Extra Points - a Pop Warner podcast
Oct 9, 2026 · 34 min · 12 segments
On Episode 16 of Extra Points, we dive into NFL Replay with Mark Butterworth, the NFL’s vice president of replay training and development.
Uh, so I love your answer there, and one thing that really stuck out, stood out for me is, um, you're there to correct errors on the field.
So, and, and this, I'm making a point here, trying to get into th- we're kind of in the direction of youth sports, but it's already built in that you know there's gonna be errors on the field.
Uh, it doesn't always, people at maybe youth or grassroots levels don't always have that perspective, or not everybody has that perspective.
Um, I- do you have any sense on, like, what different traits would make a good official that could be applied at the lower levels, youth, high school, maybe some college levels? Like, I'm trying to connect, we, there's a big issue in youth sports right now where there's just a shortage of officials, and, and I'm sure-
I, I love the question because I'm, I'm trying to tell as many young people as possible, just go to your local association.
Go work the eight-year-old flag football game, because you're gonna fall in love with it, and the key with that, too, is f- find an official there and talk to them, typically a more experienced, a, a, an older official that, that will mentor you, and that- that's one of the first keys.
The other thing is h- if you have the passion for football, passion for the game, you get to see the game from such a different perspective, and you're g- again, you're go- not only are you gonna fall in love with it, you're gonna figure out, how do I get better? And being able to build those relationships with other officials, that's really going to help you.
Th- uh, one of my first experiences officiating, I did a, a, a third and fourth grade girls basketball game, and they were out of, uh, offi- the officials didn't show up.
They're like, "Hey, Butter, would you come do this?" So I did it, and I couldn't believe not only how tough it was, but how fun it was, and it gives, uh, it gave me, as a parent, a very different perspective of what officials have to do.
I knew most of them, but still, um, for, especially for a young person, they just need to understand they're not going to be perfect, but if you chase that perfection, you will be excellent.
And as, when they understand that, and, and when they make those errors, just don't make the same ones again.
My best learnings, and I, we don't wanna cover them today, believe me, but I've had a few errors in my officiating career at the NFL level, and they hurt.
I, I, you know, one thing that we're doing at Pop Warner is we have a set of rules that, Pop Warner rule book usually mo- for the most part, um, takes or borrows from, uh, National Federation of High Schools.
Uh, so I love your answer there, and one thing that really stuck out, stood out for me is, um, you're there to correct errors on the field.
So, and, and this, I'm making a point here, trying to get into th- we're kind of in the direction of youth sports, but it's already built in that you know there's gonna be errors on the field.
Uh, it doesn't always, people at maybe youth or grassroots levels don't always have that perspective, or not everybody has that perspective.
Um, I- do you have any sense on, like, what different traits would make a good official that could be applied at the lower levels, youth, high school, maybe some college levels? Like, I'm trying to connect, we, there's a big issue in youth sports right now where there's just a shortage of officials, and, and I'm sure-
I, I love the question because I'm, I'm trying to tell as many young people as possible, just go to your local association.
Go work the eight-year-old flag football game, because you're gonna fall in love with it, and the key with that, too, is f- find an official there and talk to them, typically a more experienced, a, a, an older official that, that will mentor you, and that- that's one of the first keys.
The other thing is h- if you have the passion for football, passion for the game, you get to see the game from such a different perspective, and you're g- again, you're go- not only are you gonna fall in love with it, you're gonna figure out, how do I get better? And being able to build those relationships with other officials, that's really going to help you.
Th- uh, one of my first experiences officiating, I did a, a, a third and fourth grade girls basketball game, and they were out of, uh, offi- the officials didn't show up.
They're like, "Hey, Butter, would you come do this?" So I did it, and I couldn't believe not only how tough it was, but how fun it was, and it gives, uh, it gave me, as a parent, a very different perspective of what officials have to do.
I knew most of them, but still, um, for, especially for a young person, they just need to understand they're not going to be perfect, but if you chase that perfection, you will be excellent.
And as, when they understand that, and, and when they make those errors, just don't make the same ones again.
My best learnings, and I, we don't wanna cover them today, believe me, but I've had a few errors in my officiating career at the NFL level, and they hurt.
I, I, you know, one thing that we're doing at Pop Warner is we have a set of rules that, Pop Warner rule book usually mo- for the most part, um, takes or borrows from, uh, National Federation of High Schools.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.