Jul 9, 2026 · 2 hr 49 min · 11 segments
Madonna Month icon Patrik Sandberg is back to help Yasi break down 'Confessions II,' Madonna’s return to the dance floor. They break down the album’s callbacks to New York nightlife, the name-checks from Debi Mazar and Mark Kamins to Basquiat and Keith Haring, and why Madonna is revisiting one of her most beloved eras. Plus, our review (we love it)! **CREDITS:** Host: Yasi Salek @yasisalek Guests: Patrik Sandberg @patriksandberg Producer: Rob Sundermann Editor: Jamie Yukich Additional Production Supervision: Justin Sayles Theme Song: Bethany Cosentino Learn more about your ad choices. Visit [podcastchoices.com/adchoices](https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices)
Yasi SalekHost
Patrick SandbergGuestAvailable on Business plans.
Sign up to unlock[upbeat music] What's with this band anyway? I don't get it, can you please explain? Wait, like, bandsplain? Never heard this band in my life.
Oh, you haven't? I love them.
Really? Why? Yeah, I love this song.
Oh, I don't know that one.
Bandsplain, bandsplain, bandsplain.
I really hate this band.
Whatever, I'm their biggest fan.
Bandsplain, bandsplain, bandsplain, bandsplain.
Bandsplain.

Hello, and welcome to Bandsplain.

I am your host, Yosi Salak.

This is usually a show where I invite an expert guest to come on and help me explain an iconic artist or a cult band.

Today's episode is an emergency episode to cap off our seemingly never-ending Madonna series.

We have gathered here today to talk about the 15th Madonna studio album that came out last week, Confessions on a Dance Floor 2.

Patrick, I've got something I wanna talk about.

It's a shemergency episode.

[laughs] It's a...

Sorry, it's a hermergency.

[laughs]

[laughs]

Um, we are-

It's a she-hermergency

... we are joined, of course, by Patrick Sandberg of Madonna Bandsplain Part 2 fame, uh, our resident gay, Madonna expert extraordinaire.

We- welcome to the show.

If I wasn't a Madonna expert before-

[laughs] You, I-

... you've made me one

[laughs] by sheer force of Google Doc.

By sheer force of y- force of your hundreds of hours-

[laughs]

... of research, we're all Madonna experts now.

I hope so.

As, as we said before, open the schools, you know?

Correct.

Um, thank God, is all I wanted to say.

[laughs]

[laughs] The relief.

The re- yeah, because, okay, we were joking around before we started recording, um, with our beautiful producers and engineers, and they were like, "Another Madonna episode?" And I was like, "Honestly, if the album hadn't have been good, we probably would've, like, [exhales sharply] like moved-"

Yeah

... on with our lives," you know? But the album is so good.

It's, it's like a seminal album.

Yeah.

Which, and I do wanna firstly apologize to that one guy, the one commenter-

Mm-hmm

... who's like, "When are you gonna get back to talking about guitar bands?" [laughs]

[laughs] I know.

So, I know.

He's like, "What happened to the guitar bands?"

Um-

And it's like-

And to him I say, "Skip all the way to the last track on the album."

There you go.

We have a little guitar-

The Rory Side Girl

... for you.

Um, it w- it, it's like there were rumors for a long time that the album was good.

Yeah.

You know?

I heard a few of those.

In elite gay circles-

[laughs]

...

there were whispers, "The album's really good." And then some of us, you know, by virtue of proximity or whatnot, were able to hear some of it-

Yeah

... a while ago, and kind of verify that it was good.

So when you actually [laughs] were first doing Madonna month, I remember I told you the album was coming out in June.

Yeah

Around Pride sometime, which you didn't even know.

I had no idea.

You were just doing Madonna.

And I was like, "Don't worry.

The album's good."

Yes.

And that was me saying, "That's what everybody's saying."

Right.

And from, like, the little snippets that I've heard, it's gonna be good, and knowing, of course, that Stuart Price was working on it, which speaks volumes.

Yes.

Yeah, I think, you know, it, uh, how, what were we betting people, just given-

Mm

...

the bit of information we had, I think we could've known at the very least it wasn't gonna be bad.

Yeah.

And then as the singles kind of rolled out, people were starting to actually kind of debate, like, if it was really major or not.

They're like, "I like it, but is it, like, amazing?"

Yeah.

And it was like...

And we can get into the rollout of these songs and how they play now-

Yeah

... hearing them in the context of the album, but I think that, like, it was like we all kind of resigned ourselves to, like, okay, it's gonna be tasteful, and it's gonna be good.

Right.

We don't know if it's gonna be phenomenal, and it's actually phenomenal.

Spoiler alert, it's phenomenal.

Yeah.

At the very least, we knew it wasn't gonna be some sort of, like, 19 songwriter in a camp monstrosity-

Yeah

... that we've perhaps suffered through in the past.

Um, and yeah, I wanna talk, I do wanna talk about the rollout, and I wanna talk about the song, 'cause, like, I do feel it's so incredible, and I've heard other people say this, like, how much more they pop the singles within the context of the album, within the continuous mix of the album, how much my relationship changed with them since, like, the first listen to then hearing them as God intended [laughs]

Yeah

... as Stuart Price and Madonna intended.

Um, but I think us going, brag, to Club Confessions Los Angeles, one of the most insane nights of my life-

[laughs]

Felt like I was in a Fellini film.

It was-

It, it will forever-

At every turn-

... be the night that I met Tori Spelling.

You met Tori Spelling.

[laughs]

At every turn, I saw something more insane and, and convoluted to my brain.

Bruce Vilanch napping in a bench, just, like, everything you want it to be.

Um, but there, I was like, "Oh," 'cause they were playing the songs, or parts of the songs, right?

Mm-hmm.

And they were good, and I was like-

Really good

...

I, I know that in, I know, like, obviously the context heightened it.

It's how it's supposed to be heard.

You're in a club surrounded by people with open hearts for this music and, and gays dancing, you know? But it was, like, really good.

I went home from that being like, "This shit's gonna fucking bang."

It kind of reminds me of the first time I heard the songs that were in the Confessions film-

Mm

... which were played to me in an SUV.

Right.

Um-

In, in, in, in their entirety, or just the snippets?

It was the mega mix that they were-

That they used for the-

... editing the video to

Okay.

And the whole time I was kind of, my mind was being blown, but then it would skip to another song-

Right

... you know? And I was just like, "What?" And then I was like, "Wait, it's really good." And then I'd be like, "I don't know." And then I was like, "Actually-"[gasps] It was, like, crazy.

Hearing it for the first time in Club Confessions was like that too because you're just, like, in the moment.

You liked it, but then it was like, "What are you left with at the end of the night?"

Right, you had nothing to grab onto.

Yeah.

You couldn't-

You couldn't go home and play it

... we didn't know names.

We didn't know...

You know, you couldn't-

Mm

... you couldn't really make out the lyrics as much.

Um, well, we're gonna get into all of it.

We're gonna talk about the making of, we're gonna talk about the cover art, we're gonna talk about the themes, we're gonna talk about the Confessions film, we're gonna talk about the track by track, and we're gonna answer a bunch of listener questions.

But before we do all of that, I wanted to make sure that we, um, hear from our, uh, fellow compatriots, our fellow Bansplained Madonna month-

Hostages

[laughs] Hostages.

Col- uh, I was gonna say collaborators, but you're as hostages.

[laughs]

Stockholm Syndrome, nobody wanted to do this.

And the thing is everybody wanted to do it.

Everyone wants to do Bansplained-

We're all hostages to Madonna

... until they realize what Bansplained is.

She has us all-

It's true

... she has us all by the throat-

It's so true

... which is going to be a theme.

Okay.

First up we're gonna hear from Mel Ottenberg, Editor-in-Chief of Interview Magazine and the guest for Madonna Episode 1.
Yassi, it's Mel.
My favorite songs on Confessions 2 are Fragile, Lower East Side Girl, and The Test.
I think that Fragile I really like because I get the story, and I read, you know, his book or, like, I understand, like, the vibes, and it's interesting.
And The Test is just great, and Lower East Side I feel like is so great on it.
And Lower East Side's just got that sort of thing, and it's got, like, the boom, boom pow of a Madonna song.
You know? Like, a lo- like, last song on the album thing that you, like, didn't expect to be the one that you loved, but you love.
You know? And it, and that's how I feel.
And I do wanna say that as the Editor-in-Chief of Interview, I've always thought will I ever have a Madonna moment? I need to have a Madonna moment because I'm a Madonna head, but, like, will that ever come, or will it be a good idea if it does come? And to have been able to do something cool with her, and she was so great, and I just th- I think so highly of her.
And watching her model and be, uh, the diva goddess that she is and also get to sit with her for 90 fucking minutes and talk to her is, like, really a dream.
And I, and, uh...
But, like, to be able to do something cool with someone that is your hero is, is tough and hard, but, but I did it, bitch.
And I am f- I'm so grateful to her.
Um, and I'm so, think it's so great to be living in an actual Madonna moment.
Here we are.
It's 2026.
We're in a Madonna moment.
Bye.

Thank you, Mel Ottenberg.

That was perfectly said.

Yeah.

We really are living in a Madonna moment.

I think that's, like, such a takeaway.

Um, I don't know if it's partially because my algorithm is completely fried from my personal interest and research [laughs] for the last couple of months, but it feels like it's broken containment from that.

It has, and it feels different than Madame X and-

I don't-

...

Rebel Heart felt

...

I don't remember Madame X even, like, crossing my desk, if I'm being honest.

Well, they all crossed my desk.

[laughs] Yeah.

There's no way for them not to.

It's like-

I mean, I saw the eye patch artwork and stuff, and I remember clocking that, but I don't-

I-

...

I don't think I heard one single one of the songs at the time.

I'm always gonna be part of a cabal of, of gays and some lesbians and, uh, some trans girls and some straight girls [laughs] who-

[laughs]

... everyone except straight men probably-

Right

... who group text or who text every time Madonna-

Right

... does something whether we like it or not, and then dissecting it-

Sure

... talking about it.

So all those albums are very present for me, but this feels like a big Madonna moment.

I feel like a lot more people are talking about it.

Again, I'm, can't ever know because I'm biased given my current preoccupations.

Um-

Your instincts are correct.

Thank you.

Um, all right.

Next we're gonna hear from Madonna Bansplained Episode 4 guest, the one and only Karen Ganz.
Hi, Madonna-splained friends.
It is Karen.
Um, Confessions 2 is legitimately such a treat, it is a feast, uh, that I am still compiling my thoughts, but here are some quick impressions for you.
Um, my expectations were very high because Confessions is such a landmark album for her, and calling this part two it just set the bar.
Did I have some ambient concerns because of the spottiness of Madame X, her last release? Um, I did, but rooting for Madonna is like rooting for the Mets.
You know? You gotta believe.
Hashtag this is my religion.
Um, I think the album is of exceptionally high quality, and there is really only one song that's a skip for me every time.
That is Everything.
As much as I enjoy hearing Madonna say, "I don't fuck with it," um, that song is just not strong enough to me.
I think the album as a whole is perfectly sequenced.
It is gorgeous.
Uh, and for me, the standouts are I Feel So Free, which I thought was a really smart first single, Danceteria, Bizarre, School, and Betrayal.
And, yes, I appreciate her writing a song for me, an LES girl of 25 years.
Um, in the Madonna canon, I think this is a really strong entry that recasts the conversation about her late career work.
And if you listen to my episode, you know I'm a fan of almost everything she has put out since 2005, especially Hard Candy and MDNA, and parts of Rebel Heart really are quite strong.
But the generally negative reaction to Madame X I think was fair, and the Celebration Tour went a very long way to helping her bounce back after that, largely because it was such an effective reminder of the things she has done to invent and reinvent pop music in her image for five decades.
I think this album functions in a similar, though not identical way Um, I love the visuals.
Parts of the rollout did make me cringe, and I think this is because I want to see a Madonna who really does truly feel so free, and she still feels restrained or rehearsed to me in some of these moments.
Uh, part of what I've loved about this album is that, the rollout, is that it's made people dig up old interviews and spontaneous moments and put them on social media, and it's that Madonna, that like truly unhinged and unencumbered Madonna.
That is what I'd like to see right now.
Um, but overall, I think this is a mega win for her, and I am really fucking happy about it.

Karen Ganz.

Bravo.

I know.

[laughs]

Let's go home.

Karen, I mean-

[laughs]

Karen's-

She said everything I want to say

... a brilliant mind.

Um, yeah, I love that.

It was a little, kind of a lot to chew on, but I think she made good points.

I, I like, I don't, I don't fuck with that song.

[laughs] Um-

Same, and we'll get there

... and we'll get there.

I, it feels validating hearing this from the Karen Ganz.

I know, the one and only.

Because I know she has very high standards.

Yes, although we disagreed on almost every single album in the late period.

[laughs]

But also like, I, as sort of a Madonna worshiper-

Yeah

...

I do think that, like, cringe moments or things that don't work can be equally rewarding.

[laughs]

I think it's-

It's like I have-

It's like a feature, it's a feature, not a bug.

It's like part of the whole thing

...

I have low standards and high standards.

Yeah.

It's like it all brings me happiness, so I don't, I don't really know how to differentiate.

100%.

And last, but certainly not least, we're gonna hear from Madonna part three guest, the most lusted after guest of the Bands Playing series.

[laughs]

Okay, I'm sitting right here.

That was rude.

I said most, not only.

[laughs]

I, I sent you multiple comments-

I wanna thank the, the-

... that were also lusting after you.

[laughs]

Yeah, I wanna thank the three people who called me attractive.

Thank you.

Do you know what this, uh, Madonna series didn't do for me? Bring me any straight male attention.

[laughs]

[laughs]

But I have a million new gay friends, so-

Totally

... listen, you win some, you lose some.

Paul Heyman, let's hear it.
It's an incredible feeling to have this album be so good.
Um, there's the feeling of, wow, she really did it, and, uh, you know, it just really delivers on everything that we want from her.
Um, I think it's really cool how the album is sequenced and, you know, is a continuous mix, and it kind of really rewards listening to it from front to back.
And, uh, I really love that about it.
And even to me, a lot of the singles make a lot more sense, um, when listened to in context.
Even like something like I Feel So Free, I really love a lot more than I did, you know, when I first was listening to it.
I think it s- like it kind of sets the stage for the record in this, like, sonic way, references, uh, Confessions one, but then the rest of the album feels like a really, an evolution rather than a sequel, which I think is really cool.
So a lot of really fresh production, a much more sophisticated ref- palette of references.
You know, all kinds of music genres in there, techno, Detroit techno, Chicago house, like two-step, you know, French house.
It feel, it feels very, you know, like a really cool palette to pick from.
And it feels like she's making things that we've never heard her do before, which is really cool.
Uh, you know, something like School, it's just like we've never heard that before.
The level of, like, vocal production and, you know, the sort of processing of her voice, even things she's doing with her voice overall across the whole record, it, it's just, it's, it's just very cool that she's still sort of pushing the boundary of what she's doing.
A theme that I think is really cool in the whole sort of picture, like, is this kind of meta-narrative of Madonna lore, which I, we haven't really seen her play with that much before.
I mean, she kind of did Bitch I'm Madonna, you know, like some self-referential stuff in the past, but I feel like this is really kind of playing into kind of something that feels very internet and very right now.
And you're seeing, you know, obviously this very specifically sort of the, like, nexus of it is, is Danceeteria, which, you know, sort of tells the literal l- lore of Madonna.
But then I think that kind of reverbs out across the whole record, where it feels like, you know, this kind of ownership of the dance floor as a place of self-expression.
And then that even kind of reverberates out into the rollout, um, in this kind of very cool meta way where, you know, the rollout itself was building this thing organically, and that it was converging with the algorithm in this cool way.
So there's, like, this kind of fan-made art.
Even the things that they've been releasing, you know, on her Instagram, like that, you know, sort of BTS, um, Danceeteria reel, feels like it's just kind of playing into this idea of, like, the internet.
You're piecing together the history and, like, putting it into this, like, larger context.
It's really cool.
It feels very right now.
It feels very satisfying for everything.
So whether that was, like, really intentional or it's just happening organically or sort of like a combination of both, it feels very savvy.
And, you know, I think it's, it's, like, helping to kind of, like, make the album really feel like it's the pinnacle of this promotional cycle.
And, you know, m- miraculously there's kind of like, having a huge budget also helps who can do these kind of great activations like the Times Square thing and the Club Confessions rollout.
But also there's, like, no sense of, uh, fatigue.
Like, even through the whole, like, pre-rollout, you know, promotional cycle, it felt like the excitement just kept building, and the lore kept building around her.
Like, it was like a gathering of steam, like, you know, this kind of, like I said, convergence of this organic push and this a- algorithmic thing happening together.
That was very cool to watch, and I think it's kind of like, it's this ineffable thing that I don't know that you can create, you know, intentionally, and I think every marketer's dream [laughs] is that that happens.
But it really kind of happened, and because she's such a powerful figure in culture, it's just very cool to see.
And at this stage of her career, at the age that she is, everything about it is really e- extremely satisfying.
I think it gives people a lot of Joy to see it.
I mean, certainly as a fan I feel that way, but I think even, you know, I'm just seeing, you know, anecdotally people who aren't necessarily, like, big Madonna fans, like, really kind of getting swept up in it and being excited about it.
And, you know, let's face it, I don't think Bandsplain has no small part in that, because I think, you know, it's an influential circle that, like, pays attention to that, uh, to this, this podcast, and I think, you know, this, that Madonna month coming right where it did in the, like, promotional cycle [laughs] is, you know, helping.
That's part of it, so that's part of what I'm talking about, this kind of sense of, like, there's all this lore on the internet and it's kind of just, like, being gathered together, like this kind of tsunami wave of, um, algorithmic and organic, you know, promotion, and it just kind of built to this level.
And it's r- just v- really satisfying to see, and everybody feels really good about it.
So I think it's just a really great cultural moment that are...
Th- these things are rare, and it feels really great for her to have this now at this stage of her career.
I think it's really reestablishing her legacy, um, not that it really re- needed to be, but it's, like, just reaffirming that for those of us who have known all along.
And then, you know, school is in session for [laughs] the zoomers and everyone else who don't know, 'cause it's kind of this, you know, collecting and bringing together of all the lore on the internet and the current moment that feels like this really, like, kind of pretty magical convergence.
And, uh, it feels really good.
I think everybody feels a lot of excitement about it, and it's, uh, it's an awesome feeling.
We're so back.

Paul was like, "Hold my beer."
[laughs]

He really had something he wanted to talk about, but also he made just exquisite-
Yeah

... and salient points.
Sabrina, Madonna.

Yeah.

[laughs]
Yasi, Patrick.

Um...
I have something I wanna talk about.

Well, I think Paul's the last one I wanted to play, because I think we're gonna cover, like, almost each and every thing he talked about in there.
Yeah.

So [laughs] okay, this wouldn't be Bandsplain if I didn't do a little too much backstory.
Okay.

I will keep it brief.

This is for the people that for whatever reason either did not listen to Bandsplain Madonna one through four, though I must recommend.
There's still time.

I must recommend that you do it, or just, like myself, are brain-dead and do not retain [laughs] the information.

Um, and someone in our, when I solicited questions, did ask, like, "Can you give us an, a Stuart Price primer again?" Um-
Oh, okay.

[lips smack] And I think we didn't go into, like, super detail, so I'll, I'll try to be a little broad, but also talk a little bit more about him, 'cause obviously he's a hugely important part of this, uh, project.

So in 2001, Mirwi, who had just worked with Madonna on the album Music, introduced her to a then 23-year-old Stuart Price to be her keyboard player and ultimately music director for the Drowned World Tour.

Um, he was born in Paris.

He grew up in Reading, England.

He had started, uh, working on two acts in his career simultaneously, which were, I think bo- both on Wall of Sound, Zoot Woman, uh, with Adam Blake and Johnny Blake.
Jessie, please don't go.

[laughs] That's right.

Um, and then Jacques Lu Cont.
Mm-hmm.

But then making music under the name Les Rythmes Digitales.
So good.

Um-
So, so good

... which I didn't know this, but I really loved it.

Okay, so they put out that single "Jacques Your Body Make Me Sweat," and h- which charted, and he put an album out called Dark Dancer, and he would go, he would, like, go on interviews and pretend he only spoke French.
So major.

