to the New World, one in which all men, in theory at least, were equal before God.
In contrast, the European settlers of Jamestown were royalists, also known as Cavaliers.
hierarchy.But the meaning of the images of the two ships shifted depending on who was invoking them and when.
Not surprisingly, the metaphor was deployed most vigorously during the Civil War.
In abolitionist speeches and writings, the White Lion, or the Slave Ship as it was commonly called, was condemned for infecting America with the plague spot of slavery.
Reynolds says that Frederick Douglass resorted to the two ships metaphor frequently, while Lincoln avoided it, hoping to preserve a unified ship of state.
Meanwhile, Southern descendants of Cavaliers invoked the Mayflower to emphasize the intolerance and cruel, persecuting character of the Puritans.
In a comment that resonates for our own times, Reynolds says, "It didn't matter to the South that by the mid-19th century, the North had become a kaleidoscope of religious denominations, few of which resembled the faith of the Plymouth colonists.
Distortion is intrinsic to cultural memory, especially when amplified by sectional or political bias.
For Southerners, the Mayflower had brought Puritanism, which had yielded fanatical movements like abolitionism, now a threat to the Union." In a brief but fascinating digression into the unpredictable power of literary fiction, Reynolds observes that the South's fondness for Nathaniel Hawthorne's anti-Puritan novel, The Scarlet Letter, and even more for the medieval historical romances of Sir Walter Scott, bolstered its nostalgia for a largely imagined feudal society.
Reynolds quotes the always quotable Mark Twain, no fan of Scott's, as saying that Scott "did measureless harm, more real and lasting harm perhaps than any other individual that ever wrote." Two Ships is a dazzling survey of some three centuries of American history through a close reading of a metaphor.
By the 1890s, Reynolds says, the interpretive tide had turned again.
Southern and Northern whites, feeling threatened by people of color and by an array of European immigrants, were retreating to a cocoon of racial solidarity that Mayflower celebrations helped reinforce.
By the later 20th century, the image of the Mayflower was depoliticized and commercialized into Pilgrim hats and Black Friday sales.
The powerful metaphor of the two ships receded into the mist.
Seven years ago, however, the 1619 Project piloted the White Lion, the Slave Ship, back into view, and anchored it at the center of debates about slavery's place in the national story.
The 1619 Project has been faulted for its historiography, and it does lie outside of the chronological boundaries of Reynolds' book.
Still, it seems too momentous a reappearance of the White Lion not to at least acknowledge in this book.
That criticism noted, I think reading Two Ships would be an excellent way to observe this particular Fourth of July.
It's wise for all of us to have a more informed awareness of how Americans have understood, misunderstood, and often flattened each other into stereotypes.
Just in time for a contentious 250th anniversary of the United States of America, historian David S. Reynolds' latest book, Two Ships, helps us realize that any country that couldn't agree on its own origin story is destined for divisive times.
Two Ships is about the complicated, conjoined legacy of the landings of the Mayflower, which carried the Pilgrims to Plymouth in 1620, and the White Lion, which arrived in Jamestown a year earlier, bringing the first enslaved Africans to Virginia.
As Reynolds demonstrates, it's not so much the facts of these two voyages as it is the meanings ascribed to them that made them such a powerful metaphor for two conflicting visions of American identity.
As the United States developed, the Mayflower was credited with carrying the seeds of a radical democracy to the New World, one in which all men, in theory at least, were equal before God.
In contrast, the European settlers of Jamestown were royalists, also known as Cavaliers.
hierarchy.But the meaning of the images of the two ships shifted depending on who was invoking them and when.
Not surprisingly, the metaphor was deployed most vigorously during the Civil War.
In abolitionist speeches and writings, the White Lion, or the Slave Ship as it was commonly called, was condemned for infecting America with the plague spot of slavery.
Reynolds says that Frederick Douglass resorted to the two ships metaphor frequently, while Lincoln avoided it, hoping to preserve a unified ship of state.
Meanwhile, Southern descendants of Cavaliers invoked the Mayflower to emphasize the intolerance and cruel, persecuting character of the Puritans.
In a comment that resonates for our own times, Reynolds says, "It didn't matter to the South that by the mid-19th century, the North had become a kaleidoscope of religious denominations, few of which resembled the faith of the Plymouth colonists.
Distortion is intrinsic to cultural memory, especially when amplified by sectional or political bias.
For Southerners, the Mayflower had brought Puritanism, which had yielded fanatical movements like abolitionism, now a threat to the Union." In a brief but fascinating digression into the unpredictable power of literary fiction, Reynolds observes that the South's fondness for Nathaniel Hawthorne's anti-Puritan novel, The Scarlet Letter, and even more for the medieval historical romances of Sir Walter Scott, bolstered its nostalgia for a largely imagined feudal society.
Reynolds quotes the always quotable Mark Twain, no fan of Scott's, as saying that Scott "did measureless harm, more real and lasting harm perhaps than any other individual that ever wrote." Two Ships is a dazzling survey of some three centuries of American history through a close reading of a metaphor.
By the 1890s, Reynolds says, the interpretive tide had turned again.
Southern and Northern whites, feeling threatened by people of color and by an array of European immigrants, were retreating to a cocoon of racial solidarity that Mayflower celebrations helped reinforce.
By the later 20th century, the image of the Mayflower was depoliticized and commercialized into Pilgrim hats and Black Friday sales.
The powerful metaphor of the two ships receded into the mist.
Seven years ago, however, the 1619 Project piloted the White Lion, the Slave Ship, back into view, and anchored it at the center of debates about slavery's place in the national story.
The 1619 Project has been faulted for its historiography, and it does lie outside of the chronological boundaries of Reynolds' book.
Still, it seems too momentous a reappearance of the White Lion not to at least acknowledge in this book.
That criticism noted, I think reading Two Ships would be an excellent way to observe this particular Fourth of July.
It's wise for all of us to have a more informed awareness of how Americans have understood, misunderstood, and often flattened each other into stereotypes.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.