Skip to main content
Alice Sullivan

Alice Sullivan

Professor of Sociology at University College London (UCL Social Research Institute), author of Sex and Gender (2023) and Sex, Lies and Statistics (2026).

Sep 25, 2026

34:03
So why are we destroying everything? I mean, am I being too cynical there?
34:07
I think that probably is too cynical because Scotland asked a much better, in their sense, they asked a much better question, which used the word trans, which people understand.
34:18
So, you know, are you trans? But people who aren't trans know that they're not trans, so they don't say yes to that question.
34:26
Whereas what the Office of National Statistics did was, I mean, they followed probably quite a similar process to the Scottish censors.
34:35
in that they went out and they did little focus groups with a few people who identified as transgender and they didn't talk to anyone else and they didn't do quantitative testing.
34:49
Now, if you just talk to a handful of people and ask them what they think, The answer you get from one thing may be a bit random because it just depends on who you've got in the room, but also they were exquisitely concerned about how is this question going to make these people feel rather than will everybody else be able to understand the question? And of course, if you're trying to identify a very small group of people, it's really, really important that the people who aren't in that category understand the question, because it's like 99% of people should be saying no, or 99.5% of people should be saying no, and only 0.5% of people should be saying yes, then if you get 1% of people from that 99% who get the question wrong, that will actually swamp the real population that you're interested in.
35:44
And people often think, you know, that the problem is that you get the number wrong, like the population number.

6 MINS LATER

41:56
So the first one was when? Was it 2017, 2018?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.