Alice SullivanGuestSo let's just start by, you know, what is sex? And I don't mean give us the whole thing about gametes and, you know, how biology works.

And it's always been, I think, alongside age, it's always been the absolute foundational category for data collection, including in the census.

governments have always wanted to know how many male and female people of each age group they have in the country.
And from your point of view, people's life courses are very different if they're male or female.
What sort of arguments do you get from people who say that we shouldn't record it or that we shouldn't be asking about it.

So some people seem to think that if you acknowledge the reality of sex, that somehow that's what creates inequalities between the sexes, which is a completely mad argument.

If that was the case, then we could abolish economic inequality by not asking people how much money they have.

And if you go back to the academic literature, people like Judith Butler, you will find them overtly arguing that education, collecting data, naming categories, handing out certificates, that these are the things that actually create sex.
I mean, I think it was Statistics New Zealand that That basically, I'm going to try and find it, or maybe you can remember it, what exactly they said about why we shouldn't be asking people about their sex, but asking them about their gender identity instead.
So let's just start by, you know, what is sex? And I don't mean give us the whole thing about gametes and, you know, how biology works.

And it's always been, I think, alongside age, it's always been the absolute foundational category for data collection, including in the census.

governments have always wanted to know how many male and female people of each age group they have in the country.
And from your point of view, people's life courses are very different if they're male or female.
What sort of arguments do you get from people who say that we shouldn't record it or that we shouldn't be asking about it.

So some people seem to think that if you acknowledge the reality of sex, that somehow that's what creates inequalities between the sexes, which is a completely mad argument.

If that was the case, then we could abolish economic inequality by not asking people how much money they have.

And if you go back to the academic literature, people like Judith Butler, you will find them overtly arguing that education, collecting data, naming categories, handing out certificates, that these are the things that actually create sex.
I mean, I think it was Statistics New Zealand that That basically, I'm going to try and find it, or maybe you can remember it, what exactly they said about why we shouldn't be asking people about their sex, but asking them about their gender identity instead.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.