[laughs] So great.

Um, anyway, so that was...

So he had, like, a, a cool musical pedigree, and he was, you know, I don't think he was famous by any stretch, but you know, he was, like, a semi-known quantity in a certain world of dance music.
I mean, this was, like, the time of Electroclash, and it feels like-

Like late '90s.
Yeah.

Yeah.
And it was sort of like if you were in the clubs, you heard Les Rythmes Digitales.

Yeah, yeah.
Like, a lot.

Yeah, and of course Madonna loves, um, to be up in the clubs and to know what's up in the clubs.

By the way, you guys, just you should note I'm method because I'm back on the Celsius for this episode, so pray for Yasi.
[laughs]

Um, anyways, Stuart Price first kind of actually collaborated with Madonna co-writing "Ecstatic Process," actually one of my faves, um, off of 2003's American Life, and then he came back to be musical director for the Re-Invention Tour in 2004.

And I'm just gonna say this part again, 'cause it's one of my favorite pieces of lore, and I feel like more people need to hear about it, even though I think I, I triangulated the proof pretty well, but obviously there's not, like, cold, hard proof, but there's, there's enough proof to put together a breadcrumb trail, which is that Confessions sprang from an aborted film [laughs] that was meant to be directed by Luc Besson, who she had been working with on music videos.

They both love parkour.

Never forget who loves m- parkour more than Madonna: nobody.

Um, and-
They both love Gaultier.

[laughs] They both love Gaultier and parkour.

And it was, I- allegedly, supposedly a musical biopic about Candy Darling-
Mm-hmm

...

but a fictional one, because it was about a woman on her deathbed, Peter Hujar photo.
The photo.

[laughs] That was remembering her life throughout the decades, but these were not real memories, so it was like a science fiction.

It's Luc Besson.
Yeah.

Anyways, sounds fucking awesome.

Wish it had been made.

[laughs] But Madonna was, while sh- you know, she sent Luc Besson off to write the script, she set about to write music for it, and she tasked Stuart with the '70s portion, the disco portion, and she came to him and was like, "Do you have anything that sounds like ABBA?" And he was like, "That's so funny you should ask that." Because about six months before that he had been DJing in Liverpool, and he was driving home after.

And at 5:00 AM he heard "Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! (A Man After Midnight)" on the radio, and he was like, "You know what? This fucks This is me editorializing in, like, a lifetime reenactment.

Um, and he went home, and he cut a sample of that piano bit, and he started playing with it in his DJ sets, and people, like, went nuts for it.

So he brought that sample to her, and obviously, that song became Hung Up.

I think this is very interesting [laughs].

It's very interesting indeed.

Besides the fact, in and of itself it's very interesting, I think it's very interesting as we tie it into Confessions too because I think you could say in a, in a really strong way that Confessions too also comes from an aborted biopic.

Not directly in the same way, but very much, like, spiritually and, like, where Madonna's head has been at for quite a while was working on this also aborted biopic of her own life.

And I think it's really cool that Confessions one, 'cause there's other tracks on Confessions one that arose from that, uh, sci-fi musical.

I think it's really cool that Confessions two also definitely arose [laughs] from a biopic that was never made.

I think when, when she's doing that, something cool happens, especially here because she's reflecting on her own life.

Anyways, they didn't talk for 15 years.

She told that to Mel.

And, uh, then in 2023 she phoned him up and hired him again as musical director for the Celebration tour.

Um, and she went to go work on her film, ultimately scrapped-

Mm-hmm

... by Universal.

Patrick works in Tinseltown, so he knows about this kind of stuff.

Yes.

Um-

Since repackaged and set up at Netflix-

Yeah

... as a miniseries.

Budget constraints.

TBD.

TBD.

To be, I'm still waiting for the call to us, Patrick, as consultants.

Um, so am I.

Yeah.

[laughs] We're here, Netflix.

[laughs]

We're ready.

Um, so yeah, she was supposed to make this movie about her life.

They'd spent all these, like, she worked on the script for two years.

There was two years at Universal doing, like, budgeting and casting and all this stuff, and I think she said something great where she was like, "I've had a huge life, so I needed a big budget." [laughs] And-

Correct

... correct, yeah [laughs].

Give her everything she wants.

But, and, and maybe I'm wrong, I was under the impression the film does not cover her whole life.

I don't think so.

That it cuts off-

Yeah

... it's sort of about the-

At long ambition

...

the early days.

Is that right?

Yeah.

Yeah.

I mean, you c- think, first of all, again, I'll say one thing that I do feel that I'm pretty expert in, and it's music biopic films, and the biggest kiss of death is doing a cradle to grave.

Of course.

They're not good.

It's too much.

It doesn't make sense.

Unless you do it, like I, actually I don't wanna say never because I think there's someone who can subvert any form.

I'm sure there's a way to do it that's fucking bonkers and bizarre and weird and kind of funny and cool.

Baz Luhrmann's Elvis.

[laughs] Haven't seen it.

I'll, I'll-

Has just entered the chat [laughs]

I'll, I'll believe you.

Um-

Checks every box of every word you just said.

Yeah.

Every adjective.

Also, does, does it ca- Yeah, okay.

Okay.

It is batshit bonkers, breaks form-

Breaks form [laughs]

... completely.

Would you say it's good?

You know what?

Yeah? I haven't seen it.

Yes.

[laughs]

Okay.

I'm gonna, I'm gonna watch it.

It's good because it, in, in the context of itself it's good.

Okay, right.

[laughs]

It was, like, n- seeing it in the theater I was confused if I thought it was good or bad because it was so strange, but what I ...

Anyway, we won't get into it.

What I like about Baz Luhrmann is he's an auteur.

He does his own, he does his own thing.

He plays in his own sandbox.

Um, I don't-

He builds a crazy fucking sandcastle.

Much like Madonna, honestly.

Correct.

Um-

Not that they should-

Not that they should collaborate, no. [laughs]

No.

Um, so I thought it was really funny that there was, like, that bit in the interview that Mel did with her for Interview where she was like, "I, like, fixed it.

I was like, 'We'll film in Serbia.

It'll be cheaper.'" And they were like, "We don't think that you can be in Serbia for more than [laughs] four days." She was like, "Yes, I can.

I'm a survivor." Um, anyways, yes, like you pointed out, that failed.

She bought it back from them for some, um, insane amount of money, and then-

She can

... she can.

And then Netflix reached out, and I do feel like a, just my personal opinion, I think a short form series is likely to be more effective at capturing something like that, although I haven't seen it done that well.

Um, at least you have more space to play in and, and more easier t- time to do different kinds of pacing, like-

Mm-hmm

...

I don't know.

I-

It can be a deeper character study.

Exactly.

You can get more into the relationships.

Exactly.

Um, you don't have to, like, what they always do, particularly in biopics about men where they're like, "This woman never existed.

She is a-"

Hybrid

... "configuration of-"

Yeah

... "five of the women that this man dated." Um, okay, anyways.

So she was like, "Well, I need to, I need to create," apparently, right? That was, like, "I need to do something."

Mm-hmm.

"This is frustrating." And she said, "I reached out to Stuart Price 'cause I thought the world is in a very dark place and people need to dance." And she said, "What if we tried to make Confessions on a Dance Floor Part 2 and reenter the world of inspirational dance music?" And th- thank God.

And I think, you know, lot has been made, and I think Karen mentioned it and Paul definitely talked about it, how this is such a reflective album about looking back on her life, and it makes total sense.

Mm-hmm.

She spent four years-

Exactly

... immersed [laughs] in her own history.

She did it with the Celebration tour.

Yeah, exactly.

There was a lot of content within that tour.

It wasn't just that she was singing those old songs again.

It was like there were interludes that surfaced old remixes that had-

Right

...

some had never been released-

Yeah

...

but that fans were obsessed with.

And, like, she dug through her own back catalog, but also, like, the extended back catalog, and I think in doing so it ...

And also there was a big reissue project that happened-

Totally

... with all of her old albums where she was, like, remastering them, so she was just revisiting her whole career, and I think it got her, I don't wanna say nostalgic, but I think that it was, like, a good thing because she was sort of forced to look back.

Totally.

Because-

When she's, like, sort of willfully not done so for so long.

Right.

Yeah.

And so she's just already in that head space, and then plus the movie she's looking back at her origin.

And so it's not a surprise that all of that plays out on this album.

Not at all, and thank God.

But she does it in, like, kind of nuanced ways too.

It's not like- Um, the album isn't like, "Here's my story looking back." It's like she throws it in in, in, like, very fun, surprising ways.

Yeah.

And it stays fresh.

She's a...

I think she's a master of throwing in, like, cheeky little references.

Mm-hmm.

So those are all over the place, and there's obviously some more direct ones, like Danceteria.

Uh-huh.

I always wanna say Danceteria.

[laughs]

[laughs] Danceteria.

Y'all mind-

[laughs]

...

if a white girl speaks a little Spanish?

Oh.

Oh, the first one.

We need a sound effect for that.

And I-

A maraca.

Oh, yeah.

[laughs] A ah.

Um-

Maraca

...

so yeah, and she reunited with Warner Brothers, um, to put this out, which I think is also kind of a big deal given that was her, her home and label for, like, the majority of her career until those four albums.

And that is, that is the backstory.

That is where we are.

Yeah.

So that gets us to where we are.

I just wanna say about Stuart Price, like, um-

Hot

... [laughs] it's, it's like-

[laughs]

... th- 'cause I have seen things online of, like, who is Stuart Price? Why Stuart Price? Why do people care that this is Stuart Price? Like-

Open the schools.

And it's not-

[laughs]

But you know what? I, it's...

He's not, like, a household name.

No, no, that's true.

He's not someone that everybody knows.

And, like, he's not even someone who's, like, a Diplo who everyone is-

Right

... aware of.

It's like-

And thank God for fucking that.

Well, exactly.

[laughs]

But Stuart Price is someone who's...

And he kind of designed his career that way by taking on so many different aliases.

Right.

Right? Like, he had Zoo Woman was a band, but then Les Rythmes Digital, no one knew who that was-

Yeah

... really.

Like, and then he, he became Jacques Lu Cont, which was sort of, like, an identity trick that he was doing.

Right.

And then he-

He had Thin White Duke

...

Thin White Duke-

Yeah

... came after that.

And he's v- he's very selective about what he does, and he, he works a lot doing production with people, but he, as, like, with remixes and things like that, like, it's like he's very tasteful.

You know what fucks? His remix of Mr.

Brightside by The Killers.

Well, yeah, that's, like, one of the-

It's legendary.

[laughs]

That's one of the legendary ones.

Yeah.

Also, Whatchu Waiting For by Gwen Stefani, Jacques Lu Cont remix.

Get out of here.

[laughs]

He's also remixed and produced, like, New Order, Pet Shop Boys-

Yeah

...

Kylie Minogue, um, Dua Lipa, the good Dua Lipa album, Future Nostalgia.

Yeah, yeah.

Most recently he did Romy's solo album.

He did the Take That reunion album for my Take That-

Incredible

... heads, for my Robbie Williams heads.

[laughs]

Yeah, and there's, like, you know, s- he did incredible work with Seal.

[laughs]

Go back, go back and look up Clean.

Who couldn't do Amer- amazing work with Seal, though? It's Seal.

Amazing, I mean to say.

Yeah.

Amazing, and then the remix of Amazing, really incredible.

Depeche Mode, Scissor Sisters he worked with a bunch.

So it's one of those things where it's like, oh my God, the Thin White Duke remix of The Faint.

Okay, anyway.

[laughs] Speaking of-

Um-

Speaking of electric shock.

[laughs] Yeah, this was, like, if, if you were, like, out in the 2000s doing coke at parties-

Right

... you were hearing Stuart Price's music.

You've heard, you've heard Stuart Price's.

I, I wasn't-

It's like, he's like the Jo-

But I have, I have friends that were-

He's what Giorgio Moroder was, is, like, what Stuart Price was-

Yeah

... to the aughts, I feel like.

Yeah, yeah.

Totally.

So people who know about Stuart Price, when his name pops up, like when they found out Stuart Price is doing the Celebration Tour, that's like bing.

Like, your antenna is like, "I'm going."

Yeah.

Like, this is gonna be a big deal.

Well, also, like, again, he's, he's a former collaborator, but I think, like, Madonna's best albums are not done with, like, mega superstar producers of the world.

They're done with, like, these sort of more nuanced, niche people.

Niche is, is the wrong word, but you know what I'm saying.

Yeah.

Like-

Well, she likes to discover them

... she likes to discover them, but also I think she works, like...

How do I say this? Like, there's gonna be one boss.

Yeah.

[laughs]

Exactly.

And I, and I think these people have, like, a mega superpower in which they're so talented, but they're also able to coalesce and work with her in a way that, like, incredible e- Like, I think some of the biggest failings in her, in her latter stage career for me were like, you're trying to m- you're trying to put, fi- fit Madonna into your productions as if she's a feature.

Right.

And it's like Madonna is not a feature, you know, on her own albums, and these producers don't do that, you know?

Mm-hmm.

And Stuart Price is obviously one of those excellent producers, and she does the best when she works with one person-

Absolutely

... for the bulk of an album.

That's so integral, and I think she's known that and has been aware of that as well.

Yeah.

And it's been a way that she likes to write and she likes to work, and she's been wanting to go back to it.

Can I just say I have Spotify open in front of me?

Yeah.

And I can see what Karen Ganz is listening to, and she's listening to Danceteria right now.

[laughs] Oh my God, Karen.

[laughs]

What a real, what a real one.

[laughs]

Um, but what was I gonna say? I saw that and was like, "LOL." [laughs]

So good.

Well, why don't we use this opportunity to, to go to the next, um, part of our conversation?

Okay.

Which I really am gonna lean on you for-

All right

... 'cause I think you have such good insight here.

But we should obviously start with the cover art s-

Okay.

But we'll start with, we have behind us my personal favorite, although I've, I've heard-

Mm.

Mine, too

...

I thought it w- I thought it was everyone's favorite, but I've heard, like, people being like they don't like that, and I was like, "That's crazy."

Why, 'cause you can't see her face?

I don't...

S- said the pose was awkward.

I think the pose looks cool.

Um, the pose is hot.

She's about to get railed.

Mm-hmm.

[laughs] Someone's gonna come up behind her.

Mm-hmm, or she's, or she's stretching.

Akeem, her boyfriend, is gonna come up behind her.

Or she's doing a hamstring stretch.

Yeah.

Um, however you wanna look at it.

Working out.

Yeah.

[laughs] Um-

Dancing

...

I love it.

I also, I just, I love that typeface.

I love the, the color palette.

Like, everything about it to me is, like, so fab and major.

Mm-hmm.

I love the thigh-highs.

Um, but the, but that's not the main cover art, the like-

No

... or the primary cover art.

The primary cover art, we don't have it here, but will flash up on the screen.

It's, um, Madonna with a pink diaphanous veil-

Mm-hmm

...

in kind of a triangle seat, but also kind of forming a triangle.

Is that a yoga pose?

pose?I think it's just a, like, it's like a 90-90, and it's, like, her lavender color that she likes so much

It's a bit of the original Confessions on a Dance Floor color scheme.

Right, and, and the way sh- that she sat in that 90-90 very famously-

Mm-hmm

...

in the artwork and in the video for "Hung Up"-

Yeah

... which I have, I think, artfully recreated [laughs] in my arsenal

You absolutely.

It was shot for shot.

Video, so

Perfection

Um, do you feel...

Okay, so, or sh- we should shout out, this is photographed by Rafael Pavarotti, styling by Ibi Kamara, and the creative direction said raw materials.

Okay.

Apparently she said about the fabric, it's not back there, um, "It wasn't planned, but while we were fitting, I found this piece of fabric and it seemed perfect for creating movement.

And then while I was sitting on these speakers that are, like, the altar of the dance floor, I put it on my head as if I were becoming a saint.

Truly the Madonna, a kind of religious and revelatory image.

If you work with the right people, ideas come up like this.

That's how art is created." Um-

Mm-hmm

...

I love it because I love when Madonna gets in her fucking religious bag.

I love it.

I'm curious, we got a couple questions about this, and some people have just gone ahead and said this is definitely true.

I don't know where I land on it.

I do think Madonna rarely does anything by accident, and has looked at everything from every angle, so at least at the very least is probably aware it might be interpreted like this.

But what do you f- make of the idea that this is also meant to, like, be the ACT UP triangle? The pink ACT UP triangle.

It's a crap shoot, babe.

Yeah.

[laughs]

There's...

And, and I...

And, like, not to take away any intention that Madonna has as an artist, but when you do enough of these shoots, you realize that-

Everything is the pink ACT UP triangle.

[laughs]

Yeah.

[laughs] Or pink, and the pink ACT U- UP triangle is kind of a vagina.

Um-

Totally

...

but it's like-

Everything is a vagina in the end

Yeah.

You don't know what's gonna be the final image, you know?

Right.

And this shoot that they did for this album was big.

Like, there's a lot of images that have come out of this shoot-

Yeah

... that are still coming out.

You know, the Vogue Italia-

Ugh, amazing

... cover and that whole shoot was serviced to them from the same sh- shoot

Right

So it's like they...

You know, in the old days, Liz Rosenberg, Madonna's former publicist, would have a binder of photos, and she would walk up and down the halls of Conde Nast going from magazine to magazine being like, "You can have this one.

You can have this one.

You can have this one." Which is why, like, there's so many photos from that, like, famous Herb Ritts shoot-

Right, right

... um, during, like, A Prayer during Blonde Ambition that ended up on the covers of so many different magazines-

Right

... because they were all being...

It was Liz walking through the office being like, "You can have this one."

It's amazing.

"You can have that one.

Interview Magazine's getting that one."

Yeah.

So-

That early on she was like, "We're controlling the image"

Yeah.

And they still, there's something old school about it, and they're still doing it to an extent.

But also younger artists do this too.

You know, there's, like, always the, like, the album cover shot, and then there's, like, the interior photos that are with the liner notes.

Totally.

There's the promo photos.

Yeah.

There's, so...

And you kind of see a same vibe and from the same photographer appearing in different places.

I think that all of that, a lot of that intention is in the edit of the photos, and, like, trying different things and seeing what feels good.

So I don't think that they went into that shot probably being like, "This is the album cover."

Yeah, I don't think so either.

I, or...

And I also kind of feel like if the pink triangle thing is a thing, I think it may, might...

This is just my, my speculation, that it might have been noticed after the fact, and then be like-

Mm

... "That's cool." [laughs]

Yeah.

"We'll leave it."

I think they definitely had a color scheme going on.

Yeah.

They knew the world they were creating.

And I also think that's why you see these different covers that they've put out, because there are probably a few options that she liked, and she would be like, "Can we use that?" But maybe-

Totally

... that's, like, this special edition of the vinyl and this, this-

Totally

...

CD cover.

And I don't know if they do Target exclusives anymore, but remember that era?

They did Grindr exclusive.

Well, there you go.

Yeah.

I think they did a Grindr exclusive and something else.

Um, I'm not, like, me personally, I don't care too much about various elements of how many releases there were.

Um, should we talk about the themes of the album?

Sure.

Did you read the manifesto that they put out?

No. [laughs]

"We must dance, celebrate, and pray with our bodies.

These are things that we've been doing for thousands of years.

They really are spiritual practices.

After all, the dance floor is a ritualistic space.

It's a place where you connect with your wounds, with your fragility.

To rave is an art.

It's about pushing your limits and connecting to a community of like-minded people.

Sound, light, and vibration reshape our perceptions, pulling us into a trance-like state.

The repetition of the bass, we don't just hear it, but we feel it, altering our consciousness and dissolving ego and time."

I did read that, actually.

It's beautiful.

Yeah.

It's-

I have read it

... it's beautiful.

Um, I think more narrowly maybe Madonna said, we talked about reflecting on her life, and then also a couple of things happened.

She said, "My stepmother died.

My brother was ill.

My brother died.

My mother, or my daughter approached me, like, I think for the first time, right? To work together.

You know what I mean? And then I thought, well, it's like the script of my film.

It begins with death and it ends with death, but there's all this life in between." It's pretty good.

She's-

She kind of nailed it.

She's, it's her year of realizing things.

Yeah.

[laughs] It's Kylie Jenner voice.

Mm-hmm.

