Sep 11, 2026 · 44 min · 12 segments
In this week’s episode, Fiona McAnena is joined by Tanya de Grunwald, host of the This isn’t Working podcast and founder of the This is Working network, to discuss how employers should navigate the…
Tanya de GrunwaldGuest
Fiona McAnenaHost
Now, the reason we're talking about this today is because there's been a news story about an organization called Trans in the City.

So we, Sex Matters, have written to the Equality and Human Rights Commission to object to Trans in the City's activity where they have published guidance and it's on a webpage that says, download EHRC guidance here.

And you would think that that was the guidance that the Equality and Human Rights Commission provides to the law for employers to do the right thing by all their employees.

It's we think it's very misleading because when you look at what's in that link, what trans in the city have written completely contradicts the HRC guidance and indeed the law.

Now, the organisation claims on its website that the guidance was developed in partnership with involved Robin Moore White and leading employment law experts.

So, again, if you were an employer or HR person, department or whatever, you would look at that and think, well, legal people have done this.

And the very first statement after the title page is the summary recommendation, which says, The lower risk approach for employers is to allow employees to use the facilities that they feel most comfortable using.

We think that's an absolute scandal, but it must be very confusing for employers, Tanya, because for years they've been told that's what the law requires.

They've been told to be trans inclusive, meaning let the men who say they're women use the women's facilities.

But when you see guidance like this from trans in the city claiming to be developed in partnership with lawyers, What are employers to make of it? What's your take

on that? My take is that I think you're being very, very generous, Fiona, with these people, because I think if you're a leader in the end of 2026, headings towards 27, and you don't know that there's a big problem with this trans thing and that ignoring it and not understanding it is going to create massive legal, commercial, reputational risks for you, and you need to be really, really careful whose advice you take, then frankly, you're not...

Or you're a leader who's so ideologically attached to some of these ideas, which let's remember are very fringe ideas, that you're not able to see this clearly.

Actually, particularly within the last couple of months, but within the last year or so, I think there's absolutely no excuse for it.

You're seeing organizations where not very good people have made it right up to the top and have not taken charge of this.

I do think it's still a muddle, but I don't think it's impossible to find the good people because we're right here.

Now, the reason we're talking about this today is because there's been a news story about an organization called Trans in the City.

So we, Sex Matters, have written to the Equality and Human Rights Commission to object to Trans in the City's activity where they have published guidance and it's on a webpage that says, download EHRC guidance here.

And you would think that that was the guidance that the Equality and Human Rights Commission provides to the law for employers to do the right thing by all their employees.

It's we think it's very misleading because when you look at what's in that link, what trans in the city have written completely contradicts the HRC guidance and indeed the law.

Now, the organisation claims on its website that the guidance was developed in partnership with involved Robin Moore White and leading employment law experts.

So, again, if you were an employer or HR person, department or whatever, you would look at that and think, well, legal people have done this.

And the very first statement after the title page is the summary recommendation, which says, The lower risk approach for employers is to allow employees to use the facilities that they feel most comfortable using.

We think that's an absolute scandal, but it must be very confusing for employers, Tanya, because for years they've been told that's what the law requires.

They've been told to be trans inclusive, meaning let the men who say they're women use the women's facilities.

But when you see guidance like this from trans in the city claiming to be developed in partnership with lawyers, What are employers to make of it? What's your take

on that? My take is that I think you're being very, very generous, Fiona, with these people, because I think if you're a leader in the end of 2026, headings towards 27, and you don't know that there's a big problem with this trans thing and that ignoring it and not understanding it is going to create massive legal, commercial, reputational risks for you, and you need to be really, really careful whose advice you take, then frankly, you're not...

Or you're a leader who's so ideologically attached to some of these ideas, which let's remember are very fringe ideas, that you're not able to see this clearly.

Actually, particularly within the last couple of months, but within the last year or so, I think there's absolutely no excuse for it.

You're seeing organizations where not very good people have made it right up to the top and have not taken charge of this.

I do think it's still a muddle, but I don't think it's impossible to find the good people because we're right here.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.