Oct 11, 2026 · 18 min · 10 segments
Hey everyone! Welcome back to Pretty Creepy. On today's episode, we'll be talking about three unsolved mysteries from Wyoming, Wisconsin, and West Virginia. TikTok: madi\_moon\_333 IG…
Madi MoonHost
Living in the small town of Lander with her husband, Steve, Amy spent the morning running errands before driving into the Shoshone National Forest.
Her goal was to scout out a remote mountain loop road for an upcoming 10K race she was helping organize.
The car was unlocked, her car keys, expensive sunglasses, and a race planning to-do list were left inside, and the only item missing was her wallet.
Hundreds of volunteers, canine units, and helicopters scored thousands of acres of the dense wilderness.
No clothing, no blood, no tracks, and no signs of struggle or a predatory animal attack.
The case remains entirely unsolved, primarily because of this total absence of physical evidence.
Because the area wasn't immediately treated or secured as a crime scene, Any potential forensic clues were likely compromised early on by the influx of searchers.
Over nearly three decades, investigators have been left with a ghost of a timeline and plenty of theories, but nothing concrete to tie a suspect to a crime.
All right, so obviously this is unsolved, but there are some theories, and these are the three main theories that I found.
Investigators noted gaps in his timeline, aggressive or unsettling entries in his personal journals.
and the fact that, on the advice of his lawyer, he refused to take a polygraph test and stopped cooperating with police.
While he was a primary focus of public scrutiny, his friends backed up his alibi, and he has always maintained his innocence and has never been charged.
Living in the small town of Lander with her husband, Steve, Amy spent the morning running errands before driving into the Shoshone National Forest.
Her goal was to scout out a remote mountain loop road for an upcoming 10K race she was helping organize.
The car was unlocked, her car keys, expensive sunglasses, and a race planning to-do list were left inside, and the only item missing was her wallet.
Hundreds of volunteers, canine units, and helicopters scored thousands of acres of the dense wilderness.
No clothing, no blood, no tracks, and no signs of struggle or a predatory animal attack.
The case remains entirely unsolved, primarily because of this total absence of physical evidence.
Because the area wasn't immediately treated or secured as a crime scene, Any potential forensic clues were likely compromised early on by the influx of searchers.
Over nearly three decades, investigators have been left with a ghost of a timeline and plenty of theories, but nothing concrete to tie a suspect to a crime.
All right, so obviously this is unsolved, but there are some theories, and these are the three main theories that I found.
Investigators noted gaps in his timeline, aggressive or unsettling entries in his personal journals.
and the fact that, on the advice of his lawyer, he refused to take a polygraph test and stopped cooperating with police.
While he was a primary focus of public scrutiny, his friends backed up his alibi, and he has always maintained his innocence and has never been charged.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.
