Jan 27, 2026 · 49 min · 9 segments
On this episode of Who's Editing?, Siskoid and special guest Captain Entropy tackle Who's Who Update '87 #5 and reinvent the DC Universe using only that comic's entries! Superboy! The Watchmen!…
And we start with the Reaper.
As Gotham's former vigilante, I decided to lump him in with the heroes, and I hope you agree.
This is going to be my longest description because this is also the setup for the entire scenario of my overarching concept.
So the issue that spawned this scenario is Green Lantern Volume 2, Number 8 from 1962.
Once upon a time in the year AD 5700, Earth will be under threat from an army of evolved Gila monsters, as happens from time to time.
The authoritarian solar council of that time that rules Earth will try to pick a solar director to lead them through this mess.
but none of their candidates for dictator slash savior seemed qualified, so they looked back into the past.
They plucked Hal Jordan from 1961, messed with his brain to make him think he was a local named Paul Manning, issued him a girlfriend from the Solar Council membership, and let him save the day.
This sort of highly questionable Silver Age activity happened a few more times.
Eventually, because the brain damage from all this was starting to build up for poor old Hal, the Solar Council remade another Green Lantern into Paul Manning.
This time the threat is a marauding space armada from across the universe bearing down on them and on all the planets associated with them.
Think the Legion's United Planets, but it's 28 centuries later and now they're in kind of a loose confederation.
Some became the officers of their shadowy empire, so they still have their minds.
They take the resources they need from the planets they conquer and destroy the rest so their victims can't rise again and come after them.
The comic that tells their story shows the Machiavellian machinations between the officers of the ruling council as they compete for power and even to take the throne.
Some of them regret their decision to join the Reapers and we see the decisions those regrets lead them to make.
And we start with the Reaper.
As Gotham's former vigilante, I decided to lump him in with the heroes, and I hope you agree.
This is going to be my longest description because this is also the setup for the entire scenario of my overarching concept.
So the issue that spawned this scenario is Green Lantern Volume 2, Number 8 from 1962.
Once upon a time in the year AD 5700, Earth will be under threat from an army of evolved Gila monsters, as happens from time to time.
The authoritarian solar council of that time that rules Earth will try to pick a solar director to lead them through this mess.
but none of their candidates for dictator slash savior seemed qualified, so they looked back into the past.
They plucked Hal Jordan from 1961, messed with his brain to make him think he was a local named Paul Manning, issued him a girlfriend from the Solar Council membership, and let him save the day.
This sort of highly questionable Silver Age activity happened a few more times.
Eventually, because the brain damage from all this was starting to build up for poor old Hal, the Solar Council remade another Green Lantern into Paul Manning.
This time the threat is a marauding space armada from across the universe bearing down on them and on all the planets associated with them.
Think the Legion's United Planets, but it's 28 centuries later and now they're in kind of a loose confederation.
Some became the officers of their shadowy empire, so they still have their minds.
They take the resources they need from the planets they conquer and destroy the rest so their victims can't rise again and come after them.
The comic that tells their story shows the Machiavellian machinations between the officers of the ruling council as they compete for power and even to take the throne.
Some of them regret their decision to join the Reapers and we see the decisions those regrets lead them to make.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.