The University of Chicago Press Podcast
Sep 3, 2026 · 43 min · 18 segments
Elisa Tamarkin, an English prof of high repute (Anglophilia and…
Elisa TamarkinGuest
Jon PlotzHost
That's such a great framing, but I want to understand a little bit more of the we who should or shouldn't understand.

And this is, you know that I have this sort of Arendtian fixation on like lying in politics and the problem, like of the Pentagon Papers, the knowledge that was disseminated.

And the distinction that Arendt makes, which I think we're going to probably come back to because it's about bubbles of misinformation or bubbles of delusion, is between the things that were known or not known within the Pentagon or within the corridors of power versus what we as a country knew.

And so can I ask how you think about the relationship between those things? How do you think about that we?

So Arendt actually wrote an essay about the evacuation, the final evacuation of Vietnam.

One of the points that she is making... is that not only did the government know what it needed to know, that the war for the US had ended in defeat and that the country would be reunified, liberated by the North from the US presence, but her idea was that actually all the information that needed to be known had been out in the press already.

that there had been intelligence leaks, that the CIA had fed to the press, CIA leaks had fed to the press everything that needed to be known, that there was no intelligence actually that was left to be known.

Part of that has to do with the Pentagon Papers, which she also had written about.

The Pentagon Papers was a 3,000-page narrative with 4,000 pages of appended documents.

that were about the US involvement in Vietnam since World War II, that basically predicted the end exactly as it occurred on that day in April.

No one read them even when they were presented, even when they were excerpted in the news, even when they went viral as a story in the news.

Somehow the news was out there, the information was out there, but it didn't register.

And either because of the superabundance of the information, too much information to sort through that you couldn't make any sense of it, or because somehow the war had fallen out of consciousness in such a way that people were bored of it, it had been ending for too long, it had been endlessly ending, the ongoingness of the war somehow meant that the facts didn't register.

And so for Arendt and for others, it becomes a question of not so much producing information or producing the facts, but having the public believe the facts that are out there already.

And then the work of the press, the work of writers and intellectuals becomes the work of trying to raise consciousness.

People were simply bored of the war, and its ongoingness meant that it no longer really made the news.

Part of what interests me in covering that last day is the fact that the foreign press had essentially left Vietnam by the time the ending happened.

They all had to fly in for the end, days before the end, as these kind of parachute reporters, to cover the story that should have happened years before.

I think the crucial question is being able to recognize that the war would end.

That's such a great framing, but I want to understand a little bit more of the we who should or shouldn't understand.

And this is, you know that I have this sort of Arendtian fixation on like lying in politics and the problem, like of the Pentagon Papers, the knowledge that was disseminated.

And the distinction that Arendt makes, which I think we're going to probably come back to because it's about bubbles of misinformation or bubbles of delusion, is between the things that were known or not known within the Pentagon or within the corridors of power versus what we as a country knew.

And so can I ask how you think about the relationship between those things? How do you think about that we?

So Arendt actually wrote an essay about the evacuation, the final evacuation of Vietnam.

One of the points that she is making... is that not only did the government know what it needed to know, that the war for the US had ended in defeat and that the country would be reunified, liberated by the North from the US presence, but her idea was that actually all the information that needed to be known had been out in the press already.

that there had been intelligence leaks, that the CIA had fed to the press, CIA leaks had fed to the press everything that needed to be known, that there was no intelligence actually that was left to be known.

Part of that has to do with the Pentagon Papers, which she also had written about.

The Pentagon Papers was a 3,000-page narrative with 4,000 pages of appended documents.

that were about the US involvement in Vietnam since World War II, that basically predicted the end exactly as it occurred on that day in April.

No one read them even when they were presented, even when they were excerpted in the news, even when they went viral as a story in the news.

Somehow the news was out there, the information was out there, but it didn't register.

And either because of the superabundance of the information, too much information to sort through that you couldn't make any sense of it, or because somehow the war had fallen out of consciousness in such a way that people were bored of it, it had been ending for too long, it had been endlessly ending, the ongoingness of the war somehow meant that the facts didn't register.

And so for Arendt and for others, it becomes a question of not so much producing information or producing the facts, but having the public believe the facts that are out there already.

And then the work of the press, the work of writers and intellectuals becomes the work of trying to raise consciousness.

People were simply bored of the war, and its ongoingness meant that it no longer really made the news.

Part of what interests me in covering that last day is the fact that the foreign press had essentially left Vietnam by the time the ending happened.

They all had to fly in for the end, days before the end, as these kind of parachute reporters, to cover the story that should have happened years before.

I think the crucial question is being able to recognize that the war would end.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.