Bechorot 28 בכורות כ״ח

So the Idach.

So now Debbi Rebbe, right, why didn't they learn it from Shlamim? Why did they bring the Pasuk Shanah Be Sha- tell me two days? The Gemara says, Im Yadam, Ikrimai Mar Chazah Beshok shel Todah.

We bring a Todah, and Todah wouldn't have helped us.

We'd have said, ah, Bechor is like a Todah.

And what's unique to the Todah? The Todah's eaten in one day.

Ah, they have eaten Bechor also one day.

Therefore, they used to us.

Then [thudding] now Rav.

Right, so now the question that we started over here, right, is that Rav asked that que- of that same question.

So what's, what's, what, what's, wha- wha- what did he say to that? Amakrah Lecha Yihye.

He says, no, you wouldn't have had a Havamina.

Pasuk says, Lecha Yihye Hosif Lecha Hakatuv Havaya Acher B'Bechor.

The Bechor has got Lecha Yihye.

It's an extra Havaya.

In other words, the Bechor, you wouldn't even ...

Even if you would've learnt from Kochim, would've said Kochim is a, a Todah is one day.

The Bechor got extra Havaya.

It's already two days.

Then Idach.

So now what does Rebbe say to ...

What, what does, wha- what does he say? He says Ikrimai Mar Haya Lach.

Right, so Debbi Rebbe would say, no, you wouldn't have learnt that Lach.

That Lach wouldn't have helped you get out of the two days if we had learnt it from, from, from, uh, from Todah.

Why? Because he says that Hai Yihye Lach Limela Bechor Baal Mum Shen Lotnolo Kohen.

That year, the extra Havaya means that even the Bechor of a Baal Mum, you gotta give to the Kohen.