Sincerely Supernatural Podcast
Aug 12, 2026 · 27 min · 9 segments
What if the person you see isn't really the person you think it is?In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we read some of the creepiest viewer-submitted paranormal stories we've received…
Our boys were asleep, but for some reason my eyes were locked on that pink house.
Mm.
I felt scared, but I eventually decided to go to sleep.
A while later, I had the worst sleep paralysis of my life in a car.
That's horrifying.
Yeah.
In the middle of nowhere.
Yeah, at a gas station.
At night.
Yeah.
[laughs]
Oh my gosh.
[upbeat music] Hello and welcome to Sincerely Supernatural, the show where we talk about the strange, mysterious, and unexplained.
I am your host Hudson.
And I'm the other guy, Seth.
What do we got today?
We got some more stories today.
Read the full transcript.
Create an account to read the whole episode, search across every transcript, and follow the shows you care about.
Our boys were asleep, but for some reason my eyes were locked on that pink house.
Mm.
I felt scared, but I eventually decided to go to sleep.
A while later, I had the worst sleep paralysis of my life in a car.
That's horrifying.
Yeah.
In the middle of nowhere.
Yeah, at a gas station.
At night.
Yeah.
[laughs]
Oh my gosh.
[upbeat music] Hello and welcome to Sincerely Supernatural, the show where we talk about the strange, mysterious, and unexplained.
I am your host Hudson.
And I'm the other guy, Seth.
What do we got today?
We got some more stories today.