Um, and then b- before we get into the track by track, I did wanna talk about the film, because-

Okay

... as we're talking about the rollout, I guess, we, the film was a major part of the rollout.

Mm-hmm.

Because prior to this, I Feel So Free came out.

That was first, right?

Yeah.

Which, but it wasn't a single.

It wasn't a single.

It was, like, a teaser.

Which I loved it when I heard it.

So did I.

That one made me really excited 'cause I was like, "This is fucking good."

That was for the Confessions heads, that song.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Because it sounds very similar to Future Lovers on the Confessions Tour.

Yeah.

Yeah, it has that same, like, drug high, [laughs] like, vibey, just, like, incredible-

Donna Summer sample

Totally.

It has, it's like a

aIt doesn't have a Donna-

It does have a-

It has the Lil Louis sample, the I Feel So Free, right? French Kiss, that-

I think it does have...

Or it has, like, an interpolation of Donna Summer or something.

Okay.

It says it's an interpolation of I Feel Love by Donna Summer and French Kiss by Lil Louis.

And it samples Sois Shiro by Arca.

Okay.

Interesting.

Love that.

That's why it sounded beautifully familiar.

Mm-hmm.

Um, yeah, but I, I loved that as a single, and then obviously the second moment, which was the first single, was the Sabrina Carpenter-

Yeah

... song that was debuted, am I correct in saying, at Coachella, right? Bring Your Love.

Yeah.

That was the first time anybody really heard...

Well, not anybody, but the, the general public heard it.

Yes.

Um-

'Cause Coachella's in April.

Yeah, and which was, like, such an interesting way to, like, try to take something in.

'Cause I remember I, I didn't watch it live.

I must have watched a video of it that night or the next day-

Mm-hmm

... or whatever.

Um, and trying to be like, "What do I think of this?" You know? Like, I'm trying to, like, piece it together, and I remember, like, kinda liking it.

Although, I'm not a huge Sabrina Carpenter person.

Mm-hmm.

I don't have any real beef or, like, dislike of her, it's just I-

You're feuding.

[laughs]

I've...

Yeah, me and Sabrina are in a feud.

Um, no, I just, like, don't really listen to her music.

She's, like...

Famously, I'm not super, like, up to date on pop girlies.

[laughs] But definitely Sabrina's not one I've ever, like, put on.

Like, I know the hits.

Like, I know Es-

Mm-hmm

... that's that Me Espresso and Manchild, they play it at the gym, but-

Right

... yeah.

[laughs]

She's an interesting case because I feel like maybe someday you will become familiar with her.

Mm.

Like, we'll s- I think she's gonna have longevity that is like-

Are you the one that said you feel like all her songs outside of her singles are actually really g- like, amazing? Someone was saying this to me.

Probably not me, and the reason is that I don't like country music.

Okay, and she ha-

So-

She does have a super twangy through line in her

... which I love, and I think it's great for her.

Yeah.

And I understand, I understand it all.

I totally get it.

It's just not what I listen to.

Yeah.

But I can appreciate it.

A lot of people asked, so we might as well address it now, a lot of people asked, like, our thoughts on her as the, like, kinda main or first feature.

It feels very savvy.

Yeah.

For sure.

It's, I questioned it when I first heard about it because I wondered if this was something, like, Warners was pushing or I don't-

Right

... you know, why her, I guess.

Seeing them perform at Coachella together, and I was not at Coachella this year, I, I...

What happened was I had tuned in, I did watch it live on YouTube while it was happening 'cause I wanted to see Madonna, and so I ended up taking in, like, a big chunk of her set at Coachella.

Right.

And I started, and because I was watching it within that context, I was like, "She reminds me of Madonna."

100%.

Like, there's something about her that was very, and her set at Coachella and the, like, the set build, the physical set-

Yeah

... and the costumes and the whole art, all the art direction, that was very Hollywood in this tongue in cheek way that reminded me of, like, Madonna during Dick Tracy.

It was, like, a little bit of, like, a caricature.

She has that, I don't wanna say cartoonish, but kind of.

Like, that-

Kind of

... that one streak of Madonna that we've, I think, identified in a lot of our, like, episodes, like that Betty Boop quality that...

But, I mean, Madonna has many flavors, but I think-

Mm-hmm

...

Sabrina is a great living example of that one flavor.

She's v- she is cartoonish, in-

Yeah

...

in, like, a cool way.

Like, she, like, really, like, kind of vamps it up.

She's like a, she's like a-

Yeah

... a pin-up in a gasoline from- station from the '50s come to life, you know?

If you go watch Madonna's Academy Awards performance of Sooner or Later-

Yeah

...

it has a very similar quality to what Sabrina Carpenter's doing now, and it feels like it...

Like, Sabrina Carpenter could star in a remake of Who's That Girl.

Totally.

And do a new-

Well, 'cause it's-

...

Who's That Girl song to go with it, you know?

It's like, like, obviously, like, if you were gonna, you were gonna partner with some young pop star, right? I don't know that anyone else made more sense.

And seeing them side by side, I was like, "They're the same height."

I was saying, totally.

[laughs]

I was, I was like, "Maybe she should play Madonna-

[laughs] I know, right?

...

in this, in this thing." Um, it made sense to me once I, once I saw it.

Yeah.

And, and heard the song.

And the song itself is interesting because then the next s- that, that single came out before the film.

Yes.

Right?

Yeah, April.

And it, it's interesting to me because I was perhaps underwhelmed at the beginning when that song came out.

Me too.

I liked it.

Yeah.

It, then it got stuck in my head, and I was like, "Oh, there's something to this." And a lot of these songs that she put out, the singles, have had that kind of earworm quality.

Totally.

Where you aren't, it doesn't, like, hit you over the head the first time you hear it, and you're not like, "Wow, this is a smash hit." You're kind of wowed by the production, and then it sinks itself into your subconscious.

Yeah.

So by the time the album came out, hearing it in the album context, you're like, "These are sensational songs."

Totally.

It's, like, actually unbelievable.

We'll get into it.

I also feel the single version we heard and the album version are slightly different, right? And I do prefer the album version.

And the film version are, is also different.

Yeah.

So, like, you kind of had all these opportunities to hear it a bit differently.

Um-

And you're getting a lot of really fun, um, insight into Stewart Price by hearing these different versions and hearing the different transitions.

Those, like, the transitions in the film are also-

Yeah

... a bit different than on the album because there's, like, a film component, so there's time.

You know, like, in the film she crashes the car.

Yeah.

And the airbag deploys.

Love it.

And then you see the lipstick mark on the airbag.

Yeah, I loved it.

But then she walks in, you hear the footsteps.

So there's, like, different-

The sound design of the film-

... sound design happening

... is incredible.

Yeah.

Like, there's so much of it, like, I n- like, something small but, like, there's a, the scene, my, my personal favorite part which, with the, like- Dominatrix filmers, um, for lack of a better word.

I don't know what you could call those women

Right, which we need to talk about them.

Yeah.

I'm, the, I'm obsessed with them.

But one's in the bathtub smoking, and you hear her drag the cigarette.

Like, the sound is so clear.

Mm-hmm.

Okay, well, let's talk about the film-

It's good

...

since that's where we're at right now.

Okay.

I think that's the next thing that happened.

I don't think any other music came out, or am I wrong? Did, did Love Sensation come out before Confessions film?

I'm iffy on dates-

Mm

... and timelines, but I know that Love Sensation played at Club Confessions at The Abbey.

That's true, but I don't think-

Videos of that leaked

...

but it was, the video leaked, but I don't think it was officially out.

No, but the fans kind of went crazy for it-

Yeah

... just based on, like, what leaked to the internet-

Right

... from that night.

So it, I, from what my, from what I understood, I've never talked to anyone, I don't know if this is true, or if they were always planning to release it-

[clears throat]

... early.

I felt like they put it out because the fans were like, "Put that fucking song out," you know? And so then-

She also played it at that Time Square concert.

Yeah

It was one of the three songs that she played.

So maybe it was planned.

Anyways, but that, regardless, the film built around the first six songs-

Mm-hmm

... of the album, directed by your close personal good friends-

Yeah [laughs]

...

Torso, David Toro and Solomon Chase.

Correct.

Um, starring Madonna, with appearances by, in order, Arca, Archie Madiquay, Madiquay? Benedict Cumberbatch, [laughs] Sabrina Carpenter, Cole Palmer, Debbie Mazar, Gwendoline Christie, Honey Dijon, Fade, João Pedro, Julia Garner, Kate Moss, Odessa Young, Richard E.

Grant, Shygirl, and Lourdes Leon, amongst others.

I, I missed probably a couple people, but these were the featured players.

Mm-hmm.

And it premiered June 5th at the Beacon Theater in New York City during Tribeca Film Festival.

Yeah.

It premiered for me in my bedroom on my YouTube.

[laughs]

It premiered for me-

[laughs]

...

in a time and place I can't discuss.

[laughs] Right.

If, and you had an NDA.

I just, I mean, I've watched it, like, several times now.

I think it's so good.

It's amazing.

It's amazing.

And it's, there's so much, every time you watch it, new things, like, for me anyways, come out.

Like, the, the meta kind of arc of these, like, filmer dominatrixes-

Mm-hmm

... 'cause they're throughout, you know? Like, it's so genius.

The pacing of it is so perfect.

I love the driving part.

It's funny to me that the way it begins is, like, you see the light beams, like-

[laughs] From the, from the vagina? [laughs]

No, from the camera people.

Oh, yeah

And you kind of think that it's, like, a SWAT team.

Right, right

You know? That they have guns, and that they're, like, busting in, but of course it's ca-, like, that the weapons are the cameras.

That's so cunty.

It's so funny.

It's so cunty, it's so funny.

It's so, but it's also so, like, salient.

It's like, yeah, like, being perceived is a weapon.

[laughs] It's punishing, it's punitive, you know? Like-

Mm-hmm

...

while, like, it's almost like I might be putting way too much into it, but I'm like, I think, like, one of, a, a thing Madonna has had her whole life and maybe has come to terms with in a different sense, and has made art about in the latter half of her career is like, "I always wanted so much attention, and now I got it, and I don't...

Like, it's not what I want." You know? Like, what a double-edged sword that level of attention is.

And it's like we're now in...

We all remember when Britney Spears was inside, like, the crazy tunnel of cameras in the Hold It Against Me video.

Yeah, of course.

Um.

Who could, who could forget?

[laughs]

[laughs]

So we've seen this before, this trope before.

Yeah

But it feels like, of course, as time goes on, with the internet and social media being what it is, like, we're inside the panopticon at all times.

Right

Especially someone like Madonna.

And then now hearing the album and going back and, if you watch the film again, certain things make much more sense than they probably did to begin with.

Totally.

Um, regarding that, you know, because it's like there, she's had many dance records throughout her career that had different kind of messages behind them about, like, finding freedom in the music and, you know, losing yourself and-

Yeah

... on the dance floor, whatever.

But this feels like the most pointed that's like, "I go to the club to be on the dance floor so people, like, stop looking at me."

Yeah

Like, because I'm tired of...

It's, like, almost, like, to get away from, to escape being Madonna.

Right.

And it's, it, I think it functions on two levels, which is what makes it so good.

It's obviously so specific to her, but it's also so applicable broadly in a world where we don't go anywhere, and we don't commune with other people, and we don't engage in physicality to the everything...

Not everything, obviously, but you know what I'm saying.

Like, it, it-

We don't put our phones away

There's so much of a, of a, of a fixation on two-dimensional, flattened, being perceived through your phone.

Whereas being, you know, resplendent and free and physical at a club where you're, like, yeah, maybe you're filming for a second or whatever, but if you're really in it, you're not.

Yeah

You're not even on your phone.

And it's interesting as, like, a fantasy for her, because we saw at Club Confessions that she can't do that still.

No, of course not.

You know? It's like-

Well, not at her own event.

Right.

Certainly not.

I mean, it's like she's surrounded by security.

Yeah

She's behind, like, a kind of protective layer, because she has to be.

Yeah

And, like, you...

And so watching it, watching her in the video, it's like the scene where it goes into Bring Your Love, it's like she's in sort of like a concert, like, club-

Yeah

... dark room with tons of people, and she's, like, in the crowd with them.

And you're kind of like, "Oh, this is, like, what she's fantasizing about."

Right, like a dream situation.

Mm-hmm.

Um, yeah, I loved it.

I mean, I loved, I, my, I think one of my favorite parts was the table dancing

dancingOh, yeah

I loved that.

Like, the stretching and the knee pads, the yoga moves, and like, the, the, the, you know, cir- circular motion of the camera.

Um, obviously the, the dance-

And that was during One Step Away.

Yeah, I think so.

Um, or is it, does it go through two songs in that part? 'Cause like, I, like, vaguely remember hearing-

Good For The Soul is the pussy lasers

Okay.

And then it kind of bleeds into that part, I think.

Mm-hmm.

'Cause I kinda remember some of the lyrics of Good For Your Soul, 'cause I love that song.

Um, obviously the bathroom scene, which was with all the cameos-

Yeah

... is, like, so major.

I w- I was a little, like, when-

It also seems to be the one that's caught on the most

Sure, 'cause it's like, it's, it's the, like, grabbiest.

Yeah.

Also, it has Danceeteria, which is the grabbiest song.

Yeah

Is the easiest one to, like, take away from when you walk away.

Um, I'm, I'm a little mad they didn't use the armpit, uh-

[laughs]

...

this Desperately Seeking Susan moment.

She might have.

I need to go back and rewatch.

Maybe we just didn't catch it.

No, I watched it again.

I'm sure they filmed it.

They have her in front of it.

They did film it, because a, a still of it is, I think, in the-

Oh

... bonus thing they put out, and that was, like, major.

Um, when Lourdes walks in with the mask.

There is something hilarious, though, about how her hair flies up when she does that, like, that she's just doing it to her face.

[laughs] It's, it's great.

It reminds me of in the movie, this is such a weird reference that just popped into my head, you know, in The Faculty?

Mm-hmm.

The movie The Faculty.

Sure, the horror film.

The acclaimed film, The Faculty.

Yeah, of course.

Yeah.

When Piper Laurie, they're, like, in the closet spying on her, and she goes over to the, [laughs] to the water-

I haven't seen it in a long time.

[laughs]

She goes over to the, like, I don't, what do you call it? Like, the drinking-

Fountain?

It's not a fountain.

It's like-

The dispenser?

The jug.

Yeah

The dispenser.

She fills up the cup of water and she just throws it in her face.

[laughs]

And then her hair whips back.

That's how they know she's an alien, 'cause the aliens need water.

Right.

Okay, anyway.

[laughs]

Maybe that was the reference, and we don't know about it.

I doubt it.

[laughs] Anyways, I loved it.

I think it was great.

That's-

Totally

... major.

I mean-

I think that if people haven't wa- rewatched the Confessions film since getting into the album, it's very fun to go back and watch it after the album.

Totally.

Um, and I'll tell you what, Benedict Cumberbatch grew on me.

At first I was a little off-put by his prominent featuring, and now I'm like, "It's cool." [laughs]

It's something about it's very Madonna-

Yeah

... to have him there.

I love Richard E.

Grant being in it.

I'm such a stan.

Me too.

But I was like, "Hell yeah." I hope that was one of your best friends.

[laughs] I hope they hung out every day in London.

I had some foreknowledge of who was going to be in it, but I didn't know everybody who was going to be, so it was, it was surprising seeing some of those people were fun.

Obviously we would be remiss if we didn't mention the hide the cocaine pan directly to Kate Moss moment, which is so wonderful.

Yeah.

Chef's kiss.

Which obviously she was in on, because there's no way she would have allowed it if she wasn't.

Of course

And it's very, it's very cool and funny.

It was choreographed.

The whole thing was choreographed.

Yeah, it's so great.

Um, all right.

This album has been sort of universally, uh, received with high marks.

Yes.

It's gotten great reviews.

Um, the Metacritic score, I think, right now is 83.

Um, everyone loved it.

Is that, I don't look at Metacritic for albums ever.

Yeah.

Is that high? Is that-

I think so.

I mean, I don't, I don't usually either, but I mean, it's quite high.

[laughs]

Yeah.

That means, like, you know.

I didn't see, the only thing I saw under four stars was something called The Arts Desk, which I didn't look into.

But, like, even, I mean, Pitchfork gave it 8.1. That's really high.

[laughs]

But not Best New Music, which is a mistake.

That is a mistake.

Can we have a, can we have a word with you, Pitchfork? One last thing before we get on the tracks, and I wonder if you've heard them, she did reveal in that major interview with Mel Ottenberg, which we should totally shout out because it's...

A, the interview's amazing, but also the visuals are, like, I think some of my favorite that I've seen in years of Madonna.

Like, so artfully styled, so, the sh- the shots are so cool.

It's just, like, amazing to be able to have that gift of something kind of new and outside of, like you said, the-

The album campaign

...

the campaign.

It's really wonderful.

Yeah, I believe it's the only magazine cover shoot she's doing for this album.

So great.

That's for, that's an original shoot for the magazine.

Right.

It's, I mean, she looks so cool, and the hair is amazing.

The looks are amazing.

The, like, setting, that filmic sort of, like, Scorsese film vibe is so great.

Anyways, she said that sh- there's eight other songs that didn't make it onto the album-

Mm-hmm

... including one called What Will Save Me with Arca, or pr- helped produce with Arca.

Um, do you think those are gonna come out?

Yes, because I feel like, unless they're very unfinished-

Right

...

they probably will, because her, but who knows? Might be in 30 years.

[laughs]

Yeah.

[laughs] I mean-

She has, she has a tendency to release all of the old unreleased tracks.

But also, we live in the age of, like, the, the various deluxe editions, and-

Yeah.

We also haven't had any, uh, remixes besides the Peggy Gou one.

Is that right? Am I mistaken?

No, there've been a few.

There's a Honey Dijon one that came out.

Oh, right, right, of course.

There was a Stuart Price one that was a remix that came out also.

The remixes are trickling out.

I'm, I can't, I don't know.

I feel like there's gonna be a remix record.

Record, yeah.

I just get that feeling.

There's gotta be.

There's gotta be.

All right, let's go through the tracks.

We talked about I Feel So Free a little bit, but I mean, the deep house moment that is the song, that's just...

It's, I love, I love that ecstatic sort of religious ethereal soundscape that it starts with.

It's such, like, a wonderful beginning to an album, 'cause you're sort of like [whooshes] pulled into it.

Yeah.

You know?

Mm-hmm.

And then her whispering her statement.
[electronic music plays] Thanks for coming.
Sometimes I like to just hide in the shadows.

Thanks for coming Sometimes I just like to hide in the shadows, [laughs] create a new persona.

So good.

It does have a little bit of Erotica-

Yeah

... of, like, "My name is Dita.

I'll be your mistress tonight."

Totally.

Which, on my episode, I said that I thought Erotica was, like, the prequel to Confessions.

Right.

That, like, if we're gonna be looking at Confessions one and Confessions two, I think that Erotica belongs in that sequence-

Yeah

... somewhere.

I mean, it's interesting.

We're gonna talk about it, 'cause we got a lot of questions of people being like, "Do you think this is actually a sequel to Confessions one?"

Yeah, we will talk about that.

Yeah, 'cause I-

Or should we talk about it now? [laughs]

I know.

I'm interested to hear...

I kinda don't, like w- like, fully musically.

I think, like, maybe spiritually, in the sense that it's, like, how Confessions was a return to, like, pure dance music.

Mm-hmm.

This is a return to pure dance music.

But I th- I, I almost feel like it's more like the Confessions of every dance...

Or, you know, I don't know how to say it.

Like, there's so much, there's so many, so many direct references and indirect references to other albums.

Mm-hmm.

Yeah.

It's funny, because I think that, like, there was a question that was like, "What's your favorite throwback sound on the album-

Yeah

... to Madonna's Confessions?" And I was really struggling with it because I was like, "It's not-"

I wouldn't call them throwback sounds.

Yeah, there aren't.

It's not one to one.

I, I would almost say they were, like, nod- they're, like, nods or, like, updates.

Yeah.

You know? Um.

And, like, I was hearing different ones, like...

Or I, I guess I was just sort of, like, what songs could go together, and I was thinking, like, weirdly Get Together works with Bring Your Love.

Yeah, totally.

Or Love Without Words kind of goes with Jump.

