Jun 12, 2026 · 1 hr 44 min · 21 segments
Most women in 2026 are told menopause affects everything, the weight, the belly fat, the bones, the heart, the brain, and that the fix is hormones, supplements, and a proprietary protocol. The data…
Jordan FeigenbaumHost
Austin BarakiHost
Lorraine BarakiGuestAll right, Dr. Baraki, well, let's start out with body composition, and we'll begin with the question that women probably hear about most frequently, what menopause does to body composition.
They've probably heard all sorts of numbers thrown around, and you have, too, but the actual study that gives answers to this question most carefully is the SWAN body composition study.
And I think the answer, uh, it gives is different from what's, from what most women have been told.
So SWAN is an acronym, uh, and it stands for the Study of Women's Health Across the Nation.
This is a prospective group, uh, of about 3,000 women across seven different sites in the United States, and they're, they were enrolled in their early to mid-40s, and they were followed yearly with serial DEXA scans, which stands for dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry, uh, which is basically a fancy way of saying X-ray technology to tell you different body composition, um, levels.
So this is from UCLA, Greendale, and colleagues, and they published their analysis in 2019.
If menopause itself were the primary reason that women gained weight in, uh, the middle-- in, during midlife, you'd expect body fat to start piling on quickly when the transition hits.
You'd expect it to keep piling on across the post-menopausal years and account for most of what a woman gains between ages 40 and 60.
Menopause does add something to this curve, but it's more of a small bump on top of a much larger trend that's more about aging and behavior across, uh, these years and across several dec- several decades.
A patient walks in, she's 51, perimenopausal, and she's gained eight kilos over the last six years.
Her menopause coach, uh, that she found on Instagram tells her that this is hormonal, that estrogen and progesterone changes are the reason, and that the only fix is menopausal hormonal therapy plus a proprietary supplement stack.
... what proportion of her eight kilogram weight gain, um, would this study attribute to the menopausal transition itself?

One is how much of this weight gain is directly attributable to any degree of hormonal decline, or you c- if you wanted to take the extreme stance, like estrogen deficiency, so to speak.

Because that could be evaluated, that could be tested, and if true, then replacement or, or delivering, giving the, giving the woman that hormone back should either reverse that trend or should mitigate it from happening in the first place.

The other way to look at it, and this is the, I suppose, more charitable, uh, way, and if I were the person making those kind of claims, I might pivot and make the claim in this way to say, "Well, a lot of the changes that happen around midlife lead to a lot of unpleasant symptoms, and those unpleasant symptoms can then lead to a cascade of downstream consequences." So, for example, having, you know, hot flashes can make it really unpleasant to stay as active, to be outside, to be doing things throughout the year.

The night sweats can disrupt your sleep, make it more difficult to recover, can make you feel terrible and have less energy and motivation to do the physical activity, might increase appetite, things like that.

So there's a lot of indirect, plausible indirect ways that there could be some impacts here.

But I think that if the question was this is if she's saying purely directly hormonal, and the way we reverse it is by giving the hormones back, that is, to my understanding, not well supported by current evidence, um, looking at this as far as the direct impact of the hormonal decline throughout the menopausal transition on total body weight gain, total body fat gain.
All right, Dr. Baraki, well, let's start out with body composition, and we'll begin with the question that women probably hear about most frequently, what menopause does to body composition.
They've probably heard all sorts of numbers thrown around, and you have, too, but the actual study that gives answers to this question most carefully is the SWAN body composition study.
And I think the answer, uh, it gives is different from what's, from what most women have been told.
So SWAN is an acronym, uh, and it stands for the Study of Women's Health Across the Nation.
This is a prospective group, uh, of about 3,000 women across seven different sites in the United States, and they're, they were enrolled in their early to mid-40s, and they were followed yearly with serial DEXA scans, which stands for dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry, uh, which is basically a fancy way of saying X-ray technology to tell you different body composition, um, levels.
So this is from UCLA, Greendale, and colleagues, and they published their analysis in 2019.
If menopause itself were the primary reason that women gained weight in, uh, the middle-- in, during midlife, you'd expect body fat to start piling on quickly when the transition hits.
You'd expect it to keep piling on across the post-menopausal years and account for most of what a woman gains between ages 40 and 60.
Menopause does add something to this curve, but it's more of a small bump on top of a much larger trend that's more about aging and behavior across, uh, these years and across several dec- several decades.
A patient walks in, she's 51, perimenopausal, and she's gained eight kilos over the last six years.
Her menopause coach, uh, that she found on Instagram tells her that this is hormonal, that estrogen and progesterone changes are the reason, and that the only fix is menopausal hormonal therapy plus a proprietary supplement stack.
... what proportion of her eight kilogram weight gain, um, would this study attribute to the menopausal transition itself?

One is how much of this weight gain is directly attributable to any degree of hormonal decline, or you c- if you wanted to take the extreme stance, like estrogen deficiency, so to speak.

Because that could be evaluated, that could be tested, and if true, then replacement or, or delivering, giving the, giving the woman that hormone back should either reverse that trend or should mitigate it from happening in the first place.

The other way to look at it, and this is the, I suppose, more charitable, uh, way, and if I were the person making those kind of claims, I might pivot and make the claim in this way to say, "Well, a lot of the changes that happen around midlife lead to a lot of unpleasant symptoms, and those unpleasant symptoms can then lead to a cascade of downstream consequences." So, for example, having, you know, hot flashes can make it really unpleasant to stay as active, to be outside, to be doing things throughout the year.

The night sweats can disrupt your sleep, make it more difficult to recover, can make you feel terrible and have less energy and motivation to do the physical activity, might increase appetite, things like that.

So there's a lot of indirect, plausible indirect ways that there could be some impacts here.

But I think that if the question was this is if she's saying purely directly hormonal, and the way we reverse it is by giving the hormones back, that is, to my understanding, not well supported by current evidence, um, looking at this as far as the direct impact of the hormonal decline throughout the menopausal transition on total body weight gain, total body fat gain.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.