Female He Created Them Podcast
Oct 28, 2026 · 1 hr · 10 segments
In this episode, Mary and KT discuss Sick Societies by the anthropologist Robert B. Edgerton. We discuss breaking away from the evolutionary lens that…
The book we're reading today is Six Societies by Robert Edgerton.
who
So it's an academic anthropology book.
It's not hard to read academic anthropology, but he's definitely approaching it as an academic.
He's citing other professional anthropologists and trying to make an intervention.
in the literature, which for those who are other academics listening to this, I guess we'll understand and other people would be like, why are you subjecting me to this, you
know, jargon right now.
But basically
when an academic is writing something, they need to prove that it is important to write by showing how it, um, contributes and often departs from interpretations of earlier academics.
So that is departing from the interpretation of earlier academics, specifically other anthropologists, is the big point, essentially, of this book.
And his argument or his concern is that anthropologists The way that they do their research is that they live with the communities that they're studying, often for a period of years.
Not always continuously, but sometimes continuously, usually between one and three years.
At least that was the standard when he was writing.
And he...
His concern basically is that anthropologists have, I think the way that we have it in common parlance is gone native, or at least gone emotionally native, which is that they form bonds of affection with the people that they're studying because they're living with them and that is good and human and even right.
But his concern is that Essentially, from the time of Rousseau, there's this idea of the quote-unquote noble savage, which is that there's an understanding of primitive harmony.
So thinking about societies that are less technologically developed or don't exist in large, complex states, they exist in smaller states.
Kinship groups, clans, tribes, that kind of thing.
And this idea that everything was good until imperialism by Western powers or until the advance of these technologies or until we lived in complex societies or whatever.
And he says for a variety of reasons, usually redounding to either commitment to this ideal or the human affections of the researchers, many of the bad practices of these societies as they're presented that bolster the myth of primitive harmony are just completely papered over or whitewashed or even when They are acknowledged by the anthropologists.
There'll be a description of, like, oh, these are, you know, peaceful, totally in harmony, children are all obedient, you know, parents and families are perfectly ordered, etc.
And then during the course of the book, they... site occasions when that wasn't at all what it was like, seemingly without realizing that they're undermining their own thesis that this is, you know, perfectly how the society always goes.
Okay,
The book we're reading today is Six Societies by Robert Edgerton.
who
So it's an academic anthropology book.
It's not hard to read academic anthropology, but he's definitely approaching it as an academic.
He's citing other professional anthropologists and trying to make an intervention.
in the literature, which for those who are other academics listening to this, I guess we'll understand and other people would be like, why are you subjecting me to this, you
know, jargon right now.
But basically
when an academic is writing something, they need to prove that it is important to write by showing how it, um, contributes and often departs from interpretations of earlier academics.
So that is departing from the interpretation of earlier academics, specifically other anthropologists, is the big point, essentially, of this book.
And his argument or his concern is that anthropologists The way that they do their research is that they live with the communities that they're studying, often for a period of years.
Not always continuously, but sometimes continuously, usually between one and three years.
At least that was the standard when he was writing.
And he...
His concern basically is that anthropologists have, I think the way that we have it in common parlance is gone native, or at least gone emotionally native, which is that they form bonds of affection with the people that they're studying because they're living with them and that is good and human and even right.
But his concern is that Essentially, from the time of Rousseau, there's this idea of the quote-unquote noble savage, which is that there's an understanding of primitive harmony.
So thinking about societies that are less technologically developed or don't exist in large, complex states, they exist in smaller states.
Kinship groups, clans, tribes, that kind of thing.
And this idea that everything was good until imperialism by Western powers or until the advance of these technologies or until we lived in complex societies or whatever.
And he says for a variety of reasons, usually redounding to either commitment to this ideal or the human affections of the researchers, many of the bad practices of these societies as they're presented that bolster the myth of primitive harmony are just completely papered over or whitewashed or even when They are acknowledged by the anthropologists.
There'll be a description of, like, oh, these are, you know, peaceful, totally in harmony, children are all obedient, you know, parents and families are perfectly ordered, etc.
And then during the course of the book, they... site occasions when that wasn't at all what it was like, seemingly without realizing that they're undermining their own thesis that this is, you know, perfectly how the society always goes.
Okay,
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.