Yeah.

Or, or, um, s- I feel like Sorry and, um, Bizarre have a little, like, in common.

And I thought Sorry and Fragile had something going on.

Sorry, that's what I meant.

Yeah, yeah.

Sorry and Fragile.

No.

Was I...

Did I mean Bizarre?

We'll get there when we talk about Fragile.

But it's, like, essentially, like, I think that Stuart and Madonna knew that they couldn't go backwards.

Yeah.

You know? Like, I think that Confessions two was sort of like it's a spiritual sequel.

That's hard.

It's, like, born of a similar instinct of, like, "I wanna make, like, a dance record."

Right.

"I wanna go back to this well." But I think that they knew that the...

if they, if they evoked Confessions on a dance floor too much, that this album wouldn't stand on its own and be considered its own-

I think that's so true

... work

'Cause a lot of people, I feel like, were like, "Where's the Hung Up?" And I'm like, "There's not gonna be a Hung Up."

No, you can't redo Hung Up.

Yeah.

[laughs] Like, Hung Up is its own th- standalone thing.

So I think that the Confessions two title and the visual references are fun, and I like it as a marketing thing, and it sort of feels largely like a marketing thing, but I, um, it doesn't seem like it's, like, such a statement.

I think maybe it's, like, a tribute to how she felt making Confessions one.

Which, yeah, and which is what she sort of talked about, like, "I wanna go back to that space that we made Confessions one from," like, that sort of, like, free, like...

She had come off of American Life that was so, um, weighted and serious and political, and gone into this other direction.

And if you think about it, Madame X-

Madame X

... you know, is also with Mirwais.

And, like, it, it's, it's, like, the repetition of that sort of one-two makes sense.

But, like-

It also makes sense to do... 'Cause also you get people being like, "Why doesn't she do a sequel to this album or this album-"

Yeah

... "or this album?" But it's like dance music is about repetition.

Totally.

So there's kind of a meta layer there-

It's so true

... of, like, of these albums kind of f- situating together.

But it's like Madonna can't, she's never gonna come and, like, not try and take her listeners to the next level.

No.

And I think she and Stuart knew they had to keep pushing it, and I think that's part of what made the album such a surprise for people-

Yeah

...

when they heard it, how novel it felt.

Because they were, especially with the title, they were expecting so much of Confessions one.

Nostalgia-

Yeah

... or looking back.

Yeah.

And you're not really getting it.

Yeah.

And it's funny, you do get it, but thematically instead of musically, you know? Um, I think I Feel So Free is a wonderful first song.

And, like, like we were talking about, like, hearing it in the context of the album as the kickoff is like, made me like it even more.

Yeah.

And I guess just to reiterate a little bit, like, the Future Lovers, I, um, I Feel Love, Confessions Tour track that this is, like, so similar to.

This is the most, of any track on this album, this is the most similar to a Confessions era song-

Right, right

... and it's that song.

Future Lovers is of course produced by Mirwais on, on, um, that album.

And what's interesting about it is, like, Future Lovers has Madonna saying basically, like, "Forget all your problems, find brilliance in religion," in this, like, Kabbalah futurism-

Mm-hmm [laughs]

... sort of thing.

And I feel like I Feel So Free more narrates her desire to disappear and find safety in numbers on the dance floor-

Yeah

... which kind of feels, like, more reactive to the times now, like, in this, like, kind of, like, apocalypse [laughs] we're living in.

Totally.

It's, it's, like, less hopeful, and it's [laughs] a little more like, "I'm hiding," or, "I'm, like, desperate to feel free like that again." Just, like-

Yeah.

Like, I haven't felt...

I feel so constrained.

Yeah.

Like, I...

Like, this is, like, casting a spell.

Like, I...

This is a manifestation ritual.

Like, I want to feel that free again.

It's kind of what Karen Gans was saying, right?

Mm.

She wanted to hear and see more of that.

Well, as a fucking certified woo woo ass bitch-

[laughs]

I love Good For The Soul.

I love it.

"Everything begins in consciousness," so true.

Bedtime Stories reference, maybe.

Maybe.

Slightly.

Slightly.

Those, there's a bunch of those throughout the album, which makes me very happy.

"Just dance in the rain.

No need to explain." Say no more, fam.

It was-

I'm bought in

...

I went on a little bit of a Reddit dive with-

Okay

...

this one 'cause I wanted to see what the fans were saying, and someone pointed out that they feel that this is referencing Impressive Instant-

Interesting

... which didn't cross my mind.

Which I love

And Impressive Instant is one of my favorite-

Same

...

Madonna songs.

Same.

Um, it's one of my top five.

No. [laughs]

One of my top five too, babe.

One of my top five.

One of my endless-

Endless top five

... one of, one of the magic trick top five-

My 500 top five

... which is m- Mary Poppin's bag of top five songs.

[laughs]

But that's because this song, and if, it, lyrically you can see it-

Yeah

... because she says, "Traveling through space and time, interstellar helix unwind.

Don't forsake or the love will die.

Don't forget your love, all right.

On the spiral light we fly.

We will be one, we will be divine.

All the spirits, they intertwine." And then back on Impressive Instant, it's similar but different.

She says, "Cosmic systems intertwine.

Astral bodies drip like wine.

All of nature ebbs and flows.

Comets shoot across the sky." Like, it's like-

It's-

It's, it's very-

We're, we're mining the same well of-

Yeah

... of, uh, Burning Man- [laughs]

[laughs]

... references, which I love

Of new age pop spiritualism.

Totally.

I mean, this, this one doesn't have singy, singy, singy like a bird on a wingy, wingy-

No

... unfortunately.

Um, but it does have astrology references.

She could've been like, "I like to dancy, dancy, dancy."

Dancey, dancey.

[laughs]

[laughs]

Um, I love, "Moon is in Virgo, the sun in the sky, Venus and Taurus, the planets aligned." I love the little astrology reference.

Yeah.

With, and I didn't even think about what that might mean.

Um-

And I'm sure there is a meaning.

Well, Venus is exalted in Taurus.

It's the best position it can be in.

Um, Taurus is ruled by Venus, so when, so the planets are aligned there.

Yeah.

I love Good For The Soul.

I don't think there's, like, a ton to unpack lyrically there, like we talked about.

I think it is in conversation with some of her Ray Of Light [laughs] and Impressive I- like, some of her preoccupations arou- around her spirituality-

Mm

... and her idea of, like, the cosmic oneness and, you know.

I had a thought here.

Tell me.

Um, not to get too TMZ.

Sure.

But it feels like an acknowledgement of mortality-

Well, yeah

... uh, is happening in this song, and she did have a near-death experience, right, shortly before the Celebration tour-

Yeah

... which was then when she toured the world with Stuart, then they went into making this album.

Feels potentially connected or like she f- she is expressing kind of like a new appreciation-

Right

... for where she is.

I think that's a through line of the whole album, though, because, like, the near-death experience for sure, like, I think there's no way to take stock of your entire life by writing a biopic about yourself and not think about your own mortality and your own legacy and, like, "Okay, w- where is my life going? How much longer do I have?" So I think that colors this whole album, which is very interesting, 'cause I thi- don't think we've heard that before.

Right.

And I just wanna, sonically I have to say that the minute the album came out-

Yeah

...

I was up at a house in the woods.

There was, like, not a party going on, but a gathering.

Mm-hmm.

[laughs]

I-

Of the drug lords

...

I French exited-

Uh-huh.

[laughs]

... with my friend Jacques Lucant-

[laughs]

... into a pitch dark bedroom, put headphones on, and listened to the entire album in the darkness, drinking a glass of wine.

Ugh.

Dream.

So when I've heard this, I had heard the song of course on the Confessions film.

Right.

When I li- was listening to it on headphones, I found the production super crystal clear.

Yeah.

Every element hits with impact.

It's, like, very sweeping and overwhelming-

Totally

... and dazzling.

The strings are really phenomenal.

Um-

I think this is a sleeper song on the album-

Mm-hmm

... where it's not as grabby and showy as some of the other songs.

But when I c- listen over and over, I'm so drawn to this song, for exactly the reasons that you're talking about.

It takes you somewhere.

It takes you somewhere.

Stuart knocked it out of the park with kind of bringing to life what she's kind of trying to communicate melodically and with the lyrics.

Also in, in this song, there's, like, a build, and Stuart is really good at a build.

[laughs]

Especially, like, with this structure of the songs mixing into each other.

Yeah.

It, it-

Continuous mix

... and he kind of takes this freedom of, like, letting it build until it's, like, this trancy techno refrain-

Yeah

... happening, super fucking loud.

It's wonderful.

And I will mention there is a bird reference in Good For The Soul.

She says, " 'Cause up to the sky a thousand birds fly," so the bird is back from, you're right, Impressive Instant.

They're in conversation.

The bird is back.

[laughs]

The, a thousand birds flying in the sky, that's her in the Frozen video.

Frozen video, exactly.

[laughs]

Um, so this goes into One Step Away.

This was one of the ones that when I first heard it, I was like, "Let's fucking go." [laughs]

Completely.

Like, grabs you right away.

One of my top songs.

Her vocal performance on this.

Well, you fucking love Bedtime Stories.

I love Bedtime Stories.

And my first note was it feels like it sprouted off of Bedtime Stories.

Totally.

Or The Untold Chapter.

Yeah, yeah.

Mixes.

Yeah.

It's like, it's one of the most elegant songs on the record.

I love it.

I just, I, I, her, her vocal performance brings me back to, like, every old Madonna song that I love because she sounds, I think this is a song she sounds the most like her classic Madonna vocal self, in my opinion.

It's like it has the sexy aught's, like, midtown Manhattan lounge feel.

[laughs]

[laughs] Buddha Bar-

Yeah

... is open for business.

It's like you have a Rachel haircut, but it's really sleek.

Mm-hmm.

It's, like, a Tom Ford silk satin shirt.

Totally.

It's, like, maybe a choker, but, like, a really thin-

thin-Oh my God

Shade

What is that, what was that restaurant that was like Asian themed that was like very big at this time?

Tao.

It's very Tao.

Not Tao, the other one.

[laughs]

They just re- they just opened it again in LA.

Oh my God.

It's gonna-

Sushi Samba?

Indochine.

Oh, Indochine.

Mm-hmm.

I mean, Indochine is timeless, but also it's very-

But also Sushi Samba.

They did also re-

[laughs]

That's, Sushi Samba also-

It's very Indochine.

It's like this song has Detroit techno influences in it.

Yeah.

The strings, the piano, it's like, you know, and I wrote that it was like it, it was like the wow track, like the standout-

Yeah

... on the Confessions film for a lot of people.

Yeah.

For like a certain kind of Madonna fan who were like, "Oh my God, we're so back."

I love it so much.

[laughs] Um, and then we spoke a little about it, but this, this segue is a really great continuous release moment.

Really powerfully and s- and insanely.

Yeah, into Bring Your Love.

I got something I wanna talk about, talk about.

And when that transition happens, like whatever Stuart and Madonna did with the album mix turned the song into a smash for me.

Yeah, I agree.

I totally agree.

Um, someone mentioned this, and I d- I actually didn't hear it the first time, that they...

Was this only in the film where they put the, uh, the-

The lucky star synth stab?

Lucky star synth.

Yeah.

Uh, yes.

Are we ever gonna get it? Probably not.

I didn't catch it when I listened to the film the first couple of times-

The, the lucky star synth line-

... until someone mentioned it

... to me is like so, if, if I hear it anywhere I'm like-

Right.

[laughs] It's like-

Where is it?

It's like dog whistle.

You're like-

Yeah.

[laughs]

[laughs] It's the Batman call.

You're like, "I'm here."

Yeah.

Um-

It's like that, and like the intro to the X-Files have the same effect on me.

[laughs]

I wonder why, I wonder why they didn't include that version on this album.

It's so major.

I know.

I'm obsessed with it.

Maybe it'll come out in some other thing.

And like when I'm listening to it, I actually hallucinate that it's there.

Sh.

[laughs]

Like I, when I'm listening to it, I, at the gym this morning-

You put it in the place

...

I was like, I'm like, "Is it on there?"

[laughs]

Like I'm like tweaking because of it.

So-

I can't un-hear it.

It w- it's so good.

I didn't hear it the first time 'cause I w- or even the second time until someone pointed it out, and then I was like, "Oh, yeah." Um, this version has additional production by Parisi.

Mm-hmm.

Um, I'm, I'm pointing this out because nine of the tracks I think are just her and Stuart.

Yeah.

But then there's the other tracks that have these additional collaborators.

Um, this song interpolates at one point Good Life by Inner City, which we hear, "Good life, good love." Major.

Really, really major.

Gorge.

Um, a very important song in my life and in the lives of generations of club-goers.

It's, like it still hits like it was yesterday when they put that song on.

Um, I love, I, I talked about this maybe with Karen, or I'm not sure, but, um, I actually, pink pussy hat, sh, love the lyrical conceit of this song.

Like I do-

Okay

...

I do think like, I do think there's something in it that's like bringing back Don't Tell Me.

Mm-hmm.

Bringing, bringing back kind of a through line that started for her when she was like, "Stop fucking telling me what I can and can't do.

Stop telling me how old I am.

St-" you know? Like, and it, it's not so explicit, but it is.

Like, "Don't try to shut me up," that's very Don't Tell Me.

Um, she talked about it in Dark Ballet too, and not to bring up Dark Ballet, which I love.

Um, "Don't try to distract me with numbers," which is like both I think age, but also like-

Industry

... industry.

We live in a, like how many followers do you have, like whatever.

And-

And the irony of her saying that on the Sabrina song-

[laughs]

... which is pro- like of course the label was probably thrilled to make it the first single.

Yeah.

And like-

Oh yeah, I was thinking about like-

They thought it would do numbers, and she's like preempting it by being like, "Don't talk to me about the numbers."

Right, "Don't talk to me about numbers." Um, I mean, Sabrina's on Universal.

Warner could have probably pushed for one of their own, like a dual lead or something.

Yeah.

Um, but yeah, I just, I do love that.

I love like, there is, there's a bit where she says, [sighs] "Who are you doing it for?"

Mm-hmm.

"Ask yourself who you're doing it for." Um, I think this is like a really good central question that like-

Many people should be asking themselves?

Yes.

Yeah.

Exactly.

Not me, but other people.

Me sometimes.

[laughs]

Sometimes I, I like had the craziest dream, which I will not burn airtime boring you with the details of my dream.

Mm.

But it essentially panned out to being like, "Who are you doing it for?" And I was like, "Damn, my dream about my ex-boyfriend being unmasked?"

[laughs]

It's a whole, it's a bit...

We don't have to get into it.

Um, anyways, this song has grown on me-

Girl

... incredibly and-

It reminds me a little bit of how like when Beyonce put out Renaissance, she had Break My Soul.

Mm-hmm.

And I was like, "It's good." I was like, I don't know, you know, threw it on the playlist.

Yeah.

It would come on.

I was like feeling it more and more.

Then when I heard the album, I was like, "Oh, this song is a smash fucking hit."

Right.

Like-

Right.

Like once you were able to hear it in its proper home and context.

Yeah.

It does something to it.

Yeah.

You know? Um-

They sprinkle a little crack in it for me when they put it on the album.

I can't tell if the mix on the album version is different than on the single version.

Paul-

'Cause I'm like, "Am I tripping?"

Paul said it was.

Okay.

I think, I don't wanna put words in his mouth, but I believe he did s- or he, at the very least I think he texted me and was like, "I feel the production is different." So there is something, I'm too stupid to point it out, but I know that me hearing this version and me hearing the other version, I like this version better.

Same.

So.

I love this version, and it's like-

Might be an optical illusion.

But the whole-

Or an aural illusion

... yeah, the whole entire album has a hallucinatory quality to it for me, and I think that's like because Stuart is being so maximalist.

Totally.

In the best way.

And so detail-oriented, like-

Yeah, I'm like I don't know what program he used, but I imagine like the Ableton or whatever had like 900 tracks on it.

Yeah, just like layers.

Yeah.

[laughs]

Yeah.

[laughs] But it's like-

Um-

You hear things, and you're like, "Did I hear that? Are my ears playing tricks on me?"

It's a lot.

"Is it the headphones I'm wearing? Is it my car speakers?" Like- There's just so much detail that continues to fly at you the more you listen to it

His age is like a fine wine, I must say

Just so good.

So with this one, it has this kind of like staccato, like teleporting quality to it, where the synth chords, at least when you're listening to it on the headphones that I have, which are Bose, and if you put it in immersive mode, the-

On this podcast, we love Bose headphones.

No free ads-

Yeah

...

but I have a gorgeous pair of Bose headphones that I love

You know, the synth chords like kind of jump around you.

They're like, "Here, here, here, here, here, here, here." And it's like surround sound-

Yeah

... and you're like, "Ba-da-ba-boo," la-la-la.

[laughs]

And then like the song is just barreling forward, like to this like driving propulsive beat.

It has this like shiny bulletproof like pop adrenaline.

Yeah.

It's pretty massive actually, the song.

It's amazing.

I was like, "Wow, this has not really ever happened to me with a song." Songs have like grown on me with repetition-

Mm-hmm

...

but they've n- it's never like to this extent gone from like me hearing it, being like, "Meh," and then me being like, "I love this song so much." [laughs]

[laughs]

I love it.

I wanna hear it 10 times.

Um-

I was driving down the freeway listening to it, and when it, by the end of the song when it builds and builds and builds, I was like, "How fast am I going? Oh, 92 miles per hour."

[laughs]

I'm like, "I-" [laughs]

You get pulled over, you're like-

It's, it's-

... "Madonna"

... it's gonna cause accidents.

Yeah.

Um, well, and it, it sh- right into Danceteria.

I have to stop every time to not say Danceteria.

Um, this is-

Say it.

Do it, do it your way.

Do it-

How you do it in your culture

... girl, in my culture.

Um, I'm, I'm interested that this song is, there's two songs on this album that are co-written with Andrew Watt and Henry Walter, who goes by Cirkut.

Mm-hmm.

Um, this is one of them.

And Andrew Watt is obviously like kind of famously f- or like as le- as of late, a rock music guy, like has been sort of the, uh, pied piper of breathing life back into sort of like '90s rock bands.

[laughs] Like I think he did Pearl Jam.

I believe he did Red Hot Chili Peppers' last album.

Um, and Cirkut is like a big pop music writer.

Yeah.

I noted that he, I mean, a lot of the songs on the album are writers-

He works with Gaga on the last album

... worked with, yeah, and so did Andrew Watt.

Um, but he also was a writer on Wrecking Ball by Miley, which is one of the fucking best songs of all, our whole lifetimes.

Katy Perry's Dark Horse, which I love that song.

It's my favorite Katy Perry song.

I hate that song.

Go on.

Oh, my God, I love it.

Um-

Sorry

... na-na-na-na-na-na-na.

It's okay.

And Starboy by The Weeknd, which I have no thoughts on 'cause it's like-

Great

... wallpaper music.

[laughs]

Um, [laughs] but-

I love Starboy.

I love Wrecking Ball

It's great.

And Cirkut also is credited as a producer on here.

So someone asked, "Can you please go through the name checks [laughs] on Danceteria?" And I was like, "I've never been born to do anything more in my life.

Let's start."

Well, can we start off saying what Danceteria is?

Yes, of course, please.

So the song starts, and I like how it goes straight into the verse.

Yeah.

It's a little, it's much different than it is in the Confessions film-

Yeah

... because they picked and choo- they chose certain-

Yeah, they, they, they chop it up.

Like I, when I went back to watch the film, I was like, "Wait." I was like, like anticipating how I know the song to be-

Yeah

... and I was like, "Oh." [laughs]

That it just starts with like, "I get off the train 4, 5, 6."

Yeah.

And it's because Danceteria was on West 21st Street-

Right

... and so you would take the 4, 5, 6 to 23rd Street to get there.

Yeah.

Um-

And if you guys didn't listen to part one, we talk about it extensively, but this was like Madonna's, you know, first arena of like where she came to dance, where she met all the people that sort of like became like important in her life, and where she first got her music played for a crowd.

Correct.

And it was, uh, founded by Rudolph Piper and Jim Farrah.

Uh, it's where the club sequence in Desperately Seeking Susan was filmed.

I know, that's right.

