Guilty Pleas Before Trial
The accused changed his plea before trial.
Tim ClarkGuest
Natalie BonjoloHost
Damian CrippsGuest
... um, a l- uh, it, it might seem obvious to a lot of people, but some people will be wondering why this evidence, um, is relevant or how, how it would come in, in-into a trial.

Um, was there any discussion about that pre these, these statements being read in? Did the court address that?

So this was- Um, just to put this in context, Mr. Edwards was originally charged with this crime, the Huntingdon crime and two, two of the murders way back in December 2016.

And basically, right up until about three weeks before the trial, he had maintained his innocence on all of those.

And then out of the blue, he, um, you know, two, three weeks before the trial, he pleaded guilty to Huntingdon, which we heard about last week, and he pleaded guilty to the rape.

But in all the pretrial sort of, um, prevarication, um, uh, the prosecutor argued for the propensity evidence, which we discussed last week.

Basically, if he is able to do this to a young girl in Claremont, seventeen, take her off the street, abduct her, have his way with her, you know, uh, that surely, as according to the prosecution, is a pre-- could be a precursor to other crimes, i.e., three young women going missing off the street from Claremont and all this happened within, you know, o- just over a two-year period.

Edwards obviously pleads guilty, but the prosecution say, "Well, it's still, it, it, it's even more relevant now because we now we know it's Mr. Edwards that has done this."

"And so we say that this evidence is, um, e- even more prevalent, hence why it's able to come in today."

I mean, essentially, Damien, I guess, is this the prosecution arguing that, um, you know, the accused has graduated from being a rapist to a killer?

Well, Nat, o- obviously, I'm in a position where I don't know the actual answer to that.

... um, a l- uh, it, it might seem obvious to a lot of people, but some people will be wondering why this evidence, um, is relevant or how, how it would come in, in-into a trial.

Um, was there any discussion about that pre these, these statements being read in? Did the court address that?

So this was- Um, just to put this in context, Mr. Edwards was originally charged with this crime, the Huntingdon crime and two, two of the murders way back in December 2016.

And basically, right up until about three weeks before the trial, he had maintained his innocence on all of those.

And then out of the blue, he, um, you know, two, three weeks before the trial, he pleaded guilty to Huntingdon, which we heard about last week, and he pleaded guilty to the rape.

But in all the pretrial sort of, um, prevarication, um, uh, the prosecutor argued for the propensity evidence, which we discussed last week.

Basically, if he is able to do this to a young girl in Claremont, seventeen, take her off the street, abduct her, have his way with her, you know, uh, that surely, as according to the prosecution, is a pre-- could be a precursor to other crimes, i.e., three young women going missing off the street from Claremont and all this happened within, you know, o- just over a two-year period.

Edwards obviously pleads guilty, but the prosecution say, "Well, it's still, it, it, it's even more relevant now because we now we know it's Mr. Edwards that has done this."

"And so we say that this evidence is, um, e- even more prevalent, hence why it's able to come in today."

I mean, essentially, Damien, I guess, is this the prosecution arguing that, um, you know, the accused has graduated from being a rapist to a killer?

Well, Nat, o- obviously, I'm in a position where I don't know the actual answer to that.
Every episode on Radar is fully transcribed, speaker-labeled, and rich with metadata. Here is a taste of this one. Try Radar for free to see the rest.
3 of 9
Guilty Pleas Before Trial
The accused changed his plea before trial.
The Escape From The Cemetery
She realized the danger was not over.
The Missing Crime-Scene Photos
Crucial crime-scene photographs have mysteriously disappeared entirely.
+6 more clips · 7 min 53 sec of audio in all
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
All 9 clips — the highlight moments, each cut as its own audio, with a title and a speaker
All 7 segments — the transcript broken into labeled sections, every ad read marked
All 25 topics — jump to every other episode discussing the same subject
Every related episode — other shows Radar links to this one
No account is needed to search Radar.