Nov 2, 2026 · 52 min · 12 segments
When a human-driven vehicle gets into a crash, an established legal framework holds parties who have contributed to harm accountable. But how does that work if a misbehaving robotaxi or robotruck…
Michael BrooksGuest
Phil KoopmanHost
Junko YoshidaHost
Yeah, I mean, that's the thing that humans have to deal with this patchwork of regulations, you know, every time we cross state lines.

And, you know, it's interesting to see how the AV industry has kind of bound that up as some huge problem that they can't, you know, get around and continue to try to.

get state and local laws preempted so that they can have a clear path to, or a more efficient path, I guess, if they're not having to spend money complying with lots of different state laws.

When you cross the state line, I don't have to go to traffic school in the next state.

The AV industry tried to make it sound as though that's the biggest hurdle that I have to overcome.

It's their way of looking for an efficient way to bulldoze, to promote the federal level.

The fact is that at the federal level, regulations, particularly safety regulations at the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration moved incredibly slowly.

I mean, I think you're talking about 10 to 15 to maybe 20 years from now, we might finally see some regulations come into play on autonomous vehicle safety because it takes that long for the agency to do it.

And what these companies are doing essentially is pushing to nullify all of the state and local law that they can while knowing that there isn't a federal safety standard for autonomous vehicles on the books that essentially opens up a wild west where there really are no laws or regulations until the Department of Transportation finally gets around to writing them.

preemption is supposed to work, right? You've got to have preemption in any type of government system where you've got, you know, a centralized control like the federal government and then, you know, the states which are, you know, beholden to federal law and then can create their own.

But typically, Preemption occurs when the DOT or NHTSA actually write a regulation.

What they're asking for here is preemption, you know, 10 to 20 years in advance of that, which to us doesn't make a lot of sense because I think we all assume that consumers are going to be left holding the bag in that in that situation.

Yeah, I mean, that's the thing that humans have to deal with this patchwork of regulations, you know, every time we cross state lines.

And, you know, it's interesting to see how the AV industry has kind of bound that up as some huge problem that they can't, you know, get around and continue to try to.

get state and local laws preempted so that they can have a clear path to, or a more efficient path, I guess, if they're not having to spend money complying with lots of different state laws.

When you cross the state line, I don't have to go to traffic school in the next state.

The AV industry tried to make it sound as though that's the biggest hurdle that I have to overcome.

It's their way of looking for an efficient way to bulldoze, to promote the federal level.

The fact is that at the federal level, regulations, particularly safety regulations at the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration moved incredibly slowly.

I mean, I think you're talking about 10 to 15 to maybe 20 years from now, we might finally see some regulations come into play on autonomous vehicle safety because it takes that long for the agency to do it.

And what these companies are doing essentially is pushing to nullify all of the state and local law that they can while knowing that there isn't a federal safety standard for autonomous vehicles on the books that essentially opens up a wild west where there really are no laws or regulations until the Department of Transportation finally gets around to writing them.

preemption is supposed to work, right? You've got to have preemption in any type of government system where you've got, you know, a centralized control like the federal government and then, you know, the states which are, you know, beholden to federal law and then can create their own.

But typically, Preemption occurs when the DOT or NHTSA actually write a regulation.

What they're asking for here is preemption, you know, 10 to 20 years in advance of that, which to us doesn't make a lot of sense because I think we all assume that consumers are going to be left holding the bag in that in that situation.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.