Uh, the roof bar was called Wuthering Heights-

Wuthering

... which is so interesting to me because of the weird Wuthering Heights connection-

Yeah.

[laughs]

... to Madonna, the Alek Keshishian-

Totally

... thing that we discussed in our episode.

Um, it was like s- it was like the locus of new wave in New York City-

Yeah

... which I think is really critical, you know?

But also like a, a place where sort of like hip hop culture also met new wave culture, and it was sort of an intersection there, right? Because you'd have like-

Yeah

... people like Fab 5 Freddy, and people we're gonna talk about that are name checked in here also coexisting at this club with like these white new wave kids, you know?

Right.

Like it was like a really cool cultural like exchange there.

But new wave was sort of like the dominant pop music at the time.

Yeah.

And so like it's interesting when you're tracing Madonna's trajectory at, at like being pop, and the fact that like Warhol was there, and things like that.

But it was like also it's definitely where I probably would've been every single night had I been young-

A white- [laughs]

... and in New York back then.

Yeah.

Because like everybody was there, and among the bands that would go there just to hang out and play there was like The Smiths, New Order, Echo & the Bunnymen, B-52s.

Do you know one thing we never talked about in the Madonna episodes that I was really mad about 'cause I didn't realize it until after the fact, that Madonna opened for The Smiths.

We didn't talk about that?

No.

We've talked about that.

Yeah, but it was, it would've been in episode one for some reason, but Johnny Marr brought it up I think-

Uh-huh

... semi-recently, and I was like, "Can you fucking imagine?" Anyway.

But also like Klaus Nomi-

Yeah

... and Soft Cell.

Marc Almond told Vanity Fair that they, that Soft Cell was recording non-stop Erotic Cabaret in New York, and they would go there every single night, and that that album was sort of like written as like a New York album, but it was about Danceteria.

Well, I have a little, I have a little footnote about, um, Marc Almond also-

Well-

...

in my, [laughs] in my notes.

Um-

Oh, well, there, Vanity Fair just like because of this Madonna album-

Yes

... probably did an oral history of Danceteria that came out like-

Which was great

...

in June-

Yeah

... which was great and worth reading.

But it was like- It's crazy to think about because this was, like, it was, like, peak Fiorucci at that time.

Mm-hmm.

And it was, like, you know...

It was, like, the, it was the tail...

It was, like, CBGB's was kind of dead.

Mm-hmm.

I mean, it was, like, the, the heyday peak was over, and there were still people playing there, but it was, like, not a thing, and dance music was kind of, like, this other thing that was going on in all these clubs in New York, and Danceteria.

I did it again.

[laughs]

One of the main ones.

Yeah.

Danceteria.

And someone who's not mentioned in the lyrics but who was a major force of Danceteria was Diane Brill.

Yeah.

There's a couple pe- W- I wanna talk about who wasn't mentioned-

Uh-huh

... and kind of speculate on that-

Okay

... um, when we're done.

So keep-

Okay, okay

... put that in your-

But, like, David Wojnarowicz and Keith Haring were the busboys there.

Yeah.

It's, like, the t- like, two of the most profoundly impactful gay artists of the 20th century-

Totally

... were busboys at Danceteria.

Another person people not mention are the Beastie Boys, who also worked there.

Mm-hmm.

Um...

It was a scene, bitch.

Okay, let's get-

Just imagine it

... let's get started.

"I get off the train, 4, 5, 6.

Walk to the club, don't wait for shit.

Meet this boy named Martin Bogon.

He's my best friend.

He's my boy toy."
I get off the train, 4, 5, 6.
Walk to the club, don't wait for shit.
Meet this boy named Martin Bogon.
He's my best friend.
He's my boy toy.
He's-

[laughs]

[laughs]

Martin Bogon we talked about in episode one, but we'll talk about it again briefly here.

He was a bartender, occasional backup dancer for Madonna.

They...

He was born in England.

He was a transplant.

Um, they met, uh, and they lived together.

She had to move out of her Riverside Drive apartment 'cause Futura, her boyfriend, another person not mentioned in this, uh, song, had graffitied all over the wall of her bedroom.

She really makes these guys mad sometimes.

[laughs] Well, I think he was just, like, doing a piece.

Oh.

He was, like, throwing up a piece, and she was like, "In my apartment."

I thought it was, like, his goodbye gesture.

I don't think so.

Like, lipstick on the mirror.

So sorry.

They didn't-

The guy version

...

they didn't live together.

They lived next door to each other, and he was 19.

Oh.

And they became inseparable, and according to Christopher, he had a huge influence on the way she dressed, and you can see that l- like, when we get into some later Madonna.

Like, she very much has the little hat and the, like, the vest and-

Mm-hmm

...

the little Capri pants with the little shoes.

Um...

Which feels very Buffalo as well, which maybe it was influenced by, maybe even-

And he's from England

...

New Wave.

So.

Yeah.

Um, he also did the artwork for her Burning Up EP, um, and has a brief appearance in the "Material Girl" video.

Um, they went to England together and stayed at Marc Almond's bedsit.

Perfect.

Yeah, so that's a little...

Um, anyways, I think this one was really tou- like, the most touching one to me because they were, like, such best friends, and he was one of her first, I think her first, like, very close friend to contract AIDS in '80, 1986.

Um, and she kind of, like, moved heaven and earth to try to save him and paid for his medical expenses and leased him an apartment, and also, like, in a really amazing way, like, 'cause at this time she's super famous, and the, she's with Sean Penn.

The press are hounding them.

Their, tabloids are running all these, like, ugly stories about how, "Oh, Sean Penn and Madonna have AIDS from their friend who's infected."

Right.

And she would, like, eat out of the same bowl as him and make a huge-

Mm-hmm

... show of being like, "This is not a big deal."

Yeah.

Like, I found it very touching.

Um, and she was there, like, with him when he died, and he was only 23.

Yeah.

Andy Warhol wrote about it in The Warhol Diary, or not-

Yeah

... didn't write about it, but it's mentioned.

Dictated it to his secretary.

[laughs]

Yeah.

[laughs] Uh, dictated it to Pat Hackett in The Warhol Diaries-

Yeah

... that he was there and visited the ho- him in the hospital and, like, saw her doing all of this.

It's really...

So that was the...

Okay, the next part is, "Cut to the front.

There's Howie Montag.

Waves us in.

No entiendes.

I'm not sure you understand this." Howie Montag, doorman and promoter of many iconic New York City nightclubs, including Danceteria and Studio 54.

He also was the creator of a cabaret revue called No Entiendes-

Yeah

... um, which was the first place Madonna ever had an official live performance, October 13th, 1982.

Um, but-

Which is why it's a fun lyric, and she says, "I don't think you understand this."

"I don't think you understand." It's so good.

Not just because it's in Spanish.

[laughs]

Not because a white girl speak a little Español, y'all mind.

Um, Bags Riles and Erica Bell are two people that we should talk about, also not mentioned, her lead dancers.

Um, Howie Montag was also diagnosed with AIDS in June of 1991 or around then, and he organized a suicide party.

Major.

Yeah, and Madonna came via-

So major

... phone from LA.

There's actually an amazing oral history on him from an interview from, like, two years ago if you guys wanna read more about him.

Um, the next one is, "Get-"

It's a bit of an Andrea Feldman vibe-

Yeah

...

if you know who Andrea Feldman is.

Yeah.

Yeah.

She staged her final performance-

Yeah

... jumped out the window on Bond Street.

It's so insane.

[laughs]

Um, but you know what? Good for you.

Listen, it was a wild time back then.

It was a wild time.

I just read a...

This is so-

They did it a little bit different back then

...

this is so off topic, but today I was, like, on my 10 minutes of social media.

Thank you, Brick.

And I, like, of course I'm like, "Why do I come here?" And it was, like, a news story about a pi- uh, like, a student pilot who was-

Oh my God.

I can't

... did you see that?

Yeah, like, I jumped off the wagon.

Okay, anyways, we're not gonna talk about it.

Okay.

We're not gonna talk about it.

[laughs]

Okay, and the next part is-

We live in hell.

Yeah.

"Get on the elevator.

I run into Debbie Mazar." I love that she rhymed Debbie Mazar with elevator.

Debbie Mazar worked the elevator-

I know

... at Danceteria.

Yeah.

That was her job.

"Take us to the third floor.

Walk us to the dance floor.

Then I see Mark Kamins is the DJ.

He's the DJ.

Hide the cocaine.

He played my tape.

Everybody, this is how we start the party." So we ta- Debbie Mazar, you all know who Debbie Mazar is.

She worked the elevator, like you said.

Um, they called each other the Weebo Girls.

Uh-huh.

Which is still, her publishing company is still called Weebo Publishing, Weebo Girl Publishing, like "huevos," girls with balls.

Um, Debbie would do her makeup.

Like, they were fast friends and helped her In her quest to get Marge- Mark Kamins, an influential DJ who also did A&R for Island, to play her tape, and he actually brought...

I think they kind of briefly dated, and she kind of alludes to that in the interview with Mel.

Um, brought the tape to Chris Blackwell at Island, who passed on it.

Well, she said that she...

And yeah, in the interview with Mel, she said that she did coke with him and kissed and made out with him.

Yeah, made out with him, and she was like-

Then he played the tape

... [laughs] What did Mel say? It was like, uh, he's like, "You must have done a bump for the glamour." [laughs] She was like, "Yeah, but it made my throat hurt." She wasn't a partier.

She wasn't a cokehead.

Um-

But she did what she had to do

... she did what she had to do, and it worked.

He got...

He's the one that, that gave the tape to Michael Rosenblatt, the A&R for Sire, which is how she got signed.

Um-

Also, just a note about Howie Montag, he never let Donald Trump into Danceteria.

Spotless record.

Legend.

[laughs] Um-

Gold star.

The next part is, "There's Fab 5 Freddy and Basquiat, Keith Haring, and Kenny Scharf.

Everyone came from Shah Frazi.

Shah Fra-zi to the beat." You love that part.

Shah Fra-

[laughs]

... zi to the beat is the craziest lyric of the year since wh- "He wanna fuck Slater.

Richard, we should link later."

[laughs] Link later.

It's really good.

Shah-

Just, like, the most-

...

Fra-zi to the beat

... weird name drops-

I love it

... done in such a poetic way.

Love it.

Well, Fab 5 Freddy, I think, I would hope you guys all know who he is, but if you don't, born Fred Brathwaite, late 1970s, he was part of the Fabulous Five, which was a graffiti group with Lee Quiñones, who you might know as the star of the film Wild Style.

Fab 5 Freddy also in it.

Um, they kind of were, like, some of the first to shift from street graffiti, like, into, like, the prestigious actual art world.

Um, Freddy was, like, a regular on Glenn O'Brien's show TV Party.

Glenn O'Brien, former editor of Interview, TV Party, iconic.

Um, he is name-checked by Blondie in her rap in Rapture, and he's also [laughs] in that video.

Um, Basquiat.

Do you know who Basquiat is?

[laughs] Me?

Are you familiar with Basquiat?

No, I don't know.

[laughs]

I don't know.

[laughs] I don't know who that is.

Uh, Jean-Michel Basquiat.

I don't like graffiti.

[laughs] I'm not into graffiti art.

Um, obviously, iconic famous painter, um, who dated Madonna in late 1982.

Um, they were together for a while, but she couldn't be with him 'cause he wouldn't stop doing heroin, quote, quote, unquote.

Keith Haring, famous American artist and activist.

Also, the, you said, busboy at Danceteria.

Um, she performed Like a Virgin and Dress You Up before they came out at his first annual Party of Life at Paradise Garage.

Um, and she would wear a lot of his customized clothes.

Of course.

And Kenny Scharf, still alive, Kenny Scharf.

Oh, yeah.

Yeah.

Um, amazing artist.

Um, he was roommates-

Also has fun parties in, like, his own venue in New York-

Yeah

... where he has them.

I don't know if he does anymore, but-

He used to, right? Disco parties.

Pretty recently.

Cosmic Caverns or whatever.

Yeah, yeah.

And he lived with Keith Haring.

Now, very important for me, Shah Frazi.

[laughs]

Iranian excellence.

Tony Shah Frazi, an Iranian-born American art dealer.

Um, he's a fucking icon.

Yeah.

I didn't know this.

Did you-

One of the, the huge legendary art dealer

... did you know that in 1974 he spray painted over Guernica, Picasso's Guernica, in the MoMA and wrote "Kill lies all" in foot-high letters in spray paint on Guernica? [laughs]

[laughs] Wow.

Allu- by the way, an allusion to James Joyce's 1939, uh, Finnegans Wake.

When they grabbed him, he screamed, "Call the curator.

I'm an artist." [laughs]

Wow.

That's what I'm gonna start saying whenever someone questions me on anything.

"I'm an artist."

"Call the curator.

I'm an artist."

[laughs]

Um, he then went home, became the art advisor to the Shah of Iran, helped him correc- collect all this incredible contemporary art, became the director of the Tehran Museum of Contemporary Art, and then came back to America.

Did so much stuff.

Anyways, he had a gallery that showed Kenny Scharf, all these people, so-

Basquiat

...

Shah Fra-zi to the beat.

Um, next part is, "There's Mari Pohl and a guy named Fred.

See these guys spinning on their heads? There's Rock Steady Crew and Crazy Legs.

Puerto Rican boys, they make me go crazy." We knew that.

That line.

It's just... [laughs] Girl.

I'm waiting for the remix that's just that line-

Yeah.

[laughs]

... over and over and over again.

Over and over.

Um, Mari Pohl, do you wanna tell people who Mari Pohl is?

Yeah.

She's a legend.

[laughs]

She's a photographer, fashion designer, jewelry designer, artist, uh, like, occasional film producer, I would... maybe, I think.

She produced Downtown 81 and then also a few documentaries.

She was...

She's largely seen as being responsible for a lot of Madonna's style in the early '80s, like all the bracelets-

Yeah

... all the Like a Virgin era.

Totally.

Um, she worked at Fiorucci.

Yes.

She is now really known for her Polaroid photography because back then she would take Polaroids of everybody.

Yeah.

And she's released, like, several anthologies and books of all of her Polaroids of, like-

So awesome

...

Warhol, Debbie Harry, Debbie Mazar, all the Debbies.

Yeah.

Uh, [laughs] Madonna, Basquiat, Keith Haring, so on and so forth.

So she was, like, major artistic style fixture-

Yeah, and I think had a, like, a lot of-

...

in the scene at the time

... uh-

And close friends with Madonna

... and a lot of influence on her, like, early style with those br- like, she invented those bracelets, I think.

Those r- black rubber bracelets.

The black rubber bracelets, yeah.

Which came to define, like, Hot Topic style in the late '90s.

Little did she know what she wrought.

[laughs]

In, in, [laughs] in my era.

I used to have them.

Yeah, same.

Um, a guy named Fred is still referring to Fab 5 Freddy because, uh, when she met Mari Pohl, Fab 5 Freddy was performing, and he had been like, "Can you find me some girls to dance on the stage with me?" And she, like, had seen Madonna perform and was like, "Come dance on the stage." And the Rock Steady Crew and Crazy Legs, those are b-boys Look, look it up, babe.

I'm not gonna pronounce-

Not Fred Schneider from the B-52s, although the B-52s do get-

Could have been

... do get a mention

But, but I do think she was talking about that.

Um, Crazy Legs was, like, one of the most famous break dancers.

I think he was, like, one of the first break dancers to have, like, a campaign with Fila or something.

And anyways, they were around.

Um, next is "Nile Rodgers and David Byrne, B-52s had money to burn, Lounge Lizards had so much style, Lower East Side, take a walk on the wild side." Nile Rodgers we know.

The-

If you don't know anyone who Yasi just said-

Open a book.

Yeah, we don't need to get into it.

He produced the first Madonna album, though.

He was the co-founder of Chic.

David Byrne, obviously of the Talking Heads, he was around during this time.

"B-52s had money to burn" is a fun one because not only is it a name check of the B-52s, but it's a reference to one of their big songs, well, it wasn't that big, but their 1983 song Legal Tender, which has the lyrics, "We're in the basement learning to print, all of it's hot, 10, 20, 30 million ready to be spent.

We're stacking them against the wall, those gangster presidents." It's talking about, like, counterfeiting money-

Yeah

... and money to burn, which I thought was really cool.

Yeah.

And Lounge Lizards were John Lurie's, like, avant-garde, uh, jazz, fake jazz, no wave band.

It's fucking cool, man.

[laughs]

Yeah.

And I, in Norris Burroughs' book, which we're gonna talk about when we get to the last song, um, he talks about how they used to go see them play all the time.

And John Lurie is, and members of the Lounge Lizards are in Desperately Seeking Susan.

I think what's cool about this is, like, you think of Madonna as the ultimate celebrity-

Yeah

...

the most famous person in the world, certainly the most famous person in the world at one time.

Um, someone who's made it so big, who has so much money and fame and success and whatever, and there's this, like, cliche that people forget where they came from or, like-

Totally

... you, or if you knew them, you're like, "I wonder if they would even remember me," or something like that.

Yeah.

And it's just this moment where it's like she fucking remembers everything.

She remembers everything.

And also, for me, I mean, what I tried to stress so much when I was doing this Madonna series was, like, I know we're not used to this anymore, but, like, I think so many people have, like, divorced Madonna as, like, like you said, just this famous pop star.

And because now pop stars are kind of birthed from the ether, like, they're just like you're a Disney star and then you're a pop star-

Yeah

...

they don't really come from anywhere.

Like, to remember that this person comes from a scene.

Like-

Yeah

... a deep scene of, like, artists and weirdos and fucking cool people, and she was one of them, and it just, her trajectory was different.

But, like, never forget that she comes from the same pool as the fucking Talking Heads and these, and Crazy Legs and fucking the B-52- You know? Like, I think that's really important to remember for the kind of artist she is.

Obviously, d- d- dude, Lurie, we know Walk on the Wild Side.

He has a writing credit on the song.

I love that part of that song.

I love it, too.

I love it.

It's-

So good

...

it could, like, it could've been so bad, but yet it works so well.

And she threads in the theme of being, like, a somebody on this song.

[laughs]

Because it has those lyrics of, like, "Everyone might talk about us, like, we don't care."

Yeah.

Or, "They might be watching us, we don't care." It's like she's of, like, knowing you're kind of hot shit and, but then also being like, "I'm just here to have fun," throwing that aside.

Yeah.

But still mentioned again.

Totally.

Okay, well then it goes in...

This is a strange sequencing, but it goes into Read My Lips featuring Fade.

Um, which I told you I recently learned that not everyone likes.

I like it.

This is the World Cup song.

Is it?

Right? This is the song, yeah, that she's-

That's gonna, that she's gonna do at the halftime show?

Because it was also released as its own single with, like, World Cup artwork.

Right, right, right, right.

Um, co-written by-

I like it

...

Puerto Rican producer Taymy and Fade.

I love Taymy.

Yeah.

If anyone hasn't gotten into Taymy, get into Taymy.

Listen, I always love it because, "Y'all might know who my girls be, well, ask Manuel."

[laughs]

And I just think it's good.

Like, I, for, okay-

It is

... every Madonna album needs to have some Spanish guitar [laughs] and this is the track.

Um, I like, I like the fury and anger in it, you know? Um, do you think the song is about Guy Ritchie?

The thought didn't cross my mind.

Please elaborate.

I mean, you're giving lead actor, you wanna steal the show.

Mm-hmm.

You like to be a bully, you like to always win.

These are director type [laughs] uh, accusations.

That's just what I thought about.

Could be about, I mean, it's a broad enough song that it could be about anybody, but, like, it is, it's a vitriolic song about an ex-lover.

Uh-huh.

You know?

That's really interesting.

I-

And she talks about, like, you know, "You cut me with your lies, but you're just broken.

It knocked me off my feet, but I will survive." And I kind of feel like her divorce from Guy Ritchie was the biggest, like, thing that she sort of had to recover from, you know?

I wonder how much she knew that there would be also a football element to this [laughs] whole thing.

Like, like this is a sports song? [laughs]

Yeah, this is a sports song so he'll notice it or something.

Oh.

It will reach him because he's probably really into the World Cup or whatever.

I don't know.

That's me speculating.

I have no idea.

I have no idea.

It's just th- we'll never know.

It just, like, it cr- I w-

We're improvving here

...

I was trying to think of, like, who's such a big...

