Y Yevamos 78

There's an interesting Chagigah.

There is a masnisa, which we'll get back to hinting that.

But first, let's continue.

Masnisa b'shkitcha b'kesef.

The Mishnah, this whole discussion is where there was kiddusha kesef.

That's where it's equal footing.

The kiddushin and the gerishin is remiza, remiza, and it's all good.

Avalim kiddusha b'b'ila.

But what happens if there was kiddusha b'ya? Kiddusha b'ya, which we don't do.

But if there was kiddusha b'ya, so then the kiddushin is stronger than the gerishin.

And therefore, just being nizgarish b'ramiza wouldn't be good enough.

But if kiddush ebiya took place, then kiddush avmaisa v'girush avenomaisa.

So then, undoing it with just the ramiza and the without a real full gerishin, that would not be good enough.

There are two deists here in the Mefarshim.

Look at Rav Chaim Kadyevsky quote two of the opinions.

Is kiddush ebiya daraisa? In that case, even for a cherish hareshas, because the focus is on the maisa.

And if it was on the maisa, they could do a maisa biya.

Or do we say, no, it doesn't mean that it's Darai, so it just means it's stronger than Kedusha Kasem, Kedusha Ishtar.

So he has two days about that.

Some say that Yerushalmi is holding, I'm ready to hear from Haim Gidevsky, because the Isha is Makna herself, just like we have in T.D. Mamadis, where some Rishonim say that as long as someone is willing it, is being makne'ed into the reshus of the katan, then that could work dar eisah, even though a katan who picks something up from the floor, that's hefker, he cannot be kone'ed mi dar eisah, but if I sell it to him, if I give it to him, it can be, kodas acheres makne', so to here, she is makne'ed herself, and then he is kone'ed through the maisabiyah.

Masha'en kein b'kesav, oh b'shtar, b'kesav and shtar, where the keresh, sotorach acheres l'haknos lo'kesav, where the keresh has to be makne', the kesev has to be a transfer, And therefore, that wouldn't work.

So maybe that's what the Gemara means.

The Kedusha B'ya would be Darai, so the other ones would be Durabanan.

Or no, even Kedusha B'ya might be Durabanan.

It's just stronger.