Jul 9, 2026 · 21 min · 9 segments
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.serioustrouble.show *Humphrey’s Executor*, which has been…
We've finally gotten the ruling that laid out the thing that the Supreme Court has been telegraphing in a series of cases for months, or actually two rulings.
One about the Federal Trade Commission in which they have finally driven a stake through the heart of Humphrey's executor.
A precedent that allowed the existence of independent commissions in the executive branch, which this court has just been weakening and weakening and weakening.
And there have been shadow docket cases where they're like, well, basically this probably doesn't exist anymore.
So here they finally overturn Humphrey's executor and say the president can fire officials on the Federal Trade Commission.
And then another decision in Trump v. Cook, this one about the Federal Reserve, saying another thing we long expected, which is that you can't have independent commissions except the Fed, which is special and unique and in a long historical tradition.
And they have like – they've hinted at this bullshit and now we have the fully fleshed form of the bullshit that says the independent commissions, they're unconstitutional.
So let's break down these two decisions and where they leave the executive branch and the ability to have things that are beyond the president's reach.
The back story to this, again, is the case Humphreys Executor, which is an FDR-era case that basically said FDR couldn't just fire whoever he wanted when it came to entities created by Congress.
Yes, you can fire this Democratic member of the FTC board because that's inherent in the power of the president, the structure of the government.
the separation of powers, you can't have an executive agency, with a head that you can't fire, except Roberts is careful to note in an extensive, gratuitous section of this long opinion, the Fed, which is our historically large adult son that has special historical residences and which, you know, protects my 401k.
And notably, the conservatives, you know, at 6-3, the conservatives all joined the opinion, except for that part, which Justice Thomas does not join.
Lisa Cook is a member of the Federal Reserve Board who had been appointed by Joe Biden.
We've finally gotten the ruling that laid out the thing that the Supreme Court has been telegraphing in a series of cases for months, or actually two rulings.
One about the Federal Trade Commission in which they have finally driven a stake through the heart of Humphrey's executor.
A precedent that allowed the existence of independent commissions in the executive branch, which this court has just been weakening and weakening and weakening.
And there have been shadow docket cases where they're like, well, basically this probably doesn't exist anymore.
So here they finally overturn Humphrey's executor and say the president can fire officials on the Federal Trade Commission.
And then another decision in Trump v. Cook, this one about the Federal Reserve, saying another thing we long expected, which is that you can't have independent commissions except the Fed, which is special and unique and in a long historical tradition.
And they have like – they've hinted at this bullshit and now we have the fully fleshed form of the bullshit that says the independent commissions, they're unconstitutional.
So let's break down these two decisions and where they leave the executive branch and the ability to have things that are beyond the president's reach.
The back story to this, again, is the case Humphreys Executor, which is an FDR-era case that basically said FDR couldn't just fire whoever he wanted when it came to entities created by Congress.
Yes, you can fire this Democratic member of the FTC board because that's inherent in the power of the president, the structure of the government.
the separation of powers, you can't have an executive agency, with a head that you can't fire, except Roberts is careful to note in an extensive, gratuitous section of this long opinion, the Fed, which is our historically large adult son that has special historical residences and which, you know, protects my 401k.
And notably, the conservatives, you know, at 6-3, the conservatives all joined the opinion, except for that part, which Justice Thomas does not join.
Lisa Cook is a member of the Federal Reserve Board who had been appointed by Joe Biden.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.