Like, 'cause she talks about Sean-

Mm-hmm

...

in another song, which we're gonna get to, but I was like, "And who is the other biggest," you know? But it could, I mean, like, there's, she's had a lot of relationships, so I don't know.

Or it could just be a, you know, a- an imaginary song.

Um, there's a lot of, there's a lot of deeply felt anger in this song that I imagine it's probably about a real person.

[laughs] Um, it goes into Everything.

This is, "I wanna shoot my phone."

[laughs]

This song is I want, the I wanna shoot my phone song.

[laughs]

Right.

Cher, one of the best tweets of all time.

Um, Instagram, babe, I also don't fuck with it.

I mean-

Or I try not to fuck with it, but unfortunately I keep fucking with it.

But I'm, I don't fuck with it.

Relevant, valid, sure.

Is it a little old man screams, goes outside and screams at cloud?

Sure.

Maybe

MaybeWho amongst us, though?

Right.

But what's so strange about this song, and I know Karen said that this is a skip for her, is that I fucking love it.

I like it too.

I don't even know why.

It's like I understand, but I'm also like the production of it just as like-

[clears throat]

... a crazy dance song-

Totally

...

it really hits.

I-

It builds and it hits, and it's like it gets you.

I really love it.

Also, I'm sorry, "Why you always make me feel so bad about myself? Why you always make me wanna be like someone else?" It's...

[laughs] She's right.

She nailed it.

Um-

Feminism.

Feminism.

[laughs]

[laughs]

Um, the next song is Love Sensation.

Yes.

"There's nothing I cannot do.

Nothing I cannot do." I like this song a lot.

I'm obsessed with it.

Yeah.

[laughs] I think it's great.

I didn't write down any notes, but it's like-

Me neither because it's just like...

It's just great

...

the, the kind of three song-

This is like no thoughts, just vibes.

[laughs] Smooth brain.

When I put this on, I'm just like dancing in the kitchen, you know?

Everything into Love Sensation into Love Without Words is definitely like a peak on the album for me.

Yeah.

It's personally.

Yeah, I don't have like a lot intelligent or interesting to say about it.

I just think it's fucking good.

It has like this kind of sweeping sensation to it that reminds me of why I love Get Together on Confessions-

Right

... actually.

Oh.

'Cause it f-

I don't know Get Together

...

it feels like the most like emotional, romantic kind of like burning melodic song on the album.

Like S- Love Sensation might be my favorite song.

We'll get into it 'cause that, I know that was a question that somebody asked.

Yeah, I just feel it.

Can't explain it.

I do fuck with it.

Love Without Words, additional production, Parisi.

Um-

I love that song too.

Me too.

I do think it's like those two songs, like you said, into each other are just like it's the vibe moment.

You're vibing.

It's, there's a synth sequence loop in the song that is so infectious and so addictive right off the bat that I was like, "What is this sample?" I thought it was sampling something, and it's not.

It's not.

It's just like pure crack.

I thought she was saying call it trans, whatever.

[laughs]

[laughs]

Call it trans, call it house.

I was like, "That's cool." It's not, it's trans.

But also her delivery, and this is maybe gonna sound weird, but someone somewhere out there will understand what I'm saying, her spoken word performance in the song reminds, sounds like Arca.

And I was like-

Which is why I don't know

... "Is it Arca?" I was like, "Is Arca on this track?" And it's not, but I'm like, "Is she just been listening to Arca?" She's giving an Arca kind of delivery into it.

It was she's single wide femaling-

[laughs]

...

Arca a little bit-

Well

... on the track.

She's around.

It's fab.

Yeah, it's wonderful.

Um-

Who wouldn't?

There is a nod to Madame X in this song.

How could you? [laughs]

Madame X is a spy in the House of Love.

That's true.

Come to the club, come to my house, come to the club of love.

I'm just saying.

[laughs]

So I know I just said Love Sensation is my favorite track.

This might be my favorite track.

I don't know why.

It just like taps a vein in me.

I like click into place.

I can't get out of it.

Yeah.

[laughs]

It's like I'm in it.

I'm a hostage.

And like when you talk about the sequencing of the album, like this idea, and I don't think it's that literal, but you can interpret that it's sort of like one long night out at the club.

Mm.

Which the Confessions film does a good job of like you're in this kind of like you're being like y- it's like a full throttle kind of omnibus-

Yeah

... mega club experience-

Totally

... where you're being led from like room to room by Madonna 'cause it's all like through her point of view.

And once you get to Love Without Words, this is where it feels like the peak of the club night just before things start to go downhill.

Totally.

You know?

It kind of reminds me of um-

It's a little like over the edge

Oh my God.

What?

It's like you, you do cocaine and like it's fun at first.

Yeah.

Like, you're like, "Everything's so great.

Oh my God.

We're up.

We're having fun," da da da da da.

And then someone starts talking about their ex, and you're like, "Oh, no, things are about to go off the deep end."

You know, it reminds me of Screaming Delica-

[laughs]

...

the Primal Scream album, which is also sequenced that way.

Like it's like-

Yeah

... kinda meant to be like in a night at the club doing ecstasy and then the-

Yeah

...

the end is the come down, you know? And I think this album is very much like that.

Like, it's like it's a build up into the club, and then it starts to go into a come down.

Yeah, and it's a little bit of a horror.

You're like, "Is it getting light outside?"

The fear.

You're like, "Actually, like is this..."

And the-

Yeah, the fear creeps in

... and the fear is mortality, and we're gonna talk about that.

Which I think is beautiful.

For a song to be able to sort of capture that-

Totally

... is very rare.

Yeah.

And it's like it's very stunning.

And it's not just the song.

I think the song is a microcosm of the whole album.

The album is just structured that way.

Yeah.

Okay, the next song is Bizarre.

Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.

This one has a f- this one's featuring Martin Garrix.

It's a s- stronger than just a co-write.

Um, he's 30.

He's a Dutch DJ who was discovered by Tiesto.

I'll be honest with you, I don't know a lot about Martin Garrix.

It's not my world.

Same.

Um, this song has six writers.

We're g- we're getting-

I like what I'm hearing though.

[laughs]

Yeah, we're getting into a chunk of the part that starts to have multiple writers.

So Madonna, Stuart, Martin Garrix, Oscar Ryndborg, Wilhelm Borgesson, [laughs] and Taylor Upsahl.

Um, Taylor Upsahl, I went and listened to some of her music, kinda good, I'm not gonna lie.

Um, this was, this song was born during a songwriting camp in Berlin in 2023, which is why it has all these people on it.

This is the Sean Penn song, and I don't think that's-

This is what I was talking about of like-

Right

... someone starts talking about their ex and you realize-

Totally.

[laughs]

...

the night is over.

Yeah.

That's this song.

"Movie star."

Yeah.

"Deep blue eyes, in Hollywood we're paraphrase" Yeah, and I don't think this one is like we're not speculating because she literally says Shelby Cobra, which is the car she gave him when they got married, so- I think it's pretty obvious who it's about.

Um, I didn't, I felt, I was kinda sh- like side, sideswiped by this song lyrically, 'cause I was like, "Oh, I thought-

It's never really over.

Yeah.

I was like-

You know? There are certain people you never get over

...

but I thought they were like, the whole thing was, the whole narrative was that they were like so cool and chill with each other and they're friends.

Uh-huh.

But this song is like kind of has some animosity.

It's like, "The roll the red carpet out for us, but you won't share it.

I guess you're threatened by me, but you won't admit it." It's, it's maybe not animosity, it's like airing unaired grievances-

There was a time-

... maybe

... recently, air quotes recently-

Yeah

... 'cause I don't remember when it was, it could've been 10 or 12 years ago, but there was a time where they were like seen together again.

They were like hanging out again.

Yeah.

And that was when it was like, oh, they're still friends.

They can be friendly.

They still have admiration for each other.

Right.

We don't know what the fuck happened.

So true.

There could've been like a late night hangout, hookup.

Yeah, maybe.

Like...

We don't know.

All we-

We can't know

... all we know, I do know that there was like a lot-

I would love that, but we can't know.

I know.

[laughs] Sean Penn smoking-

Fan fiction

... 200 cigarettes.

[laughs]

Yeah.

Oh my God, so major.

Just blasting cigs.

Um-

I still think there's time for them, those two.

Sean Penn right now in the Ukraine listening to this song on repeat-

Listening to this podcast-

... chain-smoking cigs.

Yeah

... being like, "What the fuck?"

[laughs] Um, it is, it is, like I mean, it makes a lot of sense.

Like we talked about in episode one and I think in episode two, um, our episode where like he to- he told Playboy that like when him and Madonna got together she wasn't even on tour yet, and he didn't, my understanding of the direction that she was choosing was a misunderstanding.

Basically like she got way more famous than he thought she was going to, and I don't think he really liked that.

Um, 'cause he was private or for whatever reasons.

I mean, I think she sort of is like, "You didn't, you know, you wanted the spotlight for yourself or whatever." Um, anyways, that's just-

Also he, in, in a way maybe that gets taken away from you.

You know? It's like you're only gonna become super famous once.

Like the moment where it happens is only gonna happen once.

Right, and it was t- it was like kind of-

And it was like she couldn't enjoy it-

... dampened.

Right

... because of this thing going on, and that might be a grudge that she's nursing.

Right.

Not to put a grudge in her mouth.

And also, I mean, again, we're, now we're like full fanfic-

Yeah

...

but I'm like-

Totally, like we don't know what we're talking about

... we don't know anything.

But like I'm like what, also what a bummer to have that tainted by the fact that it also ruined her marriage.

You know? Like that-

Yeah

... fame, not just 'cause of him, but just 'cause like I think any marriage would crumble under like they were like nonstop-

Even after she wrote Cherish? [laughs]

... stalked by paparazzi.

You know?

I'm on Broadway and I'm in love.

[laughs]

If the only good thing that came out of it was her like, you know, hysterically writing Cherish to save the marriage, not-

Mm-hmm

... that that's what she did, but then I'm happy with it.

I'm fine with it.

Yeah.

One of the best, top five-

This song

...

Madonna songs.

Um, okay, the next song, this is my favorite.

I'll go on record.

I'm on record, School.

It's my favorite too.

The, you already said three favorites.

[laughs]

[laughs] It's like we'll get into it.

I w- okay, I was already like once, you know, uh, one step away or whatever, I was like, "Let's fucking go," and then School came on and I was like, "Stop.

Stop the fucking presses."

That's like you think the night is over.

Exactly.

There's one last gas.

A surge comes in.

Yeah.

Someone comes by with a little dropper of-

This is like the third-

... 2C-B.

Yeah.

And they're like, "Sorry."

New wind.

One, de-de.

Um, this song actually has seven writers on it, which I thought was really interesting.

Um-

Well, it's a really complex and interesting-

Totally

... song even for how simple and repetitive it is.

Yeah.

There's also a lot of like buried, or not so buried, references in here to various things that popped into my mind.

Like obviously I'd Rather Be Your Lover-

Bedtime Stories

... is Bedtime Stories.

Call back.

Um, but the vocal pitching in it is so anarchic and playful and like weird and druggy that it reminds me of Music.

Totally.

Oh my God, totally, like m- Mere Weather.

Yeah, like the kind of like willingness to be like indecipherable.

Yeah.

And then like I saw some fans posting like I'll teach you how to fuck being...

Which is just a much more kind of esoteric, like moments in her career where she's been like, "I'm the teacher." Like-

That is the l- by the way, for those of you who don't know, that's a, a, a line that is in the sex book.

In the sex book.

And then also is in Erotica except she doesn't say fuck at the end.

She says, "I'll teach you how to unh" in Erotica.

It's also to my ear the most Britney blackout song on the record.

Ooh.

[laughs]

It's like, which is in case people don't know, Blackout by Britney Spears the album is an incredibly important electronic music production landmark-

Mm-hmm

... record.

It's, it's been inseminated by Get Naked I Got A Plan.

[laughs]

Go listen to it.

I swear to God, I can't prove it, but we need a paternity test.

Okay.

[laughs]

There's Get Naked Got A Plan, that I, I c- I can like feel and guarantee that Madonna loves that song.

Yeah.

I also wonder if this was a song that Britney was meant to be on, because it feels-

Oh, interesting

... very Britney to me.

Yeah.

The fans are demanding a Kylie Minogue feature or remix I saw.

We're gonna talk about that, because people have asked us multiple questions about where we think the Kylie, the rumored Kylie remix is gonna come in or the feature.

Um, I don't, I love Kylie, but I would not want it here.

You can hear how her voice would do it, like you could hear her doing it sort of.

Yeah.

It is very her.

But also what I love about this song is like it's, it's not anyone, and it's not Madonna-

Yeah

... and it's not Confessions, and it's not Bedtime Stories, and it's not Music.

This feels like one of the most forward-looking-

I agree

... productions.

Like I think that's why it stuck with me so much.

I was like, "Oh, this is like so new." I mean, there, again, there's sort of like some lyrical nods and stuff, but like I was like, "Damn." And, but also, I know you said it's not Madonna, but I, it somehow is so Madonna to me.

Spiritually it is, and it's-

Like new Madonna-

Yeah

... where I'm like, "Oh, like this is like-" It's, it's a way of embracing sexuality that feels so honest and so, like, true to her, you know?

Yeah.

And also, like, she's talked so much in other lyrics about being the teacher, and now wanting, being like, "Please, please teach me something I don't know," like-

Impress me, goddamnit

... yeah, wanting to be the student.

And like, I don't know, as I can make moves on the dance floor-

The lyrics of where she says

...

I can make love all night

..."Please someone teach me something I don't already know" is also kind of meta in the way that this feels like her being like, "Can we do something fucking new?"

Yeah.

She wants something new.

Yeah.

And this record is very new sounding.

"Once I had a masterpiece that burned in a fire." Me too.

Same.

[laughs]

Lady Gaga.

Wow.

I actually don't think she, I don't think she actually did have a masterpiece that burned in a fire.

I think that's a metaphor.

Um, "Maybe you're Picasso, but you're also a liar." Do you think that's another Guy Ritchie dig? I don't know.

I mean, jeez.

I don't think I, not with, like, absolute love-

Is it a Rocco Ritchie dig?

With love and respect-

No

...

in my heart, I don't think anyone will compare Guy Ritchie's filmography to Picasso.

Um, Lock Stock is good.

Um, anyways, love this song.

Also she says, there's a little, that little line, "I think I need to show you the way.

Blind ambition." Blind ambition, which is what people would say about her-

Mm

... which is where Blind Ambition came from-

Yeah

... which is lots of, school is in, "School is in session." Someone asked if they think there's a Basquiat reference with the masterpiece that burned in a fire, and I'm like, I don't think so.

Um-

'Cause he-

He took back all his paintings when they broke up except for one

And he painted over them

He painted over them.

[laughs]

I feel like this is very, we're getting a lot of her personality in this song because it feels like, and I say this with love, the most snide kind of lyrically.

Yeah.

Like-

"I'm not your mother."

Yeah.

Like-

She's so, it's like she's like, "I'm over it."

Yeah.

Like, you know?

"I can make moves on the dance floor."

"I'm bored."

"I can make love all night.

Tell me you're a man, but you're not so." Many such cases.

Um, it's amazing, and it's wonderful, and it's perfect.

Um, some of the other people on here, uh, LaNita Lashonda Smith, who has sang backup and choir stuff for a bunch of Sia albums, who I believe I read made an intro for a lot of these people to Madonna.

Scott M. Carter, which, who I think has credits on Normani, like the most recent Normani and Cardi B albums.

Um, and Mustafa M. Mbiakop, I'm sorry if I mispronounced that, Matthew Fonten, and then this woman, Jessica Ashley Karpov, who goes by Harlo, who co-wrote, uh, Secret Sh- with Charli-

Oh

... on Vroom Vroom, and has written songs with Kelly Clarkson, Zayn, Celine Dion, and also Britney Spears.

She co-wrote Love Me Down for Glory.

Secret by Charli is a very Madonna-ish song.

That's maybe that's why I would choose-

One, one of her most Madonna-ish songs

... tapped for it.

Um, okay.

The next song is Fragile, drum and bass-esque rave ballad.

[laughs] Um, I think the intro, I know that this song is very obviously and clearly, and she said about Christopher, but I do think in the intro she's, she's referencing a little nod to Prince, another past person.

"People really think that there's a beginning and ending to this thing called life."

Mm-hmm.

I think any time you say, "This thing called life," you are referencing Let's Go Crazy.

Of course.

"Dearly beloved, we are gathered here today to get this thing called life." And obviously they had a relationship, so I think that's just one point, you know.

Something I found interesting is that the intro also goes into the same chord progression of Sorry.

Yeah.

And-

You already know Stuart Price was like...

Yeah.

[laughs]

[laughs] Plotting.

He-

Because she never does apologize on the track, and it feels like it's her being like, "I understand you now and I forgive you"-

Right

...

but not like, "I was wrong."

Oh, so you think the apology is buried in the chord progression by-

A little bit

... referencing Sorry? [laughs]

Yeah.

Wow.

Maybe.

Seven dimensional chess-

I know.

[laughs]

... with your dead brother.

And like, like look, we don't know what happened, but I found that interesting.

Yeah.

That is really-

Maybe it's a figment of my imagination

... no, but that's really interesting.

Um, but what makes this album so brilliant is that it allows for us to [laughs] kind of project these things, and, you know, frequently.

Yeah.

And also, I mean, again, this is an autobiographical album more than almost any of her other ones, and that's, it's rich for us to look into that, especially people like us who have just spent the last three months of our life going through her autobiography.

Yeah.

So if that was seven dimensional chess-

[laughs]

...

I'm gonna move it into eight dimensional chess now because I was listening to Sorry after I f- I was like, "Why does this remind me of Sorry?" And I realized it's the same chord progression.

Sorry was not a song about apologizing either.

It was about not wanting to hear an apology.

Yeah.

It was like...

And I, then I had the thought, could Sorry have been about Christopher?

Hmm.

And maybe we didn't know it or realize it, and I don't think she's ever said that it ha- that it was, but if you kind of time back when they started their rift-

Right

...

it was during Confessions or before Confessions because I know he had issues with Guy Ritchie.

Totally.

There was like, she was no longer working with him on the tour stuff.

She kn-

Or-

She knew, well, the book didn't come out until 2008.

Yeah.

So I don't think she knew about it yet.

But I think it was, I think it was-

But there was other-

But the book came out because of this stuff-

Right

... that had happened, which would time to Confessions.

Yeah.

So I just wondered if she was saying like, "I don't wanna hear I'm sorry from him."

Yeah.

And that's why it's in this track.

And we presumed it was Guy Ritchie when we were talking about it.

And now I'm a conspiracy theorist.

[laughs] Now you're...

Um, well, regardless, this song is explicitly about him.

Um, we talked a lot about his book on the other episodes.

If you guys haven't read it, you should read it.

Um, she told Graham Norton that she wrote this song, like, right after she spoke to him on the phone, which was, like, right bef- just before he died.

They, they reconciled before he died, thank God.

Mm-hmm

Mm-hmmAnd she said writing it was like an exorcism.

This song's the one that I started crying on my first listen.

It just, like, hit...

I mean, I guess I've been so immersed in the autobiography-

Yeah

... of this woman and her story.

And a lot of the other parts got, made me emotional, too.

But, like, this song and hearing, like, "We shared a name, a home.

We shared a fragile bond, now you're gone.

We laughed, we cried, we held each other's hands.

We had each other's eyes and we belonged," that line ruined me.

I was like, "They did have it.

They had, did have the same eyes."

Yeah.

"And they did belong together." And then, "I see inside your soul and I feel whole." It's just, it's r- I do...

Someone pointed out that they think this is, like, the most emotionally vulnerable, like, explicitly she's been lyrically, and I kinda think it's true.

I mean, sh-

No

... maybe, like, O Father a little bit, and there was, there's, like, some other bits of, Like A Prayer that she gets pretty-

Promise to Try

...

Promise to Try, yeah.

But yeah, it's been a long time.

Yeah.

[laughs]

For sure.

It's been a long time.

Also, like, people were saying this is the most, like, vulnerable she's ever been in terms of, like, talking about her family life and her grief, which also isn't true to me-

No, she's talked almost-

... because-

... every single album she's spoken of, or s- done a song about her grief about her mother

I mean, I think that she, like, has done it in ways that are very funny.

