May 11, 2026 · 34 min · 17 segments
In 1940, Mary “Moll” McCarthy was found shot dead in a field in rural Tipperary. Within months, Harry Gleeson, the farm labourer who reported her body to Gardaí, was convicted and hanged for her…
As always, in order to understand the crime at hand and, of course, our victim, we have to look at when and where this murder occurred.
While in our past episodes, we have ventured all the way back to the 18th century and all the way up to the 1920s, today's case is our most modern this season.
These parts of the island were mostly very poor at the time, isolated, and deeply agrarian places.
Life revolved around small farms, livestock, seasonal labor, local fairs, mass, of course, and the rhythms of parish life.
They would live off their livestock and whatever neighborly favors came their way.
It was a small and simple life, and many towns were still, 100 years later, feeling the effects of the Great Hunger, when almost a century of emigration, depopulation, and economic stagnation had left so many villages feel even more isolated.
Although Ireland obviously remained officially neutral, the war still shaped everyday life.
Rationing still affected the island of Ireland as important goods became very hard to access.
Moll McCarthy lived in a town called New Inn, which is around 11 kilometers outside of Cashel, but towns like these at this time especially felt even more isolated than they were.
Poor road conditions and limited transport meant that these communities existed in their own bubble.
Communities were very tightly knit, and as we have seen before in many similar cases, everyone knew everyone else's business, and if they didn't know about it, they made it up.
And look, Irish people may joke about our love of a good story, and we like to present ourselves as welcoming of strangers, but we have been whispering about our neighbors for centuries.
We are gossips, and in rural Ireland, what could seem like harmless gossip often carried serious consequences.
Reputation mattered enormously, and in some instances, a person's name was really all they had, and some people had far more than others.
More often than not, a woman in this world was only as good or as trusted as a man said she was.
As always, in order to understand the crime at hand and, of course, our victim, we have to look at when and where this murder occurred.
While in our past episodes, we have ventured all the way back to the 18th century and all the way up to the 1920s, today's case is our most modern this season.
These parts of the island were mostly very poor at the time, isolated, and deeply agrarian places.
Life revolved around small farms, livestock, seasonal labor, local fairs, mass, of course, and the rhythms of parish life.
They would live off their livestock and whatever neighborly favors came their way.
It was a small and simple life, and many towns were still, 100 years later, feeling the effects of the Great Hunger, when almost a century of emigration, depopulation, and economic stagnation had left so many villages feel even more isolated.
Although Ireland obviously remained officially neutral, the war still shaped everyday life.
Rationing still affected the island of Ireland as important goods became very hard to access.
Moll McCarthy lived in a town called New Inn, which is around 11 kilometers outside of Cashel, but towns like these at this time especially felt even more isolated than they were.
Poor road conditions and limited transport meant that these communities existed in their own bubble.
Communities were very tightly knit, and as we have seen before in many similar cases, everyone knew everyone else's business, and if they didn't know about it, they made it up.
And look, Irish people may joke about our love of a good story, and we like to present ourselves as welcoming of strangers, but we have been whispering about our neighbors for centuries.
We are gossips, and in rural Ireland, what could seem like harmless gossip often carried serious consequences.
Reputation mattered enormously, and in some instances, a person's name was really all they had, and some people had far more than others.
More often than not, a woman in this world was only as good or as trusted as a man said she was.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.