2026-08-30

OK, so as mentioned, the first question here is, I think I was learning with Peretz also on Thursday, and we were, I think it's a very natural thing to be a bit kind of bothered by, right? In terms of the structure of the Mishnah, going back to the structure of the Mishnah, yeah? So the first post on Yud-Zion, I'm advised, yeah? So the mission is talking basically about what happens if you kind of start or end or change somewhere in between, you know, in terms of your status of being poor or rich, right? And basically the point is, when it comes to Erechin, we're kind of quite marked here that effectively, well, you know, according to Rabbi Huda, if any time you're rich, according to the Tanakhama, if, you know, the key points, the beginning or end, you're rich, then, you know, you get fixed as being rich.

and and the mission then says of our commonness ain't okay kubanis which we understand is talking about the components from mitsura is different yeah and it says a feeling right and even if you're you know his father was to die and leave him tens of thousands and then all his ship was to come in yeah ain't the hectic for him club so The question here is, yeah, that what's the connection between the words of our book, and then the continuation.

So we're kind of used to, which is, this is very good in terms of what our instinct should be, is what are you talking about, Yisrael? We learned Rashi, yeah? So the first point in here is Rashi, yeah? So Rashi says that this afilu is basically separate.

We kind of stop.

Yeah, you say Corbinus, Anakain, it's understood that it's different, that the Mishnah doesn't say how it's different, but it's just understood that that's, you know, and the Gemara will spell out later on that when it comes to Corbinus and Sura, it's fixed by a certain time.

You just look, whatever the time is, yeah, but let's say, According to one opinion, you know, when you bring your khatas, what's your status? Bang, it's fixed.

It doesn't matter if, you know, before you, you know, afterwards, you know, you get rich or whatever.

It doesn't matter, yeah? It's one point in time.

So that's just not spelled out by the mission.

But, okay, it just stops there.

And then the next part is really, is a standalone.

So Rashi says, right, this is number one, the first one.

He says, Yeah? Yeah? It's all about Erechon, and it's a completely new thing.

And what is that talking about? Let's just speak that out.

So when the Gemara comes along, the Gemara starts off, by the way, by saying, wait a sec, it clarifies what it's talking about.

It ends up talking about a situation of where the father is basically on death's bed.

And there, basically, seemingly the Kiddush is that even though he's a ghost, he's kind of about to die, that doesn't make you kind of rich.

And similarly, the ship, you know, it's coming in.

No, that doesn't make you rich.

In the simple sense, that seems to be then how you'd read it.

It's kind of a new thing.

Fine.

But you'd be forgiven for feeling a little bit uncomfortable, yeah, because of that.

And let's say, I mean, a number of them, unfortunately, I'm just going to, and the Rambam, the Baltanura, I'm going to pick here on Rabbeinu Gershon, because, you know, for most people, it's in their Gemara.

So, I mean, let's have a look at Rabbeinu Gershon, yeah? uh you'll see we'll see also in taste this you know there's a whole discussion about this this one but to remain aggression is very clear so he says the following yeah he says on this on this dinner of of of filu he says uh so this is the first part this is a corbanus anakin yeah So if he's an ani and then he becomes rich, he doesn't bring a rich person's korban.