Oct 9, 2026 · 29 min · 10 segments
In this episode of the ABA Tax Section's People in Tax podcast, Shail Shah discusses his career path from federal transactional tax at EY to California state and local tax controversy, working in…
Shail ShahGuest
Priscilla ParrettHost
So I left the FTB, so right after we found out we were having twins, and I did the math in my head that, um, paying for college on a, on a government salary is gonna be, for two kids, it's gonna be pretty, pretty tough.

Uh, decided to go, uh, back into private, and I knew a few people over at Anderson, and they were looking for somebody, uh, a state and local tax, uh, especially a California-centric person up in San Francisco.

So I was, uh, at Anderson in San Francisco, um, helping sort of build out a California tax practice, uh, there, and I was there for about six years.
How was your, the work that you were doing at Anderson sort of different than what you had been doing at EY?

Um, you know, uh, so initially when I joined Anderson, there, there was not much of a controversy practice, and that was something that I sort of helped build.

Um, so initially it was a lot of sort of supporting internally a lot of the, you know, the, the individuals who were preparing returns with California-specific, or questions and sort of answering those questions.

Later on, once we were able to sort of establish a controversy practice, it, it was, a lot of the work was really similar.

I mean, it was just on the other side, right? It was drafting protests, drafting alternative apportionment, uh, petitions, um, requesting chief counsel, uh, rulings, but just being on the other side of the, of the table.

I, yeah, I joined Reed Smith, uh, the state tax practice in, in San Francisco, and, um, you know, sort of continued to do a lot of the same work, a lot of protests, a lot of, uh, appeals with, uh, was formerly the Board of Equalization and then the Office of Tax Appeal, um, settlements.

Um, so a, a, a big continuation of, of the work I was doing at Anderson, and I guess continuation of the work I was doing at Franchise Tax Board, just on the other side.
Yeah, so for those that have never either worked at a firm or worked in an accounting firm, what are the sort of differences as a tax lawyer? What are the differences in the work, if any, that you're doing at either of those places?

Yeah, I mean, it's, it's kind of interesting 'cause, you know, California has such a robust filtration system that controversies, uh, in California are resolved at the administrative level.

So in, in a lot of sense, there's not a huge difference day to day between what you're doing at a, at a law firm versus what you're doing at a, at an accounting firm.

Uh, but the biggest difference is obviously the ability to litigate an issue, right? And there are some situations where litigation is the only path for a particular taxpayer, um, because maybe it's, it's a reoccurring issue, um, it's a constitutional issue, um, or, you know, some combination of, of, of the two, and you're, you're required to, you know, to litigate, and so something you cannot do at an accounting firm.

Um, so that, that is sort of fundamentally, I think, the, the difference between the two.
What about as far as, you know, business development and bringing in work? I mean, I know obviously as a, as a partner in a firm, that's something that's expected, um, that you're going to be going out and bringing in your own clients.
At the accounting firm, is it the same for the attorneys, or is it more that you're servicing sort of larger, um, accounts for, you know, the general, the general accounting firm?

Yeah, that, that is, that is the huge difference between an accounting firm and a law firm, right? Because w- w- within an accounting firm, your federal tax group or some, some other tax group within the firm has the returns, and you have sort of the, the built-in clients.

So I left the FTB, so right after we found out we were having twins, and I did the math in my head that, um, paying for college on a, on a government salary is gonna be, for two kids, it's gonna be pretty, pretty tough.

Uh, decided to go, uh, back into private, and I knew a few people over at Anderson, and they were looking for somebody, uh, a state and local tax, uh, especially a California-centric person up in San Francisco.

So I was, uh, at Anderson in San Francisco, um, helping sort of build out a California tax practice, uh, there, and I was there for about six years.
How was your, the work that you were doing at Anderson sort of different than what you had been doing at EY?

Um, you know, uh, so initially when I joined Anderson, there, there was not much of a controversy practice, and that was something that I sort of helped build.

Um, so initially it was a lot of sort of supporting internally a lot of the, you know, the, the individuals who were preparing returns with California-specific, or questions and sort of answering those questions.

Later on, once we were able to sort of establish a controversy practice, it, it was, a lot of the work was really similar.

I mean, it was just on the other side, right? It was drafting protests, drafting alternative apportionment, uh, petitions, um, requesting chief counsel, uh, rulings, but just being on the other side of the, of the table.

I, yeah, I joined Reed Smith, uh, the state tax practice in, in San Francisco, and, um, you know, sort of continued to do a lot of the same work, a lot of protests, a lot of, uh, appeals with, uh, was formerly the Board of Equalization and then the Office of Tax Appeal, um, settlements.

Um, so a, a, a big continuation of, of the work I was doing at Anderson, and I guess continuation of the work I was doing at Franchise Tax Board, just on the other side.
Yeah, so for those that have never either worked at a firm or worked in an accounting firm, what are the sort of differences as a tax lawyer? What are the differences in the work, if any, that you're doing at either of those places?

Yeah, I mean, it's, it's kind of interesting 'cause, you know, California has such a robust filtration system that controversies, uh, in California are resolved at the administrative level.

So in, in a lot of sense, there's not a huge difference day to day between what you're doing at a, at a law firm versus what you're doing at a, at an accounting firm.

Uh, but the biggest difference is obviously the ability to litigate an issue, right? And there are some situations where litigation is the only path for a particular taxpayer, um, because maybe it's, it's a reoccurring issue, um, it's a constitutional issue, um, or, you know, some combination of, of, of the two, and you're, you're required to, you know, to litigate, and so something you cannot do at an accounting firm.

Um, so that, that is sort of fundamentally, I think, the, the difference between the two.
What about as far as, you know, business development and bringing in work? I mean, I know obviously as a, as a partner in a firm, that's something that's expected, um, that you're going to be going out and bringing in your own clients.
At the accounting firm, is it the same for the attorneys, or is it more that you're servicing sort of larger, um, accounts for, you know, the general, the general accounting firm?

Yeah, that, that is, that is the huge difference between an accounting firm and a law firm, right? Because w- w- within an accounting firm, your federal tax group or some, some other tax group within the firm has the returns, and you have sort of the, the built-in clients.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.