Yeah

Or, like, where she's kind of...

You know when s- l- like, you'll take something serious and you'll kind of make a joke? Not that she was making a joke out of it, but you'll be l- s- say it in a lighthearted way-

Yeah

... 'cause it's too much to deal with.

Yeah.

Uh, I wasn't on the American Life episode, but Mother and Father is such a funny song-

Yeah

... to me 'cause she has that whole thing of sh- you know, the poem she basically does where she's like, "My mother died when I was five."

Yeah.

"All I did was sit and cry."

[laughs]

Like, that whole thing.

She gets into all...

She's quite specific on that song.

Yeah.

She will be very personal at times throughout her career.

It's true.

Yeah.

I, I u- I do think Like A Prayer is, like, maybe the most... 'Cause she also has the song about, um, "My luck is running out of time."

Oh, yeah

"You're no longer in love with me anymore"

Love that song

That also people...

That was also about Sean Penn, and she said it was.

Mm-hmm.

Um, can't rem- why can I not remember the name of that song?

Me neither, which is so embarrassing.

'Til The Afternoon Apart

Okay.

Yeah.

[laughs]

Um, [laughs] my God.

Um, okay.

The next song, i- anyways, I love, I, I love Fragile.

I agree with Mel.

I think it's one of, one of the highlights of the album.

Um-

I went to the trouble of answering some of these questions that you put in here

Oh, we are going to...

Oh, wait.

Under f- under Fragile

Under Fragile

Okay, yeah.

Oh, yeah.

We should, we should t- talk...

The only one I kind of left here was, um, what do you make about the nervous breakdown line? These are, these two questions are basically the same.

What do you make of the nervous breakdown line in Fragile, and would Christopher have liked Fragile? Was it fair to reveal his breakdown?

Okay, so we don't know what happened.

I do have, like, a little inside tea that it did happen.

Okay.

Um, it's not tea, but, like, I know someone that was meant to interview him, and at that time he was unable to be, do the interview 'cause he was hospitalized, and I'm pretty sure it was for this.

Nervous breakdown actually?

I think so.

Again, I'm, you know, I'm sort of-

Listen, it happens

It totally-

It happens to the best of us

It totally happens.

Mine's coming soon.

Um-

Um, was-

I do, I do think that she's being sincere on the song, and she's trying to convey empathy to him.

Yeah.

Does nervous breakdown happen to rhyme? Yes.

[laughs] When in doubt.

Is it an, is it an exaggeration? Who knows? Is it a little shady? Absolutely.

Yeah, and, but also, like, I'm sorry, like, he wrote a whole book putting her shit on Front Street.

Yeah.

I think it's okay for her to, like-

And, like, does that shade portray their-

He's also not even, he's not alive anymore.

Right

You know? Like, it's-

Convenient

And she's not-

No, I'm just kidding.

[laughs]

She could've been like, "He was a drug addict."

Right

Which is what a lot of people said and, you know, sh- that would've been, that would've been fucked up.

But also for-

Like, I think if she had been like, "You were addicted to drugs"

For her to, like, poke at that, which I'm not even saying is what she's doing-

Yeah

... 'cause I, again, I do think, at, at least in the delivery of the song, it's, it feels very empathetic the way she's saying it.

Yeah

But nervous breakdown is kind of a barbed thing to say.

Yeah.

I mean, she's forgiving him-

But does that pay tribute to the relationship in its own way? Like, yes.

Totally

It's like they weren't like this.

Yeah

You know what I mean? So, like, it's almost like if she didn't take a little potshot, would it be authentic?

I also think, I do think he would've loved it.

Well, I also wonder, like, would they have reconnected if he wasn't dying?

That's a good question.

So you kind of can't even, would the song-

Right

...

even exist? Like, I'm not sure.

And, like, but I do think she wants closure in that relationship-

Totally

... and I don't really feel like she's gonna get it-

Yeah

... completely.

'Cause you never do.

You never do.

It's not real.

It's a...

Um, okay.

The next song is My Sins Are My Savior featuring Stromae.

Am I saying that right?

Oh, one more thing.

Yeah.

I do wanna say that I think for Madonna to explicitly devote a song to Christopher on this album is in and of itself, like, an enormous gesture from her.

Totally.

She doesn't do that for a lot of people.

Yeah

And there have been others who have also passed away that she doesn't, including her other brother, Anthony.

Right.

Well, she wasn't as close-

Who she wasn't close with

Yeah

But-

I mean, there are a couple.

There's the, there's the Martin Burgoyne song that's, uh, kind of about him but also about her other friends that-

She's very specific about-

... passed away.

Yeah

...

the people who she would do this for, so I think that's meaningful.

I mean, he clearly was one of the more major relationships in her life in, like, creatively and fam- familially.

Um, okay.

Those beautiful houses.

What a...

He had such a touch.

Um, and also we, we talked about it on episodes, so I don't wanna go into it, but, like, he really had such a hand in her creative direction on the ear- those early tours and, like, was so incredible at it.

Um-

Um-And there's a lyric on the song where she's like...

Sorry, we're going forever.

Yeah.

But there's a lyric on the song where she's like, "You couldn't be yourself" or, "You can't be yourself now." And it almost made me wonder if she's meaning about how like, about him being gay.

Well, he wasn't, he sh- he wasn't in the closet, but I remember there was like a huge thing 'cause she revealed to the press that he was gay, and he was really upset about it.

Yes.

Mm-hmm.

But also like would his career have gotten to where it should have without her giving him that leg up essentially?

Yeah.

And like him be...

You know, and, and like maybe he resents her for it, but I don't think that's her fault either.

It's like she did ev- she did what she should have done.

Yeah.

I think they were...

I mean, I think what's true is that they were like inextricably linked.

Like-

Yeah

... she benefited greatly from, I think, her- his creative input, and he could kind of only do that with her-

Mm-hmm

... because that was his sister, and he knew her the best.

Otherwise, he would've done it for someone else eventually, and he didn't.

Yeah.

You know? Um, it's sad, and it's beautiful, and I love it.

I also think it's not my favorite song on the record.

I'm just gonna put that out there.

That's okay.

I thought it was inter- Mel said it wasn't her favorite-

It can't all be your favorite song

... right.

[laughs]

And this one, to me, I just find the melody a little repetitive.

Yeah.

And it feels a little inert.

Like, it doesn't build to anything.

It kinda just repeats.

And I was sort of like-

I think it's a nice breather.

Yeah.

Like, in the pacing of the album, this is like you, you had to sit down for a second.

But I do wanna say-

Mm

...

I love the breakbeat techno beat of the song.

Yeah.

Uh, the guitar is cool and interesting.

It's like a very Madonna touch.

It feels a little Ray of Light to me, a little bit of Music.

Yeah.

A little Club 69, if you will.

So I get it.

It's just not my favorite.

All right.

Okay, moving on.

You're talking still about Fragile.

Yeah.

Okay.

[laughs] Now we're talking about track 13.

Got it.

My Sins Are My Savior, Stromae.

Featuring Stromae.

Not pronouncing that right.

Okay.

So do you remember Justify My Love?

No.

I have not heard that song.

Um, she got pregnant.

[laughs] This-

'Cause she was a hoe.

This is what I wrote.

This is her son.

[laughs]

I was like, "This is the very Justify My Love vibe." Also, a lot of Erotica vibes.

Um, also, I'm gonna throw something weird out there, but I think you'll get it.

I was really in, in college, was really into, like, French neo-soul trip-hoppy kinda stuff, like Le Nubian.

[laughs]

I can tell.

[laughs] It's a really-

We can all tell

... what a, what a college thing to be into.

Yeah.

And also, like, Thievery Corporation, who are not French, but-

It was also, like, that time

...

it was that time, but I feel that vibe through this song.

Yeah.

And I, I think it's the French obviously, but-

It's percussive.

It's, like, French.

Totally.

It's, like, sort of funky.

And I fucking love it.

The-

I love this song.

[laughs]

It flips my army of lovers, my army of lovers w- and it makes that sound.

I'm obsessed with that sound.

I don't know what that sound is.

[laughs]

[laughs]

I'm gonna need Stuart Price to, like-

Can you tell us?

It's like a percussive synth piano through some type of patch or preset that just does this, like...

It's somehow aquatic to me.

It's somehow, like, a sex scene on a beach in a Kathryn Bigelow movie in 1991 feeling to me.

[laughs]

It's a back lit, like-

Totally specific

...

Tony Scott-

[laughs]

... film scene to me.

It's like...

I'm probably using the wrong terminology.

It's this very percussive synth pad, like choog, choog, choog sound.

Yeah.

It kills me.

It's like a dramatic scene in 90210.

Yeah.

[laughs]

Do you know what I'm saying?

Totally.

It's like... [laughs]

[laughs]

It's so atmospheric.

Yeah.

And it makes the song so expensive [laughs] and so major to me-

So wonderful

... that I'm like, "I actually...

This is my [laughs] favorite song."

It's your favorite song now?

My other favorite song.

It's really good.

I feel like it fits...

Well, I love it.

I love it, love it, love it.

I think it fits really well in the sequencing 'cause, like you said, you know, now we're on the down swing, right?

Mm-hmm.

Fragile is absolutely obviously a down swing, and this is also part of the, like-

This is like you're coming down, and so you need to smoke weed, and you need to, like-

And you're, and, like, you know, thematically, you're kind of thinking, like, she's thinking about looking for love in unfamiliar places.

Um-

You're fucking a stranger you just met at the club-

[laughs]

... that you were at for the first part of this album, and now you're, like, back at their place, and you're like, "Who is this? Whatever."

[laughs]

Like, this, this is, like, why I am who I am, baby.

It's interesting.

I was thinking more that-

My Sins Are My Savior

... she was thinking, like...

This is, like, she's thinking about all the people that judged her, and they tried to take her down, and she's, like, kind of reflecting on, like, how she, like, you know, those sins that they tried to...

Like, that's-

But it's about sex.

It's, like, sexuality.

What?

It's, like, for being risque-

Right

... for being provocative.

Talking about the Erotica thing, I think it's really-

Yeah

... hearkening back to that, that, like, time that, like, Erotica and Sex Book came out, and she was, like, vilified, and it really emotionally affected her, you know? Um, but it's a great song.

The next song is Betrayal.

Um, it's co-written with Mirwais, additional production by Parisi.

I'm gonna tell you something, and you can laugh at me, but I like to be honest.

At first, I thought this was sampling the Succession theme song.

[laughs]

What? Wait, can we hear it for a second?

Yeah.

[upbeat music] You know what I-

It's much more sultry than the Succession

I just said, dun, dun, dun, dun.

Yeah.

I w- that...

Sorry.

Okay? I'm sorry I'm fucking HBO-pilled.

Um, but anyways, that's not-

Okay

...

the Succession theme song

...

My Sins Are My Savior into Betrayal-

Yeah

... to me feels like, I don't know how to put it except to say, like, a major Madonna moment.

Like, I just, it feels like you look up Madonna moment in the dictionary-

[laughs]

... and that sound plays, whatever it is.

'Cause it, then it feels like we're fully back in Erotica- The horns

Totally

It's reminding me of Bad Girl a little bit

Yeah

Like, fans are speculating that this was held over from Madame X, which I am not sure is true, but maybe on some level, uh, just because Mirwais is listed as a co-writer on it.

I felt like this song is a really good example, and there's many throughout this album, how incredible it is that her voice sounds the same-

Mm

... like, that it did in the '90s.

Yeah

Like, this song could have been recorded in the '90s.

You- someone could tell me that, and I would believe it

I mean, that's how I felt with One Step Away, you know? Like, I really feel like the, the voice is just, like, voicing.

It's like w- that's how I remember Madonna singing

Mm-hmm

Yeah

Which is not nothing, 'cause a lot of people, their voices go-

No, totally

... or they change, or they-

And I think it's a one specific style of her singing-

Uh-huh

... it's not all, everything, but I, it's so great

It still sounds, like, crystal clear, like how it did a little bit

I do, I find this song kind of interesting.

I love it sonically.

I do find the lyrical conceit so weird, where I'm like... and weird is not the right word.

I was just like, oh, like, also a whole song for Joan Ciccone, her stepmother, who obviously we know she had a fraught relationship with.

Um, but I do think it's an interesting pivot, where it's like almost every other Madonna album has a song about her mother's death-

Mm-hmm

... and this one is sort of, like, sideways about her mother's death by, like, being about how she never really gelled with her stepmother

Poor Joan.

[laughs]

Listen, maybe she deserves it.

Maybe Joan had it coming

If you ask Madonna.

[laughs]

I wonder what the betrayal is

I don't know.

Did she also write a book about Madonna?

No, I don't think so

Um-

This one, I think w- we'll just have to speculate and wonder

Someone, one of our listener questions was like, "Do you think Betrayal is about the media and her fans?" And I was like, "I didn't get that at all"

She says, "I used to hate you, I don't hate you.

We're together forever"

Yeah.

Although, I, now that, that person is kind of spitting, 'cause I'm like, "You'll never-"

And then blocked forever till the end, I don't think she means literally blocked, like social media blocked

"You'll never take my mother's place" is actually, if you interpret it as, like, how she said early on that because her mother died she wanted the love of the world-

Oof

... you could almo- I mean, I don't know if this is at all what she was, uh-

It's the royal Joan

Yeah.

[laughs] The royal Joan

[laughs]

And I thought, I thought that was interesting.

Um-

Mother Earth

She's talked-

Mother Joan Earth

She's definitely talked at length about her, you know, not awesome relationship with her stepmother, at least when she was a child.

Um, okay-

But I think what's cool about Joan, why am I defending Joan? I know nothing

You loved Joan Ciccone

I know nothing.

[laughs]

I just think it's nice, I suppose, that her, that Joan and Madonna's father's relationship was, like, very genuine and sincere, and it wasn't like, "Oh, your daughter's rich and famous." 'Cause Joan didn't really, I, from what I understand, I feel like Joan didn't really care that much about Madonna and her career and all of that

She, they got married when she was, like, nine.

She'd been, she'd been-

Right

... well before she was famous.

[laughs]

But that she was, like, sort of unimpressed-

Yeah

... on some level, or was, like, pretty much only interested in, like, their life.

And I'm like-

They had-

... "That's fucking cool." [laughs]

They also had children.

They had-

Yeah

... a couple of her siblings, right, are.

Um, I t- I do think it's kind of very cool that this song about her fraught relationship with her stepmother and also the absence of her own mother by dir- you know, goes into the song with her own daughter and about that complicated relationship.

It's, like, a kind of a genius sequencing moment.

I love it

It works.

It works

I love, I love this song.

The test featuring Lola Leon

I love the song too

It's trip hoppy

There's, like, a naivete to the song construction and production to me, like, to the, to the melodic writing.

It's, like, very sweet-

Yeah

... and kind of, like-

Tender

Yeah, it feels like they didn't write lyrics for the song, they wrote the song around the lyrics-

Yeah, yeah

... you know? Um, it feels a little bit like a sequel to Promise to Try to me in a funny way

Interesting

It made me think about, like, this conceit that people can fix their issues with their parents through their relationships with their own children-

Right

... which-

Which is a big, a big, uh, idea

It's a big idea that everyone, that g- gets a lot of air time that I think is bullshit-

Well-

[laughs] Because-

At the very least you are-

'Cause you ne- it never ends up happening

You are going to, you are going to cause a litany of new problems-

Yeah

... for your child in a new and inventive ways.

[laughs] You know?

And, like, you are not your parents, your child is not your parents-

Yeah

... it's a different relationship, it's a different person

Right

And I think that someone like Lola is, like, a perfect example of, like, I can't speculate on what she expected Lola to be like, but no, your kids never turn out exactly how you think they're going to.

They surprise you-

Yeah

...

in ways that are, like, good

Right

Like-

I think it's, I think it's almost more that, like, you're able to empathize with your parent once you are a parent because you don't-

Mm-hmm

... you didn't realize maybe how difficult-

Yeah

... or what that relationship was actually like until you take their place

But in Madonna's case, she didn't have a mother

Have a mother, yeah

So it's also almost, like, a new frontier-

Yeah

... and then you add in what they're talking about in the song, which is, like, the issue of, like, having a famous parent-

Which is-

... and what it does to the kid

...

so incredible.

Like, like, I can't even think of a time I've listened to something dealing with that sort of such, like, direct subject matter that everyone would think about.

Like, the first time you heard, like, "Oh, Lola Leon is gonna be on a Madonna song," I wouldn't have e- expected they're gonna, like, call out the elephant in the room, you know?

know?I know, and I'm so impressed-

Which is-

... and happy that they did

... totally.

It's so cool, and it makes it such an honest and impactful song.

And also-

If this was Rebel Heart, it wouldn't have gone down this way.

It would've just been, like, a ARCA-produced, like, dance track.

I do like some of the Rebel Heart country songs, and I think that they were, they're unfairly maligned.

Okay, but you, but, like-

[laughs]

... that's also, like, me underestimating Madonna-

Yeah

... by saying that, and, like, underestimating the fact that of course if Lola was gonna do a song with Madonna, that it would be, like, this deep and personal-

Which-

... and profound to them

... as she told Mel, she was, Lola, she was like, "I never pushed Lola to do anything, like, with me," right? And then Lola came to me and said, "I wanna do something with you," and it was like such a big moment for her.

Like, how beautiful, you know?

Right, and it's the, the, it's kind of an amazing example of how, like, you have to let your kids go do their thing-

Right

... and eventually they will come back to you.

They'll come back to you.

You can't force the point.

That TikTok conversation was really beautiful between the two of them that, and I think Lola talked about, like, how she, like, never wanted to, you know, ride her coattails, which is a, I think a lyric in here.

Well, I think that, like, you can hear, there's, we live in a culture of so many celebrities and so many nepos-

Yeah

... and so many, like, celebrity offspring, and they all are like, "I didn't wanna live in my parents' shadow," da, da, da.

Right.

But I feel like-

You hear it, and you kind of think it's, like, a cliche

... for the most part they almost, like, fully ignore it, which I think why I was so struck by this, like, they, they don't even, they're like, "If I look at it, if I, like, mention it-

Mm-hmm

... people will jump down my throat.

Like, if I just pretend I don't have a famous parent and never bring it up, maybe no one will be mad at me about it." And I thought this was so cool to, like, again, like I said, take it on head-on.

Yeah.

And obviously I'm sure everyone's been thinking, my whole life I've been thinking, like, what is it like to have Madonna as your mother? Like...

Well, and if you know Lola, which, who I do know, but also, like, Madonna fans probably know this too, there was something really funny that happened because she'd always had a private Instagram.

Right.

And then she created a public Instagram because she had done something that required her to post online.

So she was like, [laughs] it was sort of like final start at Instagram-

Yeah

...

so I can, like, f- fulfill this brand deal or whatever it was.

And, like, of course day one all the Madonna fans-

[laughs] Right

... followed her and were, like, leaving all these c- like, positive, loving comments.

And she was like, "I don't know who the fuck you are."

[laughs]

Like, "Get out of here." Like, she was, like, talking shit to them.

So funny.

Anyway, sorry, all that is to say that, like, she genuinely is such an independent-

Yeah

... person, and she never, she's never, as, as far as I'm aware or anyone has ever told me, she's never been, like, riding her mother's coattails at all.

No.

That's, like, disgusting to her.

And so-

And I think it's so cool the, the music that she has made is great, by the way, and is, like, so different and in its own lane.

And, like, she does, clearly not use or lean on anything that she could use or lean on.

She's very much her own person.

Yeah.

And so if you know that, I think that makes this even more profound and moving.

So right.

I was so moved by it-

Yeah

...

when I listened to it.

I was too.

I really loved it.

Okay, the last song, "Mage," LES Girl.

It destroys me.

Co-written with Andrew Watt and Circuit, also credited as producers.

We love an acoustic guitar ballady ending.

Here's a fun fact: the chord progression is a nod to Ray of Light.

Both songs are in B major, and both have the f- three most important chords-

School is in session

... built off the first, fourth, and fifth scale degrees.

As you know, I'm doing theater, what I'm saying is I don't know what I'm talking about.

[laughs]

But it does match up.

Mm-hmm.

And they're all B major, E major, and F major.

The exact chord progressions are a bit different, but they, they take from the same well.

That's crazy.

