Effective Altruism’s Moral Void
Effective altruism faces a devastating moral critique
Sam LymanGuest
Marty BentHost
And for any of the people who may be in the 71 percent of poll respondents who would not want to.

I think it's important to to go over like the low hanging FUD and debunking like water usage is like that for context for anybody who's listening to this doesn't know like I sit on the board of a data center company historically.

And so I know this problem intimately and funnily enough, as you mentioned with your story, right on the Bitcoin mining front, we've been fighting these battles for many years, but like water usage is one like the people are commonly referencing some research report that was done over a decade ago and over exaggerated the water usage of data centers back then by something like 10,000%.

And so people are running with a bad research report and saying it's using so much water.

Yes, Bitcoin mining had its problems, and it's not like these things don't make any sound, but that is a problem that is solvable.

And then at the end of the day, are they raising electricity prices? And I can say for certain, at least for the data centers that we operate, we know for sure, because the utility companies that we work with have told us, and they've gone to public city council meetings and explicitly said this, because we're buying their excess capacity, they've been able to hold rates down for two years straight because we're there as a buyer of first and last resort.

Yeah, it's unfortunate too, because it's put the data center industry in a posture of defense.

I think for the last several months, data centers have been trying to explain to communities how they won't hurt their communities, which is a fairly easy case to make.

But even after you've made that case, I think data centers need to go a step further in explaining how they can actively help communities too.

There's plenty of stories that have been coming out as I think it's a bit of a lag effect, but the, I think the industry or parts of the industry at the very least have been jolted awake.

But if you look at some historical data centers from like microsoft or amazon in the towns that they they've entered particularly in the northwest and they've been there for decades like the turnaround that these towns have had because the data centers are paying property taxes and sales taxes on electricity that have enabled these small towns that were that were sort of hollowed out before data center came in you're talking about hundreds of millions of dollars of revenue over over many years that allow them to build roads, build schools, build football fields, hospitals, whatever it may be.

And for any of the people who may be in the 71 percent of poll respondents who would not want to.

I think it's important to to go over like the low hanging FUD and debunking like water usage is like that for context for anybody who's listening to this doesn't know like I sit on the board of a data center company historically.

And so I know this problem intimately and funnily enough, as you mentioned with your story, right on the Bitcoin mining front, we've been fighting these battles for many years, but like water usage is one like the people are commonly referencing some research report that was done over a decade ago and over exaggerated the water usage of data centers back then by something like 10,000%.

And so people are running with a bad research report and saying it's using so much water.

Yes, Bitcoin mining had its problems, and it's not like these things don't make any sound, but that is a problem that is solvable.

And then at the end of the day, are they raising electricity prices? And I can say for certain, at least for the data centers that we operate, we know for sure, because the utility companies that we work with have told us, and they've gone to public city council meetings and explicitly said this, because we're buying their excess capacity, they've been able to hold rates down for two years straight because we're there as a buyer of first and last resort.

Yeah, it's unfortunate too, because it's put the data center industry in a posture of defense.

I think for the last several months, data centers have been trying to explain to communities how they won't hurt their communities, which is a fairly easy case to make.

But even after you've made that case, I think data centers need to go a step further in explaining how they can actively help communities too.

There's plenty of stories that have been coming out as I think it's a bit of a lag effect, but the, I think the industry or parts of the industry at the very least have been jolted awake.

But if you look at some historical data centers from like microsoft or amazon in the towns that they they've entered particularly in the northwest and they've been there for decades like the turnaround that these towns have had because the data centers are paying property taxes and sales taxes on electricity that have enabled these small towns that were that were sort of hollowed out before data center came in you're talking about hundreds of millions of dollars of revenue over over many years that allow them to build roads, build schools, build football fields, hospitals, whatever it may be.
Every episode on Radar is fully transcribed, speaker-labeled, and rich with metadata. Here is a taste of this one. Try Radar for free to see the rest.
3 of 10
Effective Altruism’s Moral Void
Effective altruism faces a devastating moral critique
The Doomsday Narrative Machine
AI doomsday narratives may recycle old playbooks
The Alleged Anti-AI Psyop
Chinese messaging allegedly targeted America's AI buildout
+7 more clips · 13 min 35 sec of audio in all
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
All 10 clips — the highlight moments, each cut as its own audio, with a title and a speaker
All 17 segments — the transcript broken into labeled sections, every ad read marked
All 25 topics — jump to every other episode discussing the same subject
Every related episode — other shows Radar links to this one
No account is needed to search Radar.