Skip to main content
For Women Scotland

For Women Scotland

Search complete. 10 mentions across 9 episodes found for "For Women Scotland".

Nov 18, 2026

Kishwer FalknerGUEST
17:43
That was the key of the misinterpretation of the Act.
Kishwer FalknerGUEST
17:48
And actually the Supreme Court, where it finally ended up in a famous ruling called For Women Scotland versus the Scottish Ministers, the Supreme Court criticizes us, rightly criticizes us.
Kishwer FalknerGUEST
18:01
It didn't believe the Act was unclear.
Kishwer FalknerGUEST
18:03
It believed our interpretation of the Act was unclear.
David RoseHOST
20:30
So for doing our jobs, you almost lost them?
Kishwer FalknerGUEST
20:33
Yes.
David RoseHOST
20:34
Do you think that there's a sense that this conversion practices bill is an attempt to, as it were, row back on the For Women Scotland decision, as it were, by the back door to have another go at gender self-ID and so on?
Kishwer FalknerGUEST
20:50
Well, I think it's an attempt through the front door rather than the back door.
Akua ReindorfGUEST
33:04
So that's CAS.
Akua ReindorfGUEST
33:05
And three, that it will mean that people are not in a position to enforce their Four Women Scotland rights in the sense that anything that they do which seeks to establish with an individual that they are their sex, runs the risk of being a conversion practice.
Akua ReindorfGUEST
33:29
So the fear of that happening will cause a chilling effect.
Akua ReindorfGUEST
33:35
And the chilling effect in general is the other sort of main way in which this will be successful.
Savage Minds

Savage Minds

Robert Wintemute

Nov 11 · 1 Mention

Robert WintemuteGUEST
16:48
I mean, meaning that you'll see changes in some institutions and nothing and continued resistance in others.
Robert WintemuteGUEST
16:59
So, for example, we have the For Women Scotland judgment of the UK Supreme Court in 2025, followed this year by guidance from the Equality and Human Rights Commission on single-sex spaces.
Robert WintemuteGUEST
17:16
And, um, so you, you hear reports that some local governments are saying, no, we're not going to comply with the guidance.
Robert WintemuteGUEST
17:26
And, uh, you have the Hampstead Heath, um, pawns, which are ladies, men's and mixed, holding a referendum, well, through a consultation.
Tanya de GrunwaldHOST
33:08
So it will.
Tanya de GrunwaldHOST
33:08
What will be interesting to see is how this conflicts with For Women Scotland and the EHRC guidance, where employees can now be told they cannot use toilets not matching their biological sex, would stating this, i.e. you're male and have to use the male facilities, be a form of conversion practice? This person asks, this person says, um, the CIPD will stay clear of this one.
Tanya de GrunwaldHOST
33:30
It's a broader societal issue than HR slash employment.
Tanya de GrunwaldHOST
33:33
So they will let others have the fight.
Jennifer ShieldsGUEST
24:12
So I do think it was a bit of a misunderstanding or differing priorities.
Jennifer ShieldsGUEST
24:19
But definitely we're already seeing some, I guess, strategic litigation from the anti-trans side to attempt to essentially do what's happened in the UK with Four Women Scotland and force a definition of sex in the Human Rights Act that excludes trans people.
Jennifer ShieldsGUEST
24:36
Yeah, so that's probably the next fight for us.
Jennifer ShieldsGUEST
24:38
But similarly, you know, there's a members' bill floating around Parliament where if the left bloc wins this election, it's likely that we might see legislative changes to the Human Rights Act to make that protection more explicit and clearer.
Ken MacdonaldHOST
21:42
First of all, this it's so truly disappointing to find this podcast consistently fall below its own standards.
Ken MacdonaldHOST
21:49
Whenever you discuss trans people, um, Not only are you being intentionally obtuse about what harm the bill is addressing and ambivalent about whether it is even a harm at all, you also consistently fail to invite guests that can shed light on opposing views, which has been ongoing since at least the case involving For Women Scotland.
Ken MacdonaldHOST
22:09
That's the case in the Supreme Court where the Supreme Court said the Equality Act referred to biological... sex.
Ken MacdonaldHOST
22:15
And Satiris went on to say this, of course a conversion therapy bill targets speech.
Chris MartensonHOST
0:29
UK hospitals must now place trans-identifying patients by biological sex after the country's National Health Service reversed 2019 gender identity guidance.
Chris MartensonHOST
0:39
The shift follows the Supreme Court's For Women Scotland ruling and the Equality and Human Rights Commission Code interpreting the Equality Act 2010.
Chris MartensonHOST
0:47
Single-sex wards rest on biological sex.
Chris MartensonHOST
0:51
Alternatives such as single-occupancy rooms remain available.
Neale HanveyGUEST
15:45
But the effect of this legislation, if it came into law, would be to roll back every success that we've had resisting this legislation completely.
Neale HanveyGUEST
15:56
And that's from the Forstater judgment right through to the For Women Scotland victory in the UK Supreme Court.
Neale HanveyGUEST
16:03
None of that would matter because the scope of this legislation is deliberately drafted in such a broad way that it will capture any Now that could mean, I think somebody joked to me before we came on stage, that could mean the raising of an eyebrow.
Neale HanveyGUEST
16:19
But it really, you know, it's very difficult to know what would be in scope and what wouldn't be in scope.
Sall GroverGUEST
18:05
So it was sort of a test case to see which one had more weight.
Sall GroverGUEST
18:07
At the time, I mean, this is pre-Four Women Scotland, and it was just the first one directly tackling sex versus gender identity in a discrimination case.
Sall GroverGUEST
18:18
And yeah, so he won the first round.
Sall GroverGUEST
18:22
The judge said that sex is changeable.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.