I didn't even think-

Yeah

... about Ray of Light when I heard this.

Um, I did a little bit because of the guitar usage on Ray of Light.

This is hat tip to Shaad D'Souza.

He mentioned it in his Pitchfork, uh, review, which is wonderful, and then I decided to go do some, like, digging to be like, "Is the port, chord progression the same?" And then I found an insane website that tells you the chord progressions of every song.

And it, the chord, actual chord progression, LES Girl, is a bit more complicated, but the, what I just said is true.

They're both in B major, and they both are built off of these, like, same major chords.

Anyways.

It's deceptively simple.

Yes, but it's n- not actually that simple.

Yeah.

And simple songs are often the hardest to write, and to land like this, to me it's just, like, so pure, it's so punk.

It's like-

Yeah, our friend-

... it's personal

... our friend Cody Critchalto, did I say his last name right?

Critchlow.

Total- Cody Critchlow.

[laughs]

Um, sorry, Cody.

I can't pronounce anything.

Um-

It's the Celsius.

It's the Celsius.

I'm cracked out.

[laughs]

He called it her Lou Reed song, which I thought was, like, really good.

Oh, my God.

Yeah.

I said that too.

I said it reminds me of I'll Be Your Mirror.

Yeah.

Nico.

But yeah, um, I, I love it.

It's funny, this is also a polarizing song.

Some people really hate it.

Like, I think the New York Times called it treacly.

I was like, "How fucking dare you?"

Unbelievable.

Way to fucking miss the whole thing.

Um, if you're, if you're a real head you would know.

I think it's one of the most surprising and profound songs that she's ever written.

Totally.

It's also, given what we've been talking about this whole time, which is that, like, the last part of this album really shifts from, like, love, light, hope, into, like, sort of, like, reflecting on the fact that you're gonna die one day [laughs] and, like, what has life meant and what have you lost, so much about loss, this song is such an incredible cap to that.

Like, it's about what we've lost, you know?

Mm-hmm.

Like, and I think the very end, doesn't the very end have, um...

It's a love letter to herself, too-

Yeah

... at the same time, because through all this looking back she, I think she's very proud of the person that she was, and she admires who she was and how she went about things

thingsEverything fades away.

That's the end.

Yeah

But she keeps saying that.

It's like, yeah, all the loss.

Um, obviously what everyone wants to know, and I'm gonna go ahead and give you the fucking scientific breakdown, I'm gonna make a court case.

It's already been out there who this is about, but I'm gonna go ahead and prove it with 18 nails in the coffin.

Okay.

Not Dan Gilroy.

Not Dan Gilroy.

Not Michael Jira.

Not Michael Jira.

Although, I mean, we can, we can speculate a little bit about whether, like, this person is the cipher for all of those Lower East Side boys or whate- you know? But ...

Not Stephen Bray.

Not Stephen Bray.

He played guitar on St. Mark's Place.

He had a Marlon Brando face, painted nails the same shade as his boots, bleach blonde, dirty roots.

I had one more, which was-

What?

Nick Kamen, but she never dated Nick Kamen.

But Nick Kamen was drop dead beautiful and did h- have that whole vibe, and she did make, write songs with him and sing backup vocals for him.

Right

Which we never talked about.

But likely it's-

And I wanted to just drop that

... not about him.

It's not about him.

Yeah.

[clears throat]

He was younger, a little bit.

Yeah

And she was sort of a mentor toward him.

This song is prob- almost probably definitely referencing Norris Burrows, who in ...

I know you think it's only in that one picture, but I have unearthed several pictures where I do think he bears-

It's fine.

I don't think he needs to look just like Marlon Brando.

Well-

I just don't necessarily see it, but that's ...

I can-

In his-

Eh.

He wrote an entire book, right here.

It's called My Madonna: My Intimate Friendship with the Blue-Eyed Girl-

She forgave that?

... on the rebuttal in New York.

Okay, she forgave that book?

I'm not sure.

[laughs]

I'm so, like, love, light, peace and respect.

I don't think anybody read this book besides me-

[laughs]

... and maybe, like, eight mega Madonna fans.

Um, it's actually, it's kind of like, it's not a particularly well-written book, but it's, like, kind of sweet.

Um, he recalls meeting her and writes, "Madonna reached over with her forefinger and stroked my bicep.

A charge of electricity went through me.

'Nice arms.

You look like Marlon Brando in A Streetcar Named Desire.'" And then later in the book, she calls him to invite him over and says, "Why don't you get your gorgeous Brando body over here?" So it's almost-

Okay

... definitely her.

He was also in a band called Steel Breeze, playing guitar.

He was a artist and an illustrator.

He actually played a few shows with Richard Lloyd from Television.

Okay.

Most importantly, he's the one that introduced her to Dan Gilroy.

So he actually did play a kind of a m- major-

Okay

... part in her, like, artistic formation.

Also, after ...

This is just, I thought it was really interesting.

After d- her and Dan Gilroy started dating, so they had, like, a bit of a relationship, and then it kind of fizzled out, and then she started dating Dan Gilroy, and they, him and Dan Gilroy were still friends, that he was still around.

And he has a piece in his book where he's like, I guess they were at a rehearsal for The Breakfast Club at the gog, the synagogue, and just him and Madonna went to go get donuts.

And he reached over and, quote, "Gently brushed the sugar from her mouth.

'You're covered with sugar, as usual,' I said.

I moved closer and kissed her behind her ear.

'I love you, and I always will.' 'Ditto,' she replied." He also wrote a song for her called My Little Angel, just so you know.

[laughs]

It's also possible that she had some private relationships that we didn't know about-

I mean-

... and that it's just a total, uh, mystery

She's also, she's an artist, and maybe this was, like, a fun thing to look back on.

I mean, it sounds like they had a pretty profound, uh, connection.

Here's two other just really fun facts about him.

He later played guitar in the house music group Craze.

Do you remember this? They had a hit called The Party in 1988.

It's a big song.

I would need to hear the song.

[upbeat music]

Yeah, this one?

Okay, okay, okay.

Anyways, that's fab.

He was in that.

So apparently she knew about that.

That's '88.

And then in 1992, in his book, he says that Slam, Oliver, her dancer, called him and invited him to Madonna's birthday party.

And he was like, "Oh, I didn't think she would remember me." And he was like, "Oh, she remembers you."

Ooh.

And I guess he thought it was kind of a hoax, so he said that he would love to come, but he can't afford the airfare, so if they would send him a round-trip ticket.

And Oliver was like, "Oh, I'll go check for you," and obviously never called back.

[laughs]

So I don't know.

But she was thinking about him appar- if you, if he is to be believed in his book, in 1992.

And, and as we said, she doesn't forget anybody.

Yeah

She remembers everyone.

Um, also he m- notes that he went on a blind date with Sandra Bernhard in 1976 in LA randomly, well before they be- became friends.

Small world.

And he got really-

Lower population back then.

Yeah, lower population.

And he got really into yoga, and his instructor was Madonna's masseuse and introduced him to Gwyneth Paltrow as Madonna's old friend, LOL.

Um, he was not, he did not live in the Lower East Side, but he did work with Madonna at the same place on St. Mark's Place called The Gossamer Wing.

So I think it's this guy.

Okay.

Detective Yassi.

On the case, babe.

[whoosh] I think what I would love to talk about is-

Mm-hmm, mm-hmm

... where you feel th- like, where you feel this lands in her canon.

Could this be her best album?

I don't think so.

I think it's, it's very high up, but I don't know if it's ...

I mean, best? That's-

I think what we've established throughout Madonna-mania is that there is no best.

Mm-hmm.

It's like there-

It's personal preference

...

there are multiple monuments.

Yeah.

I saw somebody that ranked some Madonna albums-

So I'm incapable of ranking them

... on X and put, like, True Blue and Like a Prayer at the very bottom, and I was like, "You should be executed."

I kind of reflexively put True Blue at number one, but I also, you know, you could argue she peaked at Ray of Light or you could argue-

Yeah, it just depends what lens you're looking through

... it's, like, Erotica or Confessions.

Some days I think Music is her best record.

So it's-

Do I think-

But I do think this is up there

Do I think this is the best album in the last 20 years? Yes.

Yes.

I think what's significant about even saying could this be her best record is, is this her best record, is that is not a question that we were asking-

That has been asked recently, yeah

... on Hard Candy-

Totally.

MDNA

...

MDNA, Rebel Heart or Madame X.

Yeah, yeah.

So it's like We, it would have been perfectly fair to assume that she was never gonna hit this register again

Totally

And I think that, like, if you're out in the world among civilians who are not necessarily paying attention, as I was recently, a lot of people are going to come with the assumption that it's not a good record or that it's not worth their time.

Um, and those are people who have not listened to the album at all, and, and they won't even believe you when you say that it's good.

So it's your job to definitely go out there and let everybody know-

100%

... she's fucking back.

Um, I also, I do, someone asked about Grammys.

I do think it's absolutely gonna be nominated, um, for dance, definitely dance electronic recordings and stuff.

Um-

I think yes.

I think Album of the Year.

You think it'll win?

I think it'll be nominated.

I think it'll be nominated too.

The thing is, like, I'm pessimistic when it comes to, like, awards things-

Totally

... and, like, um, awards bodies and shows and all that, but I think that, like, it's the perfect opportunity in an industry context to celebrate Madonna in a way that we haven't gotten to, and that she's not often celebrated, like, at the Grammy Awards.

You know, to have a big Madonna moment.

There's this thing that happens with awards where it's like, are you giving it, the award for the work or because, like, this person's due or overdue?

Yeah.

I think in this case you have someone who's overdue, but you also are like, "She deserves it for this record."

Totally.

Which is a thrilling-

Like, it's both

... thought to have.

Yeah, it's not just like a-

Like, that she could be in the mix and performing and appearing on the Grammys and potentially winning an Album of the Year or something like that is...

I mean, I think everyone should get into it.

Don't fuck it up.

I agree.

Start the hype.

Start the drum beat.

Um, I think one of the other interesting questions was, and I love this 'cause I love that it came up a couple of times, 'cause I was like, "Hell yeah, my listeners fucking get it," which is that C2, it's what I'm calling Confessions too.

C2.

C2, [laughs] reminded them of Songs of a Lost World by The Cure and Blackstar by David Bowie, and I think those are actually excellent comparisons because those are two recent examples of late career excellence that also deal with reflections on mortality.

Mm-hmm.

So I thought that was wonderful.

And they were like, "Do you have thoughts on age on music?" And I do.

I think my thoughts are that if you try to ignore what is an obvious consideration for you, you will make probably bad music, and I think if you're willing to be so honest with what you're actually living through, you make some, you can make some of the best music of your career in the late stage.

And I, that's my personal opinion.

I agree.

Okay.

Great.

Great.

Great.

Um, okay.

I obviously, I went deep-

With the remixes?

No, of, like, who else has had this level of achievement at this career stage.

Yeah.

Who did you? 'Cause I didn't, I didn't really, like...

It's hard to say because no one's exactly at this career stage.

And nobody ever will be.

Um, but f- weirdly I thought of, like, when Slowdive came back-

Mm

... that album in 2017, the self-titled album.

They're not as old as Madonna, they're younger, but it was like it felt unprecedented in a way because no one expected it to be as good as it was.

And same with that new My Bloody Valentine album that came out.

Totally.

I was gonna say My Bloody Valentine.

Um, a lot of the old shoegaze bands are kind of keeping it up, like Ride is still really good.

Yeah.

I thought about Trent Reznor, which is a bit-

Yeah, Nine Inch Nails is pretty fucking major.

It's incredible, and he's someone who's maintained-

Mm-hmm

... and even on some levels improved over the years-

Right, I mean, his film, his film work

... into this, like, eminent figure, you know?

Totally.

And it, we don't think about him, but he was around in the '80s.

He's only, like, six years younger than Madonna.

Yeah.

That's really wild.

And, like, he's really kept it up.

Like, I think Trent Reznor will be thought of like Bowie in a, for me-

Oh, that's a really great, that's a really great one

Like, that to me is, like, pretty much...

But then there's, like, Leonard Cohen's last album was really good.

Really good.

Yeah.

John Prine.

I also was really excited because this gave me the opportunity to talk about how the Pet Shop Boys have never fucking slipped.

It's true.

Like, all their later albums are still good.

Yeah.

I think that anyone that's gotten into Stuart Price because of this album or revisiting Confessions needs to go and listen to Super, which was their album from I think-

Yeah

... like 2016, around then.

Fucking flawless.

Stuart Price produced it.

Yeah.

Amazing.

Um, and then I just wanted to throw out also, and I'm not saying that, like, their recent albums are necessarily masterpieces, but they have high highs.

Mm-hmm.

Janet Jackson.

Totally.

Who I, who we're due a Janet album I feel like, 'cause it's been about 10 years since Unbreakable, which had some really good songs on it.

Damn Baby, very important.

Um, Kylie Minogue also, and Mariah Carey.

Totally.

[laughs]

And you know what? I'm gonna throw out a crazy one.

Red Hot Chili Peppers, their last album was really good.

[laughs]

Yeah.

The double album was actually really good.

Um, okay.

Let's close it out because we gotta, we gotta close it out.

I think, I'm gonna be honest, I don't, I wanna go to the tour really bad.

I don't have any opinions or thoughts of how it should be.

Like, I, I wanna be blown away and surprised.

Um, but a lot of people ask what we'd want from the tour, and I'm like, "I just want something amazing." And I know, like, I don't, I don't want, I don't wanna dictate it.

I feel like that's the whole thing about these tours is that she, like, she always comes up with something incredible that kind of surprises and blows people away, and I, that's exactly what I want again.

And it's gonna be based on what she feels like doing.

Yeah.

It's like if she wants to do one big performa- like, her doing World Cup, she's like what? You know, and she played in Rio, that was, like, massive.

Yeah.

She decides to do these big things.

I feel like the Club Confessions release parties that have been popping up are a little bit of her- Trying out this model of, like, if I threw, if I toured this as, like, a club night-

Yeah

... rather than a concert, like a stadium concert-

What would it be like?

If it was, like...

If it was more like clubs-

Yeah

... and those sorts of venues.

Something more intimate.

And it could be cool because, like, it'll become a hotter ticket.

It's not gonna sell...

There's not as much opportunity to get in.

Yeah, and also it, it kinda, I think, frees her from the, like, uh, pressure to do such crazy spectacle, which, you know, I think obviously her physicality-

Yeah

... is challenged at this point, um, as would any- I think she c- can move almost better than I can.

Well, she talked about her knee in that interview in magazine.

Yeah, her knee.

She has no cartilage.

Like, she had a hip replacement.

I mean, she's...

I think she's incredible for what she's able to do at her age, but, like, she can't do, like, what she did at 40.

Um, I think the last thing I would like to talk about is remixes.

Our desires and our speculations.

For me, I would like Junior Vasquez.

Ooh.

I would like Victor Calderone.

Okay.

I would like Danny Tenaglia.

Okay.

And of course William Orbit, but I would also like new people.

I would like Jeff Barrow from Portishead.

Amazing.

We're doing the ma- we're doing wish lists.

Wow, okay.

Fantasy league.

I would like Two Hollis.

[laughs] Okay.

Love.

I would like Nina Jaraci.

I would like Classics.

Classics?

Isn't that random?

Yeah.

I don't know.

I love Classics.

They're good.

Every Classics remix I've ever heard is amazing, and I feel like they bring something a little more roman- like dreamy romantic to it.

I was trying to think of, like, taking it in different directions.

LCD Soundsystem?

I mean, not, no.

[laughs]

N- like, s- some of our, like-

That's fun

...

some of our, like, or Adonis Adon- you know, like-

Yeah

... that world of people would be kind of cool.

What's, what's the Persian guy that we like? The-

Oh, like a Boy Harsher remix-

Yeah

... or something?

Um, Miss Grit I think would, could be really cool, and Hank, my bro.

Okay.

Hank, who does house music.

I think he could do really cool.

Those are some of the ones that came to my mind.

What about you?

I didn't answer that question-

And obviously Shep

...

but I can do it off the top of my head.

Obviously I would love some Shep in the mix.

Shep for sure.

Yeah.

Like, if we're-

Shep alert

...

I've...

Listening to it just this morning-

Yeah

...

I was like, "I wonder what Shep thinks of this song."

[laughs]

"I wonder what Shep thinks of this record." I'm very curious about Shep's thoughts, if Shep's phone has rang.

Right.

If he's-

Shep's phone has probably been ringing.

[laughs]

A Shep remix on a Stuart Price track is a little bit gay heaven to me-

[laughs]

... and I'm, like, hoping that it happens.

Um, so Shep Pettibone for sure.

Of, of, of the old divas, of the old cohort-

Right

...

I would...

I love that.

William Orbit too, great.

I don't know.

I c- I can see her.

There's, like, where I could see her going, and then it's, like, where she should be going, you know? It's like Honey Dijon was predictable.

Yeah.

Um, Peggy Gou was less predictable-

And I liked that

...

but I really enjoyed it.

I really liked that.

Like, I can see her maybe with Fred again.

Yeah.

Uh, Jamie XX, who I talked about before.

Oh, even Romy.

Romy.

She obviously loves Romy.

Romy was at our Club Confessions.

That would be a great one.

And apart from that, it's like-

Maybe, like, s- I would, I wouldn't mind, like, an Underscores.

I, wanna, kinda, like, I just wanna hear, like, these songs taken in a bunch of different directions.

That would be really cool for me.

Like, what's going on now? Maybe some other mid-tempo st- like, just, like-

Mm-hmm

... stretch the songs in every way you can.

A CF CF remix-

Yes

... maybe.

I don't know.

I don't know.

I guess we'll see what she does.

There's, like, a lot of the people that I initially thought about have been doing a lot lately, and so I'm like, "I don't know if it should be..." I'm more into, like, surprises.

We previously talked about this on the mail bag episode.

Yeah.

I said she should do something [laughs] with Richard X or, like-

Totally

...

Ladytron or, like-

Love Ladytron

It's like, let's go through all the eras of, like, who you didn't fuck with but maybe you can now in a fun, surprising way.

Yeah.

I love it.

And I think, I'm hoping, like, back to, like, her being able to tap new talent, I think she might surprise us.

Give me a D.A.R.E. remix.

I'm here for it.

I was gonna say the D.A.R.E

Yeah.

Like, let's f- is LCD busy? Let's call the D.A.R.E.

[laughs]

Yeah.

Um, all right.

Arca will do it.

Arca s- probably has d- done it, probably is doing it.

Yeah.

Um, an Addison Rae remix.

Well, for features? Yeah.

Charlie.

Robin.

Kylie, obviously.

We're-

Everyone's gonna-

... gonna promise

... everyone answers the phone when Madonna calls.

Yeah.

Junior Vasquez.

When Madonna calls.

When Madonna calls.

Um, all right, you guys.

We said this was gonna be short.

We lied.

Um, thank you for joining our emergency Confessions on a Dance Floor 2 episode.

Um, any other final thoughts, or you wanna just, uh-

I think just, like all great albums, keep listening to it.

Like, new things unfold-

Totally

... to you.

New favorites emerge.

Totally.

Songs you didn't think you loved-

[laughs]

... you're gonna change your mind and love.

You're not allowed to love anymore.

Songs you thought you loved, you're gonna be sick of them.

You're not allowed to have any more new favorites.

Yeah.

You've had enough new favorites.

[laughs]

Um, okay, come back next week for a new episode of Bandslam.

Thank you, Patrick.

[upbeat music] If you like what you heard today, subscribe for more episodes of Bandslam.

Our guest today was Patrick Sandberg.

This episode was produced by Rob Sunderman and Jamie Ukick, with help from Justin Sales.

Executive producers for Bandslam are Gina Delvac and me, Yasi Saleh.

Our gorgeous and catchy theme song was composed and performed by Bethany Cosentino and Jennifer Clavin, and graciously recorded by Carlos de la Garza in Los Angeles, California.

Special thanks to our producer emeritus, producer Dylan, AKA Dylan Tupper Rupert, and also Sean Fennessy and the television program The Agency.

Come back every Thursday for a new episode of Bandslam on Spotify or wherever you listen to podcasts.
“Unpacking the album’s hidden sonic architect”
“Sibling grief meets unanswered what-ifs”
“Spotting a surprising modern mirror”
“When ranking favorites gets delightfully impossible”