Aug 22, 2026 · 30 min · 12 segments
Nika Kabiri is a decision scientist who has spent 20+ years studying how consumers pick who to trust, including for legal tech companies like Clio and Avvo. In this conversation, Nika and Mike…
Nika KabiriGuest
Mike WhelanHost
Law is a credence good, right? Which means that everything is as valuable as we believe it is.

But the weird thing about credence goods is you have no way to justify your belief.

They can't answer the question, is this a good lawyer? Very well, because they, first of all, don't know how to operationalize good.

They don't know what good is supposed to even mean, much less how to measure it.

How do you know? It's easier to do with like, say, if you buy a pen, like good means it writes, it writes the way you want it to write.

So and what consumers will often do is use mental shortcuts and one such mental shortcut is what behavioral scientists call a substitution question rather than answering the question is he a good lawyer you might just without knowing it automatically under the radar of your awareness ask does he have is he nice or is he a bulldog or is she spending enough time with me Does she seem fiery enough to fight for me? So when I talk to consumers about what they look for in a lawyer, they will say things like that, good bedside manner or explains things really well, et cetera, et cetera, because they can't judge lawyering.

It sounds a bit like there's a halo effect in the sense that, you know, the halo effect is if somebody's pretty, I assume they're smart, right? If one characteristic aligns with something positive to me or negative in that sense, then I'll assign it to other things that are unrelated.

Are consumers doing that because they actually care about things like what flavor coffee is in the office and do people talk nice to me? Is that a good they're looking for or are they using that as proxies for other things that they actually are looking for?

It all comes down to the fact that humans, the human brain burns up so much fuel.

So it is by design, without us even thinking about it or knowing about it, it is by design trying to constantly be efficient.

Law is a credence good, right? Which means that everything is as valuable as we believe it is.

But the weird thing about credence goods is you have no way to justify your belief.

They can't answer the question, is this a good lawyer? Very well, because they, first of all, don't know how to operationalize good.

They don't know what good is supposed to even mean, much less how to measure it.

How do you know? It's easier to do with like, say, if you buy a pen, like good means it writes, it writes the way you want it to write.

So and what consumers will often do is use mental shortcuts and one such mental shortcut is what behavioral scientists call a substitution question rather than answering the question is he a good lawyer you might just without knowing it automatically under the radar of your awareness ask does he have is he nice or is he a bulldog or is she spending enough time with me Does she seem fiery enough to fight for me? So when I talk to consumers about what they look for in a lawyer, they will say things like that, good bedside manner or explains things really well, et cetera, et cetera, because they can't judge lawyering.

It sounds a bit like there's a halo effect in the sense that, you know, the halo effect is if somebody's pretty, I assume they're smart, right? If one characteristic aligns with something positive to me or negative in that sense, then I'll assign it to other things that are unrelated.

Are consumers doing that because they actually care about things like what flavor coffee is in the office and do people talk nice to me? Is that a good they're looking for or are they using that as proxies for other things that they actually are looking for?

It all comes down to the fact that humans, the human brain burns up so much fuel.

So it is by design, without us even thinking about it or knowing about it, it is by design trying to constantly be efficient.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.