Chulin 137 חולין דף קלז
Sep 12, 2026 · 19 min · 9 segments
- Speakers
Eli StefanskyHost
- Top entities
- Abba Arikha×4HezekiahMishnah×21Pe'ah×2Torah×5
Sep 12, 2026 · 19 min · 9 segments
Eli StefanskyHost
shalom to all today's office is only with sheep not with any other animals such as goats ask the government anonymously how do we know that so Don't work with the bachar of your ox and don't shear the bachar of your sheep.
I only know from here that in Bechar, a firstborn ox is not allowed to be worked with, and a firstborn sheep is not allowed to be shorn.
How do I know to apply this to that and that to this? Being that it's even also to work with a firstborn sheep or shear a firstborn ox.
So the Pasuk says, they're linked together in the same Pasuk, tells that each one has both Yisuran.
And in the Mele, we could have this gzer shava of giza giza to Reish HaZagaz, and that would tell us that there's a chi of Reish HaZagaz, even when we're shearing an ox, and not just a sheep.
So Mark says, no, Amar Krav, the possible, Reish HaZagaz says, tita loy, give it to him, meaning it has to be something he's able to use for his clothing, v'loy le sakai, not just as a sack, and anything that's going to be shorn off of an ox is only to be used for a sack, not as clothing.
As a more fine element, if that's really so, the knights of goats should be chayiv in Rish HaGez.
Now, even though knights is literally translated as feathers, that's what we actually call goat hair, because it's usually plucked like feathers, as opposed to shorn like wool.
But either which way, goat hair should be included in Rish HaGez, because that could be used for clothing.
So the grand answer is no, but in a giza v'lecha, we still have to make the word giza, which means to shear, and that doesn't apply by goats, as we just said, that its hair is plucked.
The bottom line is, though, that even though goat hair is plucked and not shorn, since that's the norm, that's what you do with it, that's the way to take goat's hair off its body, so it actually would be considered giza.
So back to the drawing board, how do we know the ratio of gazes is only from sheep and not from men? Halchan Am Yisro Tov over here in regards to the type that we're going to be giving him, it has to be fit for sheris, for service, and it has to be wool, because we just said, the amount of wool that we're giving him has to be usable, and that would be to make the avnet, the belt out of, and that has tcheles, which is wool dyed with blue, so it must be that it's wool, and wool obviously comes from sheep, so we just further clarify, so what's the josh of giza giza for, and that's So we see the wool has to be able to warm a person.
Read the full transcript.
Create an account to read the whole episode, search across every transcript, and follow the shows you care about.
shalom to all today's office is only with sheep not with any other animals such as goats ask the government anonymously how do we know that so Don't work with the bachar of your ox and don't shear the bachar of your sheep.
I only know from here that in Bechar, a firstborn ox is not allowed to be worked with, and a firstborn sheep is not allowed to be shorn.
How do I know to apply this to that and that to this? Being that it's even also to work with a firstborn sheep or shear a firstborn ox.
So the Pasuk says, they're linked together in the same Pasuk, tells that each one has both Yisuran.
And in the Mele, we could have this gzer shava of giza giza to Reish HaZagaz, and that would tell us that there's a chi of Reish HaZagaz, even when we're shearing an ox, and not just a sheep.
So Mark says, no, Amar Krav, the possible, Reish HaZagaz says, tita loy, give it to him, meaning it has to be something he's able to use for his clothing, v'loy le sakai, not just as a sack, and anything that's going to be shorn off of an ox is only to be used for a sack, not as clothing.
As a more fine element, if that's really so, the knights of goats should be chayiv in Rish HaGez.
Now, even though knights is literally translated as feathers, that's what we actually call goat hair, because it's usually plucked like feathers, as opposed to shorn like wool.
But either which way, goat hair should be included in Rish HaGez, because that could be used for clothing.
So the grand answer is no, but in a giza v'lecha, we still have to make the word giza, which means to shear, and that doesn't apply by goats, as we just said, that its hair is plucked.
The bottom line is, though, that even though goat hair is plucked and not shorn, since that's the norm, that's what you do with it, that's the way to take goat's hair off its body, so it actually would be considered giza.
So back to the drawing board, how do we know the ratio of gazes is only from sheep and not from men? Halchan Am Yisro Tov over here in regards to the type that we're going to be giving him, it has to be fit for sheris, for service, and it has to be wool, because we just said, the amount of wool that we're giving him has to be usable, and that would be to make the avnet, the belt out of, and that has tcheles, which is wool dyed with blue, so it must be that it's wool, and wool obviously comes from sheep, so we just further clarify, so what's the josh of giza giza for, and that's So we see the wool has to be able to warm a person.