Oct 6, 2026 · 1 hr 13 min · 13 segments
Pat Flynn and Ethan Muse explain and defend natural law theory while using an article by Matthew Adelstein ("Bentham's Bulldog" on Substack) as a springboard for the discussion. 00:00…
Ethan MuseHost
Pat FlynnHost
Well, so I mean, first we-- I think we just start out by talking about how Matthew characterizes natural law theory, the thesis that he's objecting to, or really the way he characterizes it is in terms of three theses-

... that he puts forward, and then a fourth ancillary thesis that he says the natural law theorists are committed to.

Um, now, just at the outset before we start reviewing those theses, basically I don't think I would agree with almost any of them the way that Matthew has formulated them, even though I would put myself forward as someone who believes in natural law theory.

So I think these theses, the way they've been expressed by Matthew, fail to capture natural law theory and what the core commitments or central motivations of natural law theorists are.

Um, or at the very least, to the extent that I would sign up for any of the theses, it would only be after we really disambiguated the terminology that he was using, 'cause then he proceeds to object to the theses in a way that shows that the meanings that he's assigning to the terms, to the extent that I could [laughs] do, like, an ameliorative reading of the theses to try to [laughs] show how they were consonant with my-

... to the extent that I could do that, it would then, like, negate the objections that he then proceeds to offer later on in the piece, you know?

Um, so I think, I think that's the first thing that's important to talk about at the outset.

Another thing that's important to talk about at the outset is just that, like, it's more mainly towards the end of the piece that he frames the motivations for natural law theory basically just in terms of, like, vindicating Catholic commitments about sexual ethics that he didn't even find decently plausible.

And I think given the whole architectonic framework of natural law theory would actually not commit you to any particular views about sexual ethics.

It would be very weird if the entire motivation for the framework were helping you get to this particular set-

And so I really think he's not considering, like, the actual more general, like, metaph- metaphysical, metaethical, and philosophical motivations for natural law theory and why we are attracted to it, um, and instead is just viewing it as basically, like, kind of like an ad hoc theory that's just meant to try to fit particular sets of ethical intuitions that he dissents from.

Well, so I mean, first we-- I think we just start out by talking about how Matthew characterizes natural law theory, the thesis that he's objecting to, or really the way he characterizes it is in terms of three theses-

... that he puts forward, and then a fourth ancillary thesis that he says the natural law theorists are committed to.

Um, now, just at the outset before we start reviewing those theses, basically I don't think I would agree with almost any of them the way that Matthew has formulated them, even though I would put myself forward as someone who believes in natural law theory.

So I think these theses, the way they've been expressed by Matthew, fail to capture natural law theory and what the core commitments or central motivations of natural law theorists are.

Um, or at the very least, to the extent that I would sign up for any of the theses, it would only be after we really disambiguated the terminology that he was using, 'cause then he proceeds to object to the theses in a way that shows that the meanings that he's assigning to the terms, to the extent that I could [laughs] do, like, an ameliorative reading of the theses to try to [laughs] show how they were consonant with my-

... to the extent that I could do that, it would then, like, negate the objections that he then proceeds to offer later on in the piece, you know?

Um, so I think, I think that's the first thing that's important to talk about at the outset.

Another thing that's important to talk about at the outset is just that, like, it's more mainly towards the end of the piece that he frames the motivations for natural law theory basically just in terms of, like, vindicating Catholic commitments about sexual ethics that he didn't even find decently plausible.

And I think given the whole architectonic framework of natural law theory would actually not commit you to any particular views about sexual ethics.

It would be very weird if the entire motivation for the framework were helping you get to this particular set-

And so I really think he's not considering, like, the actual more general, like, metaph- metaphysical, metaethical, and philosophical motivations for natural law theory and why we are attracted to it, um, and instead is just viewing it as basically, like, kind of like an ad hoc theory that's just meant to try to fit particular sets of ethical intuitions that he dissents from.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.