Listener sentiment
The split that defined earlier periods has hardened rather than healed: devoted fans still celebrate the trio's genuine friendship and effortless banter as the show's core appeal, while frustrated listeners — many of them longtime subscribers — repeat the same structural complaints with growing weariness. The dominant criticism remains the hosts' treatment of guests, with Will Arnett singled out for interrupting, steering conversations back to himself, and repeatedly mocking Sean Hayes, and Jason Bateman's rambling questions blamed for crowding out guests; several reviewers say they've shut off episodes or unsubscribed over it. A second persistent grievance is the guest mix, with a vocal camp arguing the show has gone stale and tiresome by relying on Hollywood friends promoting projects instead of the more varied early bookings, and a few conservative listeners say the show leans too politically one-sided. Advertising from AI companies (Amazon, Meta) continues to cost the show loyal listeners who view it as hypocrisy given the hosts' stated environmental concerns. Praise still clusters around standout episodes — the widely shared emotional Sandra Bullock conversation, Brian Cox's science-comedy blend, and turns from Amy Adams, Sting, and Robby Hoffman — and the hosts' kindness and chemistry keep fans calling the show a weekly highlight.
Apple3.9 · 1,554
Summary generated Oct 23, 2026
