You Must Be Some Kind of Therapist
Nov 9, 2026 · 1 hr 35 min · 13 segments
My guest is Tamara Sears, a British existential psychotherapist with 20 years in private practice who writes about censorship in the counseling profession. We work through her Substack article…
Stephanie WinnHost
Because if I'm tracking correctly what you've shared in your article, there was Magnus Hirschfeld was his name.

And this is exactly the sort of thing that trans rights activists use to paint us as Nazis, right? As if anyone in opposition to this is a Nazi.

So I think it's bold of you to go there and almost lend our opposition that fuel for strawmanning our position.
As I was looking into it, I became aware that Hirschfeld was operating in Germany at the time.
And I'd sort of seen some of the reports of some of the more problematic aspects of his experiments, which the trans activists, they're very clearly hiding a lot of this information.
Hirschfeld, you know, they kind of applaud Hirschfeld for doing the things that he did.
But, you know, what Lily Elb, for example, you know, that man endured seven operations and died of sepsis after experiencing a womb implant.
And keeping in mind that, you know, we don't know who the female was, that's never documented.
So that, you know, appropriating body parts from women, implanting them in predominantly gay men, well, in this case, it was just one, And then who, of course, the body rejected it.
As a result of doing it, and remember, it's at a period where, you know, they were experimenting with things like eugenics, which, you know, now is like, we don't do it, you know, and Hirschfeld was a eugenicist.
um this is the man that you know promoted the idea was providing transvestite certificates as they called them back in the time so that people who pretended to be the opposite sex could be accepted legally as the opposite sex even back in the early 1900s and so It's hardly surprising that people were...
Adolf Hitler referred to what he was doing as making a mockery of the people and referred to him as being a Jewish swine.
Even if Adolf Hitler's criticisms of the experiments that Hirschfeld was conducting on people...
Even if Hirschfeld's experiments were unethical, the fact that Adolf Hitler was referring to that is correct.
The problem is that being a Jewish male, Adolf Hitler then used the fact of Hirschfeld being Jewish to justify racism against a whole entire race of people, rather than just identifying that this is medical malpractice and this is unethical.

Because if I'm tracking correctly what you've shared in your article, there was Magnus Hirschfeld was his name.

And this is exactly the sort of thing that trans rights activists use to paint us as Nazis, right? As if anyone in opposition to this is a Nazi.

So I think it's bold of you to go there and almost lend our opposition that fuel for strawmanning our position.
As I was looking into it, I became aware that Hirschfeld was operating in Germany at the time.
And I'd sort of seen some of the reports of some of the more problematic aspects of his experiments, which the trans activists, they're very clearly hiding a lot of this information.
Hirschfeld, you know, they kind of applaud Hirschfeld for doing the things that he did.
But, you know, what Lily Elb, for example, you know, that man endured seven operations and died of sepsis after experiencing a womb implant.
And keeping in mind that, you know, we don't know who the female was, that's never documented.
So that, you know, appropriating body parts from women, implanting them in predominantly gay men, well, in this case, it was just one, And then who, of course, the body rejected it.
As a result of doing it, and remember, it's at a period where, you know, they were experimenting with things like eugenics, which, you know, now is like, we don't do it, you know, and Hirschfeld was a eugenicist.
um this is the man that you know promoted the idea was providing transvestite certificates as they called them back in the time so that people who pretended to be the opposite sex could be accepted legally as the opposite sex even back in the early 1900s and so It's hardly surprising that people were...
Adolf Hitler referred to what he was doing as making a mockery of the people and referred to him as being a Jewish swine.
Even if Adolf Hitler's criticisms of the experiments that Hirschfeld was conducting on people...
Even if Hirschfeld's experiments were unethical, the fact that Adolf Hitler was referring to that is correct.
The problem is that being a Jewish male, Adolf Hitler then used the fact of Hirschfeld being Jewish to justify racism against a whole entire race of people, rather than just identifying that this is medical malpractice and this is unethical.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.