Jul 21, 2026 · 31 min · 10 segments
Two friends go camping in a California national forest, but only one returns alive. A wildfire, confusing accounts, and buried evidence nearly stand between authorities and the truth…but despite a…
[gentle music] In the early morning hours of Saturday, August 22nd, 2015, firefighters in Plumas County, California, responded to an urgent emergency call from visitors at Bucks Lake, who said that a brush fire was ripping through the area and growing larger with each passing minute.
Because the recreation space was such a popular spot for campers, emergency crews immediately got to work battling the blaze.
But as they made their way into the flames, they stumbled upon something even more alarming: a young man who appeared to be unconscious.
He had numerous stab wounds to his neck and wrists and was obviously in really bad shape.
Sheldon told authorities that he and Trevor had set up their camp in a more remote section of the forest off the beaten path between the parking lot and one of the designated campgrounds.
But at some point the previous night, Sheldon claimed Trevor had stabbed him and then taken off into the landscape.
Investigators didn't have enough information yet to really question Sheldon's story.
The district attorney for Plumas County at that time later told Crime Watch Daily that Sheldon came across as cooperative, polite, and well-spoken.
And based on what authorities had to go off of, it was looking like Trevor might be the potential threat since, according to Sheldon, he'd attacked him and was now loose somewhere in the forest, potentially capable of harming someone else.
During his initial interview with detectives, Sheldon told them that after arriving in the woods, he and Trevor had smoked cannabis together and taken multiple hits of LSD.
Then, after a while of tripping on acid, he claimed that Trevor had sexually propositioned him, but he rejected his friend's advances.
After that, he alleged that Trevor got more aggressive, and then things turned violent.
Sheldon would later recount what happened next in this way, quote, "I just kinda opened my eyes and looked behind me like this without moving, and the next thing I know, he's stabbing me in my neck.
I kicked him and stood up, and he realized after the knife wasn't sharp, and he just threw it and pulled out another knife." End quote.
In the scuffle, Sheldon said he'd stabbed Trevor on his arm at least two times, and it was at that point Trevor ran off into the woods.
Sheldon claimed he then laid on the forest floor for several hours, thinking he was going to bleed to death, and eventually passed out.
Now, while this interview was happening, firefighters were still on scene in the national forest trying to put out the brush fire.
But as they were in the middle of that process, they discovered something that stopped them cold.
Inside a smoldering burn pit, curled up in the fetal position, was a severely charred human body.
As soon as they saw it, they reported it to the Plumas County Sheriff's Office, and from the jump, it was evident to investigators that the person in the pit had not ended up there by accident.
[gentle music] In the early morning hours of Saturday, August 22nd, 2015, firefighters in Plumas County, California, responded to an urgent emergency call from visitors at Bucks Lake, who said that a brush fire was ripping through the area and growing larger with each passing minute.
Because the recreation space was such a popular spot for campers, emergency crews immediately got to work battling the blaze.
But as they made their way into the flames, they stumbled upon something even more alarming: a young man who appeared to be unconscious.
He had numerous stab wounds to his neck and wrists and was obviously in really bad shape.
Sheldon told authorities that he and Trevor had set up their camp in a more remote section of the forest off the beaten path between the parking lot and one of the designated campgrounds.
But at some point the previous night, Sheldon claimed Trevor had stabbed him and then taken off into the landscape.
Investigators didn't have enough information yet to really question Sheldon's story.
The district attorney for Plumas County at that time later told Crime Watch Daily that Sheldon came across as cooperative, polite, and well-spoken.
And based on what authorities had to go off of, it was looking like Trevor might be the potential threat since, according to Sheldon, he'd attacked him and was now loose somewhere in the forest, potentially capable of harming someone else.
During his initial interview with detectives, Sheldon told them that after arriving in the woods, he and Trevor had smoked cannabis together and taken multiple hits of LSD.
Then, after a while of tripping on acid, he claimed that Trevor had sexually propositioned him, but he rejected his friend's advances.
After that, he alleged that Trevor got more aggressive, and then things turned violent.
Sheldon would later recount what happened next in this way, quote, "I just kinda opened my eyes and looked behind me like this without moving, and the next thing I know, he's stabbing me in my neck.
I kicked him and stood up, and he realized after the knife wasn't sharp, and he just threw it and pulled out another knife." End quote.
In the scuffle, Sheldon said he'd stabbed Trevor on his arm at least two times, and it was at that point Trevor ran off into the woods.
Sheldon claimed he then laid on the forest floor for several hours, thinking he was going to bleed to death, and eventually passed out.
Now, while this interview was happening, firefighters were still on scene in the national forest trying to put out the brush fire.
But as they were in the middle of that process, they discovered something that stopped them cold.
Inside a smoldering burn pit, curled up in the fetal position, was a severely charred human body.
As soon as they saw it, they reported it to the Plumas County Sheriff's Office, and from the jump, it was evident to investigators that the person in the pit had not ended up there by accident.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.
