Listener sentiment
Listener sentiment for Dear Sugars is overwhelmingly positive, with reviewers consistently praising hosts Cheryl Strayed and Steve Almond for their radical empathy, non-judgmental advice, and willingness to tackle deeply personal and uncomfortable topics. Many describe the show as life-changing, soothing, and a source of genuine comfort during difficult times, with particular appreciation for the hosts' chemistry and the care they bring to each listener letter. A dominant recurring theme — especially in reviews from 2019 through 2024 — is a longing for the show to return or produce new episodes, as the podcast has been largely dormant or releasing re-runs since its original run ended around 2018. A smaller but vocal minority of critics raise substantive concerns: some feel Steve Almond takes up disproportionate space and offers less insightful contributions than Cheryl Strayed, while others note that the hosts occasionally center their own experiences over the letter writers' struggles, and that episodes addressing race, gender identity, and non-traditional relationships can feel un-nuanced or out of touch. Despite these critiques, even skeptical reviewers tend to acknowledge the show's emotional intelligence and good intentions, and the overall picture is one of a deeply beloved podcast whose audience remains fervently loyal and eager for its revival.
Apple4.5 · 606
Summary generated Aug 9, 2026
