Listener sentiment
That Was Pretty Scary sustains exceptionally strong listener satisfaction, with the overwhelming majority of recent reviews highly enthusiastic about the podcast's approach to horror film analysis. The dominant storyline is the 2025 departure of Freddie Prinze Jr. after 102 episodes—some listeners miss the former co-host's banter and humor, but many others actively prefer the new solo format, which has allowed Jon Lee Brody to expand his technical film analysis and behind-the-scenes insights. Across both camps, reviewers consistently praise Brody's passion, research depth, knowledge of filmmaking craft, and ability to surface hidden-gem films; several note the show has turned them into horror fans or significantly enriched their appreciation of the genre. Minor criticisms center on occasional factual oversights, pacing constraints that rush certain episodes, and a few listeners' preference for shorter, conversation-driven episodes over the deeper analytical format. The podcast's unique value proposition—blending actor and producer perspectives with genuine enthusiasm and accessibility—continues to resonate strongly with both horror newcomers and genre veterans.
Apple4.7 · 154
Summary generated May 29, 2026
